How Long Auto Insurance Claims Stay On Your Driving Record
How long a claim stays on your record depends on the type of claim and your state
A claim does not disappear from your record on a fixed schedule. Instead, insurance companies and state databases track claims for different lengths of time based on whether you caused an accident, filed a comprehensive claim, or had a collision. Most insurers look back three to five years when calculating your rates, but some look back longer. Your state's insurance department may keep records even after insurers stop using them.
The distinction matters because a claim you filed for theft or weather damage affects your rates differently than one filed after you caused a crash. Understanding what your insurer actually sees—and for how long—helps you predict how a claim will affect your premiums and when that effect will end.
Key Takeaways
- Collision and at-fault accident claims typically stay on your record for three to five years, though some insurers look back longer.
- Comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism) usually have less impact on rates and may drop off sooner than collision claims.
- Your state's insurance department keeps records longer than insurers do, but insurers are the ones that actually raise your rates.
- The claim itself stays in the system; what changes is whether insurers use it to price your policy.
- You can request your claims history from your insurer or your state's insurance department to see what they have on file.
Collision and at-fault accident claims: three to seven years
If you caused an accident or filed a collision claim, most insurers will use that claim to adjust your rates for three to five years. Some insurers extend this to seven years, particularly if you were at fault or if the claim was expensive. After that window closes, the claim remains in your record but stops affecting your premium calculation.
The length depends partly on your state's rules. Some states cap how far back insurers can look when setting rates. California, for example, limits most insurers to three years for accidents you caused. Other states allow longer lookback periods. Your insurer's own underwriting guidelines also matter—a company that specializes in high-risk drivers may use a longer history than one that focuses on standard drivers.
Even after the claim stops affecting your rates at one company, switching insurers does not erase it. The new insurer will see the claim in your history and may price accordingly. The claim does not disappear; the insurer straightforward stops using it in the calculation.
Comprehensive claims: typically two to five years
Comprehensive claims—for theft, vandalism, weather damage, animal strikes, or glass breakage—usually have less impact on your rates than collision claims. Most insurers look back two to five years for comprehensive claims, and many drop them from rate calculations sooner than they would an at-fault accident.
The reason is statistical: comprehensive claims are not tied to your driving behavior. An insurer cannot infer much about your future risk from the fact that hail damaged your car or someone broke your window. Because of this, some insurers barely raise your rates after a comprehensive claim, or raise them less than they would after a collision. The claim still appears in your history, but it carries less weight.
If you file multiple comprehensive claims in a short period—say, two glass claims in one year—some insurers may treat the pattern as a rate factor. But a single comprehensive claim usually ages out of rate calculations faster than a collision claim would.
Where claims live: your insurer's file versus state records
Your insurer keeps its own claims database and uses it to set your rates. Separately, your state's insurance department maintains a record of claims you have filed. These are not the same thing, and they operate on different timelines.
Your insurer's internal record is what affects your premium. Once that company decides the claim is old enough to stop using, it stops. But if you switch insurers, the new company pulls your history from the state's database or from a claims-reporting service like the Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (CLUE). That new insurer then decides how far back to look and whether to use the claim.
State insurance departments typically keep records longer than insurers use them—sometimes seven to ten years or longer, depending on the state. But the state record does not automatically raise your rates. Only your insurer does that. The state record is there if another insurer requests it.
How to find out what is on your record
You can request a copy of your claims history from your current insurer by calling or visiting their website. Most insurers will provide this at no cost. Ask specifically what they have on file and how far back they look when setting rates.
You can also request your CLUE report, which is a third-party record of claims you have filed. This report is maintained by LexisNexis and is often what new insurers see when you shop around. You can order a free CLUE report once per year at www.lexisnexis.com/clue. The report shows claims filed in the past five to seven years, depending on your state.
If you want to know your state's specific rules on how long insurers can use claims, contact your state's insurance commissioner's office or department of insurance. They can tell you the lookback period allowed in your state and whether there are exceptions for certain claim types.
What happens when a claim ages off your record
When a claim reaches the age limit your insurer uses, it stops appearing in the rate calculation. This does not mean your rates automatically drop—your insurer recalculates your premium at your next renewal, and the old claim straightforward is not part of that calculation anymore.
If you have other claims or violations on your record, your rates may still be higher than they were before any claims. But the specific impact of that one claim ends. If it was your only claim and you have a clean driving record otherwise, you should see your rates move closer to what a new customer with your profile would pay.
The timeline varies by insurer, so do not assume a claim will drop off at exactly three years or five years. Check with your insurer about their specific lookback period, or review your renewal notice to see whether the claim is still listed as a rate factor.
Shopping for insurance after a claim
Different insurers weight claims differently. One company might use a five-year lookback for at-fault accidents while another uses three years. One might charge heavily for a single claim while another spreads the impact more evenly. This is why shopping around after a claim can save money—you may find an insurer whose underwriting guidelines are more favorable to your situation.
When you get quotes from other insurers, they will see your claim history. Be honest about it; misrepresenting claims is fraud. But do not assume the first quote you get is your only option. Request quotes from at least three insurers and compare the rates they offer. An insurer that specializes in drivers with recent claims may offer better rates than your current company.
As your claim ages, your rates should improve even if you stay with the same insurer. If they do not, that is a sign to shop around. Insurers are required to recalculate rates fairly, but they do not all do it at the same pace.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a claim stay on my record forever?
No. Insurers stop using claims to set rates after a certain period—usually three to seven years depending on the claim type and insurer. The claim remains in your history, but it stops affecting your premium. State records may keep it longer, but that does not mean insurers will use it.
Will my rates go back to normal once a claim ages off?
Your rates will be recalculated without that claim at your next renewal. Whether they return to pre-claim levels depends on whether you have other claims or violations on your record. If the aged-off claim was your only issue, your rates should improve noticeably.
If I switch insurance companies, does the claim disappear?
No. The new insurer will see your claim history through state records or claims databases. They will explore their own lookback period and underwriting rules, which may be different from your old insurer's. You might pay more or less depending on how the new company weighs claims.
Can I remove a claim from my record?
You cannot remove a legitimate claim from your record. The claim is a factual event that happened. What you can do is wait for it to age off your insurer's rate calculation, or shop for an insurer that uses a shorter lookback period or weights your claim type less heavily.
How do I know if a claim is still affecting my rates?
Check your renewal notice or call your insurer and ask whether the claim is still listed as a rate factor. If it is, ask when it will age off. You can also request a detailed breakdown of what factors went into your premium calculation.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.