What To Do When an Insurance Adjuster Denies Your Claim
Why adjusters deny claims, and what that refusal actually means
An adjuster's refusal is not the end of the process — it is a decision you can challenge. Adjusters deny claims for specific reasons: the damage falls outside your policy coverage, the incident happened before your policy started, you missed a important date in your policy documents, the damage looks like wear-and-tear rather than a sudden event, or the adjuster believes you caused the damage intentionally. Sometimes the denial is correct. Often it is not, or it is only partially correct.
The refusal comes in writing, usually called a denial letter. This letter must explain why the claim was denied and which part of your policy supports that decision. Read it carefully — the reason given tells you exactly what you need to challenge. If the letter is vague or does not cite a specific policy section, that is a problem with the denial itself.
You have the right to dispute the denial. Most policies give you 30 to 60 days from the denial letter to file a formal objection, though this varies by state and by policy. The clock starts when you receive the letter, not when it was sent, so keep the envelope with the postmark.
Key Takeaways
- A denial letter must explain the specific reason and cite the policy section that supports it; a vague or incomplete letter is itself grounds to challenge the denial.
- You have 30 to 60 days from receiving the denial letter to file a formal objection with the insurance company, though the exact important date depends on your state and policy.
- Gathering evidence that contradicts the adjuster's reason — repair estimates, photos, informed statements, or proof of timely notice — is what actually changes a denial.
- If the insurance company upholds the denial after your objection, you can request independent review through your state's insurance department or pursue mediation or appraisal.
- Hiring a public adjuster or attorney becomes worthwhile when the claim amount is large enough to justify their fee, typically 5 to 10 percent of the recovery.
Reading the denial letter and identifying the real reason
The denial letter is your roadmap. It will say something like "not covered under Section 3.2" or "damage predates the policy" or "claim filed outside the 90-day notice requirement." That specific language is what you work against. If the letter says only "claim denied" with no explanation, that is a violation of your state's insurance regulations, and you should report it to your state insurance commissioner's office.
Common denial reasons and what they mean: Coverage exclusion means the type of damage your policy does not pay for — for example, flood damage if you do not have a separate flood rider, or damage from a business activity if your policy is for personal use only. Pre-existing damage means the adjuster believes the damage happened before your policy started. Failure to mitigate means you did not take reasonable steps to prevent further damage after the initial incident — for example, leaving a broken window unboarded during a storm. Intentional loss means the adjuster believes you caused the damage on purpose. Missed important date means you reported the claim after your policy's notice requirement expired.
Write down the exact reason and the policy section number. You will need both when you file your objection.
Gathering evidence that contradicts the adjuster's specific reason
The type of evidence you need depends on why the claim was denied. If the denial says the damage is pre-existing, you need proof the damage is recent: photos or video from before the incident, repair estimates dated after the incident, witness statements, or a second adjuster's assessment. If the denial says you missed the important date, you need proof you reported the claim on time: the date you called, the name of the person who took the report, or a written confirmation email.
If the denial says the damage is not covered, you need to show either that it actually is covered under your policy or that the adjuster misread the policy. This is where a second opinion matters. Get a written estimate from a licensed contractor or engineer that describes the damage and its cause. The estimate does not have to say the insurance should pay — it just has to document what happened and when. If the adjuster said the damage is wear-and-tear, a contractor's statement that the damage is sudden and accidental directly contradicts that.
Photograph everything: the damage itself, the date stamp on your phone, any visible signs of when it happened. If there were witnesses, get their names and contact information in writing. If you reported the claim by phone, call back and ask for a copy of the incident report with the date and time stamp. Insurance companies keep these records.
Filing a formal objection with the insurance company
Send a written objection to the address listed in the denial letter, not to the adjuster's email. Use certified mail with return receipt so you have proof the company received it. The objection should be short and direct: state that you are disputing the denial, explain why the adjuster's reason is wrong, and attach your evidence.
Example structure: "I received your denial letter dated [date]. You stated the claim was denied because [reason]. This is incorrect because [your evidence]. I am requesting that you reconsider and overturn this denial. Attached are [list: contractor estimate, photos, witness statement, etc.]." Keep a copy for your records.
The insurance company has 30 to 45 days to respond to your objection, though this varies by state. They will either overturn the denial, uphold it with a new explanation, or offer a partial payment. If they uphold it, ask in writing why your evidence did not change their decision. That response becomes important if you move to the next step.
When to request independent review or appraisal
If the insurance company refuses to budge after your objection, you have options that do not require hiring a lawyer. Most policies include an appraisal clause that lets you and the insurance company each hire an independent appraiser to assess the damage. The two appraisers meet, review the evidence, and if they disagree, they choose a third appraiser (called an umpire). The decision of any two of the three is binding on both you and the insurance company. Appraisal costs money — usually $500 to $2,000 total — but it is faster and cheaper than court.
You can also file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner's office. This is free. The commissioner's office will investigate whether the insurance company violated state insurance law. They cannot force the company to pay, but they can find violations and impose penalties. If the company broke the law, that finding strengthens your position if you later pursue other remedies.
Some states offer mediation through the insurance commissioner's office or through private mediators. A mediator does not decide who is right — they help you and the insurance company reach an agreement. Mediation is usually faster and cheaper than appraisal and does not require hiring professionals.
Deciding whether to hire a public adjuster or attorney
A public adjuster is a licensed professional who works for you, not the insurance company. They review the denial, gather evidence, negotiate with the insurance company, and handle the paperwork. They charge a percentage of what they recover — typically 5 to 10 percent — so they are only paid if they get you money. Public adjusters are most useful for large claims where the percentage fee is worth the cost. If your claim is under $5,000, the fee will likely eat most of the recovery.
An insurance attorney charges either a percentage (called a contingency fee, usually 25 to 40 percent) or an hourly rate. Attorneys can file a lawsuit if negotiation fails, which public adjusters cannot do. Attorneys are useful when the claim is large, the denial looks illegal, or the insurance company has a pattern of bad-faith denials. Bad faith means the company refused to pay a claim it knew was valid, or refused without a reasonable basis. Bad-faith cases can result in damages beyond the claim amount.
Before hiring either, get a free consultation. Ask what they think of the denial reason, whether they have seen similar cases, and what they think your chances are. A professional who is honest about the difficulty of your case is more trustworthy than one who promises a quick win.
Understanding bad faith and when it matters
Bad faith is when an insurance company refuses a claim knowing it should pay, or refuses without any reasonable basis. It is illegal in every state. Signs of bad faith include: the denial reason contradicts what the adjuster said in person, the company refuses to explain the denial clearly, the company ignores evidence you provided, the company misquotes your policy, or the company has a pattern of denying similar claims.
Bad faith is hard to prove, but if you can prove it, you can recover not just the claim amount but also your attorney fees, court costs, and sometimes extra damages for the company's conduct. This is why bad-faith cases matter — they are worth more than the original claim. If you think the denial might be bad faith, mention it to an attorney in your free consultation. They will tell you whether your situation meets the legal standard.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to dispute a denial?
Most policies give you 30 to 60 days from the date you receive the denial letter. Check your denial letter for the exact important date — it should be stated there. If it is not, contact the insurance company and ask. The important date varies by state and policy type, so do not assume it is the same as another claim you filed.
What if the adjuster never came to inspect the damage?
You can request a second inspection. Send a written request to the insurance company asking for a new adjuster to assess the damage. If the first adjuster's report is the only basis for the denial, a second inspection that contradicts it is powerful evidence. Document the current condition of the damage with photos and dates before the second inspection happens.
Can I record a phone call with the adjuster?
It depends on your state. Some states require both parties to consent to recording; others require only one party to know. Before you record, tell the adjuster you are recording and ask if they consent. If they refuse, do not record. Instead, take detailed notes of the call with the date, time, and what was said, and follow up with an email summarizing what you discussed.
What does it mean if the adjuster says the damage is "wear and tear"?
Wear and tear means gradual damage from normal use over time, which insurance does not cover. If the adjuster claims your damage is wear and tear, you need evidence it was sudden — a contractor's statement, photos showing it happened at a specific moment, or a witness who saw the incident. A sudden event caused by an accident or weather is covered; gradual deterioration is not.
Should I accept a partial payment while disputing the rest?
Usually yes, unless the insurance company requires you to sign a release saying you will not dispute further. If they offer partial payment without a release, take it and keep fighting for the rest. If they require a release, ask your attorney or public adjuster before signing — a release can prevent you from recovering the disputed amount later.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.