Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to File a Complaint Against an Insurance Adjuster

When and why you might file a complaint

You file a complaint against an insurance adjuster when their conduct has harmed your claim — not straightforward because you disagree with their decision about what your injury is worth. The difference matters. An adjuster can deny your claim or offer less money than you think is fair, and that is not misconduct. But if an adjuster has been dishonest, ignored evidence you provided, failed to investigate, pressured you into a settlement, or treated you in a way that violates your state's insurance laws, you have grounds to complain.

The complaint goes to your state's insurance regulator, not to the insurance company itself (though you may also complain to the company). The regulator's job is to enforce the rules that govern how adjusters must behave. A successful complaint can result in the regulator ordering the company to reopen your claim, reconsider it fairly, or pay you damages for the harm caused by the adjuster's misconduct.

Most people do not need to file a complaint. Many claim disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation, or by hiring a lawyer who can pressure the company to reconsider. But if you believe the adjuster has acted illegally or unethically, a complaint creates an official record and brings a regulator into the picture.

Key Takeaways

  • File a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner or department of insurance, not with the insurance company, when an adjuster has been dishonest, ignored evidence, or violated state insurance law.
  • You will need to document what happened: dates, names, what the adjuster said or did, and how it harmed your claim.
  • Most states allow you to file a complaint for free, and you do not need a lawyer to do it, though having one can strengthen your case.
  • The regulator will investigate and may order the company to reopen your claim, reconsider it, or pay damages if misconduct is found.
  • Filing a complaint does not stop you from also pursuing a lawsuit or hiring a lawyer to negotiate a better settlement.

Finding your state's insurance regulator

Every state has an insurance commissioner or department of insurance that handles consumer complaints. The name and structure vary by state — some call it the Department of Insurance, others the Office of the Insurance Commissioner, and a few use different titles altogether. The easiest way to find yours is to search "[your state] insurance commissioner complaint" or visit the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) website, which lists every state regulator with contact information.

Once you have found your regulator, look for a section on their website labeled "file a complaint," "consumer complaints," or "report misconduct." Most states now allow you to file online through a form on their website. Some still accept complaints by mail or phone. The website will tell you which method they prefer and what information they need from you before you start.

Do not call the insurance company's main customer service line and ask them to file a complaint on your behalf. You need to file directly with the regulator. The company has no incentive to report itself, and doing it yourself creates an official record that the regulator can investigate.

What information you need to gather before filing

Before you sit down to write your complaint, collect everything that documents what happened. This includes the date the adjuster contacted you, the adjuster's name and title, what they said or did, and how their conduct harmed your claim. Write down specific examples: "On March 15, the adjuster told me my medical records were irrelevant and refused to look at them" is far more useful than "the adjuster ignored my evidence."

Gather copies of all written communication with the adjuster: emails, text messages, letters, claim forms, and any notes you took during phone calls. If you spoke to the adjuster on the phone, write down the date, time, and what was discussed while it is still fresh. If the adjuster pressured you into a settlement or made threats, document exactly what they said. If they missed important date or failed to investigate, note the dates and what should have happened instead.

Also collect any evidence that the adjuster ignored or mishandled: medical records, repair estimates, photos of your injury or property damage, witness statements, or informed reports. You will attach these to your complaint so the regulator can see what the adjuster had access to and whether they acted reasonably.

How to write your complaint

Your complaint should be clear, factual, and organized by date. Start with a one or two sentence summary of what happened: "I filed a claim for a motor vehicle injury on January 10. The adjuster refused to review medical evidence I provided and denied my claim without investigation." Then walk through the timeline of events in order, with dates and specific details.

For each incident, explain what the adjuster did and why it violated the rules. For example: "On February 3, I sent the adjuster my medical records from Dr. Chen. On February 10, the adjuster called and said the records were 'not relevant' without explaining why. Under [your state] insurance law, adjusters must review all evidence submitted by the claimant." This shows the regulator that you understand the law and that the adjuster broke it.

Be honest about what you do not know. If you are not certain whether something was illegal, say so — the regulator will investigate. Do not exaggerate or include complaints about things that are not misconduct (like disagreeing with the adjuster's valuation of your claim). Stick to conduct that was dishonest, negligent, or violated state law. At the end, state what you want the regulator to do: reopen your claim, order a new investigation, or award damages.

Where to file and what happens next

File your complaint through your state regulator's website if they offer online filing, or by mail if that is their only option. Keep a copy for yourself and note the date you filed. Most regulators will send you a confirmation number or letter acknowledging receipt. If you do not hear back within a week, call to confirm they received it.

The regulator will then contact the insurance company and ask them to respond to your complaint. The company will usually deny wrongdoing and explain their side of the story. The regulator's staff will review both your complaint and the company's response, look at the documents you provided, and decide whether misconduct occurred. This investigation typically takes 30 to 90 days, though it can take longer if the case is complex.

If the regulator finds that the adjuster violated the law, they can order the company to reopen your claim, reconsider it fairly, or pay you damages for the harm caused. They can also fine the company or discipline the adjuster's license. If they find no violation, they will close the complaint and send you a letter explaining their decision. You can usually appeal this decision or pursue other remedies, such as hiring a lawyer to sue.

When to hire a lawyer before or alongside filing a complaint

You do not need a lawyer to file a complaint with your state regulator — it is free and the process is designed for people to use on their own. However, a lawyer can be helpful if your claim involves a large amount of money, if the adjuster's misconduct is complex, or if you want to pursue a lawsuit in addition to the complaint.

Some lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of any money you recover and charge you nothing upfront. Others charge by the hour or a flat fee. If you are considering hiring a lawyer, do so before you file your complaint, because a lawyer can make sure your complaint is as strong as possible and can coordinate it with any lawsuit you plan to file.

Filing a complaint does not prevent you from also hiring a lawyer or suing the insurance company. In fact, the existence of a complaint can strengthen your position in settlement negotiations, because it shows a regulator is investigating the company's conduct. Some lawyers will wait to see the outcome of the complaint before deciding whether to file a lawsuit.

Other remedies if the complaint does not resolve your claim

If the regulator investigates and finds no violation, or if their order does not fully resolve your dispute, you have other options. You can hire a lawyer and file a lawsuit against the insurance company for breach of contract, bad faith, or fraud — depending on what the adjuster did. You can also request mediation or arbitration, which are faster and cheaper than court but still involve a neutral third party deciding the dispute.

Some states have an insurance ombudsman, a separate office that helps consumers resolve disputes without filing a formal complaint. Others have small claims courts that handle insurance disputes under a certain dollar amount. Your state regulator's website will tell you what other remedies are available in your state.

Keep in mind that filing a complaint does not stop the clock on any important date for filing a lawsuit. Insurance companies often have strict time limits for when you can sue them — sometimes as short as one year from the date of the injury. If you are considering legal action, talk to a lawyer soon to make sure you do not miss the important date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I file a complaint if I already settled my claim?

Yes, but it depends on what you signed. If you signed a full release that says you will not pursue any further claims, the regulator may not be able to order the company to reopen your claim. However, you can still file a complaint about the adjuster's misconduct, and the regulator can investigate and potentially discipline the company or adjuster. Talk to a lawyer before settling if you think the adjuster has acted illegally.

What if the insurance company retaliates against me for filing a complaint?

Retaliation is illegal. The insurance company cannot deny your claim, cancel your policy, or treat you worse because you filed a complaint with the regulator. If this happens, document it and report it to the regulator when ready. You may also have grounds to sue the company for bad faith.

How long does it take for the regulator to investigate my complaint?

Most states complete investigations within 30 to 90 days, but it varies. Complex cases or cases with many documents can take longer. You can call the regulator to ask for a status update. Some regulators publish average investigation times on their website.

Do I have to pay to file a complaint?

No. Filing a complaint with your state insurance regulator is free. You do not need to pay any fees or hire a lawyer to do it, though a lawyer can help if you want one.

What if my complaint is about the insurance company's decision, not the adjuster's conduct?

The regulator handles complaints about how the adjuster behaved, not whether their decision about your claim was correct. If you disagree with the amount offered or whether your claim should have been denied, that is a coverage dispute, not misconduct. You would need to negotiate with the company, hire a lawyer, or pursue mediation or arbitration to resolve it.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.