When Your Insurance Claim Involves a Lawyer: What Happens With the Adjuster
What changes when you hire a plaintiff attorney
Once you hire a lawyer to represent you in an insurance claim, the adjuster stops communicating directly with you. All conversations about your claim now go through your attorney instead. This is a legal boundary — the adjuster knows they cannot contact you directly without your lawyer present, and they will redirect any contact back to your attorney's office.
This shift happens when ready after you sign a representation agreement with your lawyer. You should notify your insurance company in writing that you are now represented, and your attorney will typically do this formally. From that point forward, your attorney becomes the point of contact for all claim discussions, settlement negotiations, and document requests.
The adjuster's job does not change — they still investigate your claim, review medical records, and assess damages. What changes is who they talk to and how formal the process becomes. Written communication becomes more common than phone calls, and every statement is now part of a legal record.
Key Takeaways
- Once you hire an attorney, the adjuster must communicate only with your lawyer, not directly with you.
- Your attorney will send a formal notice to the insurance company stating they represent you and requesting all future contact go through them.
- The adjuster continues their investigation and assessment, but now exchanges documents and settlement offers through your lawyer.
- You should not discuss your claim with the adjuster, answer their questions, or sign anything without your attorney's approval.
- Settlement negotiations typically move faster once an attorney is involved, because both sides understand the legal stakes.
How the adjuster and your attorney interact
Your attorney and the adjuster now exchange information through formal channels. If the adjuster needs medical records, they send a request to your lawyer. If your lawyer needs the adjuster's investigation file or photos from the scene, they request it in writing. This creates a paper trail that protects both sides.
The adjuster will likely ask your attorney for authorizations — signed forms that allow them to obtain your medical records, employment history, or prior claims. Your attorney reviews these before you sign them, because some requests are broader than necessary. An adjuster might ask for your entire medical history when they only need records related to your injury, and your lawyer can narrow the scope.
Settlement discussions happen between your attorney and the adjuster's supervisor or the insurance company's claims manager. The adjuster may participate in these conversations, but they are no longer the decision-maker. Your attorney presents your damages — medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering — and the insurance company makes a counter-offer. This back-and-forth continues until you and your attorney decide whether to accept or reject the offer.
What you should and should not do
Do not contact the adjuster directly, even if they call or email you. Politely tell them you are represented by an attorney and give them your lawyer's contact information. Do not answer questions about your injury, your medical treatment, or how the accident happened. Do not sign anything the adjuster sends you without your attorney reviewing it first.
Do not post about your claim on social media, and be cautious about what you say to friends and family. Insurance companies sometimes monitor social media or hire investigators to photograph you or watch your activities. A photo of you hiking or playing sports can contradict your claim that you cannot work or have ongoing pain, even if the photo was taken on a good day or before your injury worsened.
Do tell your attorney about any new medical treatment, any communication from the insurance company, and any changes in your condition or work status. Your attorney needs current information to negotiate effectively. If the adjuster contacts you despite being told not to, tell your attorney when ready — this is a violation of the rules that govern insurance claims.
How long the process takes with an attorney involved
Adding an attorney typically extends the timeline, but it often results in a higher settlement. Most claims with attorney representation take three to twelve months to resolve, depending on the complexity of your injuries and the insurance company's willingness to negotiate.
The first phase is investigation and discovery. Your attorney gathers medical records, bills, and evidence of lost wages. The adjuster continues their investigation. This phase usually takes four to eight weeks. During this time, you may still be receiving medical treatment, and your attorney waits for your condition to stabilize before discussing settlement value.
The second phase is negotiation. Your attorney sends a demand letter to the insurance company outlining your damages and the amount you are seeking. The adjuster or claims manager reviews this and makes a counter-offer. Your attorney and the insurance company exchange offers back and forth. This phase can last anywhere from a few weeks to several months, depending on how far apart the initial positions are.
If you and the insurance company cannot reach agreement, your attorney may file a lawsuit. This moves the claim into the court system and typically takes longer, but it signals to the insurance company that you are serious about pursuing the claim through trial if necessary. Many claims settle once a lawsuit is filed, because the insurance company now faces attorney fees and court costs in addition to your damages.
What happens to your medical records and bills
The adjuster will request your medical records and bills as part of their investigation. Your attorney reviews these requests and decides what to provide. Some requests are reasonable — the adjuster needs to see the treatment you received and the costs you incurred. Other requests are fishing expeditions — asking for your entire medical history to find something that contradicts your claim.
Your attorney may redact information that is not relevant to your claim. For example, if you were treated for depression ten years ago and your current claim is for a broken leg, your attorney can remove those records from what you provide. This protects your privacy while still giving the adjuster the information they need to assess your claim fairly.
Medical bills are usually provided in full. The adjuster uses these to calculate your economic damages — the actual out-of-pocket costs of your injury. Your attorney may negotiate with medical providers to reduce their bills before settlement, which can increase the amount you keep from the settlement.
Understanding settlement offers and when to accept or reject
The insurance company's first offer is rarely their best offer. Your attorney will advise you on whether an offer is reasonable based on similar claims, the strength of your evidence, and the risks of going to trial. You have the final say on whether to accept or reject any offer.
Before accepting a settlement, understand what it means. Once you sign a settlement agreement, you give up the right to sue the insurance company or the at-fault party for this injury. You cannot go back later and ask for more money if your condition worsens or you need additional treatment. Your attorney will explain these consequences clearly before you decide.
Some settlements include a structured payment — money paid to you over time rather than in a lump sum. Others include a confidentiality clause, which means you agree not to discuss the settlement amount publicly. Your attorney negotiates these terms on your behalf and explains what you are agreeing to.
What happens if the adjuster denies your claim
If the adjuster denies your claim, your attorney can file an appeal with the insurance company. The appeal process varies by state and by insurance policy, but generally involves submitting additional evidence or a legal argument for why the denial was wrong. Your attorney handles this process.
If the appeal is denied, your attorney can file a lawsuit against the insurance company or the at-fault party. This moves your case into the court system. Your attorney will explain the likelihood of success and the costs involved before you decide to proceed.
Some claims are denied because the insurance policy does not cover the type of injury or accident. For example, if you were injured while committing a crime, the policy may not cover it. Your attorney can review your policy and explain whether the denial is legally sound or whether you have grounds to challenge it.
How your attorney is paid
Most plaintiff attorneys in personal injury cases work on contingency, which means they take a percentage of your settlement or court award instead of charging you an hourly fee. The percentage is typically 25 to 40 percent, depending on the complexity of your case and whether it goes to trial. You pay nothing upfront.
If your case does not settle or win at trial, you do not pay your attorney's fee. However, you may still owe costs — expenses like filing fees, medical record requests, or informed witness fees. Your attorney will explain which costs you are responsible for and when they are due.
Your attorney's fee comes out of your settlement or award before you receive your money. For example, if you settle for $50,000 and your attorney's fee is 33 percent, you receive $33,500 after the fee is paid. Medical bills and other liens may also be paid from the settlement, so your net amount may be less than the settlement figure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the adjuster still contact me if I have an attorney?
No. Once you are represented by an attorney, the adjuster must direct all communication to your lawyer. If the adjuster contacts you directly, tell them you are represented and provide your attorney's contact information. Report any direct contact to your attorney when ready.
Will hiring an attorney make the insurance company offer more money?
Often yes, because the insurance company knows your attorney will pursue the claim more aggressively and may file a lawsuit if necessary. However, the settlement amount depends on the strength of your evidence, the severity of your injuries, and what similar claims have settled for in your area. Your attorney can explain what a reasonable settlement looks like for your specific situation.
What if I disagree with my attorney about accepting a settlement offer?
You have the final decision on whether to accept or reject any settlement offer. Your attorney advises you based on their experience and knowledge of the law, but you are not required to follow their information. If you strongly disagree with your attorney's recommendation, you can seek a second opinion from another attorney or ask your current attorney to explain their reasoning in more detail.
How much of my settlement will my attorney take?
Your attorney's fee is typically 25 to 40 percent of your settlement or court award, depending on the agreement you signed and whether the case goes to trial. The fee comes out of your settlement before you receive your money. You should have received a written fee agreement when you hired your attorney that clearly states the percentage.
What if the adjuster says they cannot talk to my attorney?
This is unusual and likely a sign of a problem. Tell your attorney when ready. Your attorney can send a formal written notice to the insurance company's legal department stating that they represent you and requesting confirmation that all future communication will go through them. If the insurance company continues to violate this boundary, your attorney can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.