Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Will Filing a Car Insurance Claim Raise Your Insurance Rates

Filing a claim usually raises your rates, but not always, and the increase depends on who caused the accident and your insurer's policies

Yes, filing a claim typically results in a rate increase at your next renewal. The size of that increase varies widely—some insurers raise rates by 10 percent after a minor claim, others by 25 percent or more. But the outcome is not automatic. If someone else caused the accident and your insurer recovers money from their insurer (called subrogation), your rates may not go up. If you caused the accident, expect an increase. If you filed a claim for something other than a collision—theft, weather damage, vandalism—many insurers do not raise rates, though some do.

The real question is not whether rates go up, but by how much, for how long, and whether the payout is worth it. A $500 claim that raises your rate by $50 per month costs you $600 over the year—meaning you break even after 12 months and lose money after that. A $5,000 claim that raises rates by $100 per month takes 50 months to break even. Knowing your insurer's history with rate increases before you file helps you make that decision.

Key Takeaways

  • At-fault claims (accidents you caused) almost always raise rates; not-at-fault claims may not, depending on your insurer and state.
  • Comprehensive and collision claims for theft, weather, or vandalism often do not raise rates, though some insurers treat them differently.
  • Rate increases typically last three to five years, then drop off your record, though the claim itself stays on your history longer.
  • You can ask your insurer before filing what the estimated rate increase will be, and you can shop other insurers to see if the increase is worth staying.
  • If the other driver was at fault and their insurer pays, your rates may not rise if your insurer recovers the full amount.

How insurers decide whether to raise your rate after a claim

Insurers use a rating model that weighs your claim history against your risk profile. An at-fault accident signals that you are a higher risk than someone with no claims, so rates go up. A not-at-fault claim—one where the other driver was responsible—signals less about your driving, so many insurers do not raise rates for it. Some insurers, however, raise rates on all claims regardless of fault, so you need to know your own company's rule.

Comprehensive claims (theft, weather, vandalism, hitting an animal) and collision claims for accidents where you were not at fault often do not trigger rate increases. The logic is straightforward: these events do not reflect your driving behavior. But again, some insurers break this rule. A few raise rates on any claim that costs them money. Before you file, call your insurer and ask directly: "If I file this claim, will my rate go up at renewal?" They can tell you whether the claim will affect your rate and by roughly how much.

Your driving record also matters. If you have prior accidents or violations, a new claim lands harder. A first-time claimant with a clean record may see a smaller increase than someone filing a second claim in three years. Your age, location, vehicle type, and coverage limits all factor in too, so two people filing identical claims may see different rate changes.

How long a claim stays on your record and affects your rates

A claim typically raises your rate for three to five years, depending on your insurer and state. After that period, the rate increase usually drops off, though the claim itself remains visible on your insurance history. Some insurers explore the increase for exactly three years, then remove it at renewal. Others use a sliding scale—the increase is steeper in year one, smaller in year two, and gone by year three. A few keep the increase for five years or longer.

The claim record itself (the fact that you filed) stays in the insurance database for longer—often seven to ten years—but after the rate-increase period ends, it has less impact on your premium. This is why a claim from five years ago may still show up when you shop for insurance, but it is not actively raising your rate the way a recent claim does.

You can ask your insurer exactly how long they will explore the increase. Some will tell you the specific date it drops off. If you are near the end of that period, it may be worth waiting a few months before shopping for a new policy, since the claim's weight will be lighter once the increase period ends.

When the other driver is at fault and their insurer pays

If the other driver caused the accident and their insurer pays your claim in full, your rate may not increase. This depends on whether your insurer recovers the full amount through subrogation. When subrogation succeeds, your insurer gets reimbursed, and you are treated as though you did not file a claim—no rate increase.

The problem is that subrogation takes time and does not always succeed. The other driver's insurer may dispute fault, or the other driver may have insufficient coverage. While subrogation is pending, your insurer may still raise your rate at renewal, then lower it later if they recover the money. Ask your insurer whether they will hold off on the rate increase pending subrogation, or whether they will explore it now and adjust it later if they recover funds.

If you are in a state with no-fault insurance (like Michigan or Florida), the rules are different. You file a claim with your own insurer regardless of fault, and your rates may go up even if the other driver was responsible. No-fault states prioritize speed of payment over determining fault, so the rate consequences are the same for you either way.

Comparing the claim payout against the rate increase

Before you file, do the math. Ask your insurer for an estimate of the rate increase, then multiply that monthly increase by 12 and by the number of years it will explore. If your deductible is high enough that you are close to breaking even, filing may not be worth it.

Example: You have a $1,000 deductible and $3,000 in damage. Your insurer would pay $2,000. But they tell you the rate will increase by $75 per month for three years. That is $2,700 in extra premiums over three years. You net only $300 after the rate increase eats into the payout. In this case, paying out of pocket might be smarter.

Another example: You have a $500 deductible and $8,000 in damage. Your insurer pays $7,500. The rate increase is $40 per month for three years, totaling $1,440 in extra premiums. You net $6,060. Filing makes sense.

This calculation is especially important for minor claims. A $1,500 fender-bender that raises your rate by $50 per month costs you $1,800 over three years—you lose money. Many people file anyway because they do not do this math, or because they assume the insurer will handle it. You have the right to decline to file and pay out of pocket instead.

Shopping for insurance after a claim

If your current insurer's rate increase feels steep, get quotes from other companies. Different insurers weight claims differently. One company might raise your rate 20 percent after an at-fault accident; another might raise it 10 percent. A company that specializes in high-risk drivers may offer a better rate than your current insurer, even with the claim on your record.

When you shop, be honest about the claim. Insurers will find it in the database anyway, and lying about it can void your coverage. But do not assume every insurer will penalize you the same way. Some offer accident forgiveness programs that waive the rate increase for your first claim, or they may have loyalty discounts that offset part of the increase if you stay with them.

The time to shop is right after your claim is filed but before your renewal notice arrives. You will know the claim is on your record, and you can compare quotes with that information in hand. If you wait until after renewal, you are comparing your new (higher) rate against other companies' quotes, which is the right comparison to make.

Accident forgiveness and other ways to reduce the impact

Some insurers offer accident forgiveness, which means your first at-fault claim in a set period (usually three to five years) does not raise your rate. This is usually available only to customers with a clean record before the accident, and it often costs extra—$10 to $30 per year. If your insurer offers it and you do not have it, adding it before you file a claim can protect you. If you already have it, the claim will not raise your rate.

Bundling discounts (combining auto and home insurance) can also offset part of a rate increase. If you bundle and your rate goes up $60 per month, but you get a $20 bundling discount, your net increase is $40. Some insurers also offer usage-based discounts (programs that track your driving and reward safe behavior), which can lower your rate over time even after a claim.

The most straightforward way to reduce impact is to raise your deductible. If you increase your deductible from $500 to $1,000, your rate drops when ready, which can offset some or all of the increase from a claim. This works only if you can afford the higher deductible out of pocket.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a comprehensive claim (like theft or weather damage) raise my rate?

Most insurers do not raise rates for comprehensive claims because they do not reflect your driving. However, some do, so call your insurer before filing. If they say yes, weigh the payout against the increase the same way you would for a collision claim.

If I was hit by an uninsured driver, will my rate go up?

You would file under your uninsured motorist coverage or collision coverage, depending on your policy. Most insurers treat this as a not-at-fault claim and do not raise your rate, but confirm with your company first. If the other driver is later found and their insurer pays, your rate may be adjusted downward.

Can I file a claim without my insurer reporting it to the database?

No. All claims are reported to the insurance database (LexisNexis or similar), and other insurers can see them. You cannot hide a claim. You can choose not to file, but once you file, it is recorded.

How much does a rate usually go up after an at-fault accident?

Increases range from 10 to 40 percent depending on the insurer, your location, and your history. Some insurers are more forgiving than others. Call your insurer for a specific estimate before filing, or get quotes from competitors to see the range in your area.

If I wait a year to file a claim, will it hurt less?

No. The claim is dated when the accident happened, not when you file. If you file a year later, the claim still shows the original date. However, waiting longer makes it harder to gather evidence and witness statements, so file promptly if you decide to file at all.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.