Which Medigap Insurance Companies Sell Plans in Your State
The major Medigap insurers vary by state, and not all companies sell in all places
Medigap is sold by private insurance companies, not by Medicare itself. The largest national sellers include AARP/UnitedHealthcare, Humana, Cigna, Anthem, and Aetna, but availability depends entirely on where you live. Some states have dozens of companies offering Medigap plans; others have only a handful. A company that sells Plan G in California may not sell any Medigap product in Montana.
The plans themselves are standardized — Plan A covers the same things whether you buy from AARP or a regional carrier — but the monthly premium, customer service reputation, and underwriting rules differ between companies. You cannot assume the cheapest quote today will be the cheapest in five years, and you cannot assume a company that serves your state will continue to do so.
Finding which companies actually sell in your location is the first step. Medicare's official Medigap search tool at Medicare.gov lets you enter your zip code and see which plans and carriers are available to you right now, along with their current premiums. This is the only source you need to trust for this information.
Key Takeaways
- Use Medicare.gov's Medigap search tool to see which companies sell in your zip code — availability changes by location and changes over time.
- The standardized plans (A, B, D, G, K, L, M, N) are identical across all insurers, but premiums and customer service records vary widely.
- You have may provide issue rights during your initial enrollment window and certain life events, meaning insurers cannot deny you or charge more based on health.
- Comparing quotes from multiple companies in your area takes 15 to 30 minutes and can save hundreds of dollars per year.
- Some companies use medical underwriting outside the may provide issue window, so timing your purchase matters if you have pre-existing conditions.
How to find which companies sell Medigap in your area
Go to Medicare.gov and select "Find care providers" or search for "Medigap." Enter your zip code and the month you want coverage to start. The tool will show you every Medigap plan available in your location, the companies selling each one, and the premium for each company's version of that plan.
Print or screenshot the results. You will see that Plan G from Company A costs $150 per month while Plan G from Company B costs $180 per month for identical coverage. This difference is real and permanent — you are not paying for better service or broader networks. The plans do not have networks; they work with any provider who accepts Medicare.
If you are shopping during your initial enrollment window (the six months starting the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B), all companies must sell to you at the same rate regardless of health. Outside that window, some companies will underwrite your process, meaning they can deny you or charge more if you have diabetes, heart disease, or other conditions. This makes timing important if you have health issues.
The largest national Medigap carriers and what to know about each
AARP/UnitedHealthcare is the largest Medigap seller by enrollment. AARP membership is not required to buy their plans, though members often receive a discount. They sell in most states and offer plans A, B, D, G, K, L, M, and N. Their customer service reputation is mixed — some people report fast claims processing; others report long hold times. Premiums tend to be competitive but not always the lowest.
Humana sells Medigap in roughly 40 states and offers most plan types. They are known for stable premiums that do not increase as sharply as some competitors in later years, though initial premiums may be higher. They have a mobile app for claims and customer service, which some people find useful.
Cigna sells in about 30 states and focuses on plans G and N, which are the most common choices for new enrollees. Premiums vary significantly by state. Their underwriting outside the may provide issue window is known to be strict.
Anthem (which operates under different brand names in different states — Blue Cross Blue Shield in many regions) sells Medigap in most states. Availability and plan options vary by state. Premiums are often competitive, but customer service experiences vary widely by region.
Aetna sells Medigap in about 20 states, primarily in the Northeast and Midwest. They tend to have lower initial premiums but higher rate increases over time. Underwriting outside may provide issue is moderately strict.
Smaller regional carriers exist in most states. These companies may offer lower premiums or better customer service in your specific area, but they have less brand recognition and smaller customer bases. Check their complaint ratios with your state insurance commissioner before choosing based on price alone.
What to compare when you get quotes
Premium is the most obvious factor, but it is not the only one. Look at the rate increase history if the company publishes it — some companies raise rates 3 to 4 percent per year; others jump 8 to 10 percent. Over 20 years, this compounds significantly. You can ask the company directly what their average annual increase has been, though they are not required to predict future increases.
Check your state insurance commissioner's website for complaint ratios. This is the number of complaints filed against a company divided by the number of policies they sell. A ratio of 0.5 complaints per 1,000 policies is typical; above 1.0 is a red flag. Complaints about claims denial, billing, and customer service are the most common.
Confirm the company actually sells in your state for your age and health status. Some companies sell Plan G to people under 75 but not over 75. Some will not underwrite applicants with certain conditions. The Medicare.gov tool shows what is available to you right now, but calling the company directly to confirm they will accept your process is worth the five minutes.
Ask whether the company uses issue-age or attained-age pricing. Issue-age means your premium is locked based on your age when you buy; attained-age means it increases as you age. Attained-age plans often start cheaper but cost more over time. The company should disclose this, but you may need to ask directly.
may provide issue rights and when they matter
During your initial enrollment window — the six months starting the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B — all Medigap companies must sell you any plan at the same rate. They cannot deny you, charge more, or exclude conditions. This is called may provide issue.
may provide issue also applies if you lose employer coverage, move to a new state where your current company does not sell, or switch from a Medicare Advantage plan back to Original Medicare within 63 days of that switch. Outside these windows, companies can and do use medical underwriting.
If you have diabetes, heart disease, cancer history, or other significant conditions and you miss your may provide issue window, some companies will deny your process or charge 25 to 50 percent more than standard rates. This is legal. A few states have limited this practice, but most have not. Knowing this matters if you are considering delaying your purchase.
How to actually buy and what happens next
Once you have chosen a company and plan, you can buy directly from the company's website, by phone, or through a licensed insurance agent. Buying through an agent costs you nothing extra — the company pays the agent's commission — but make sure the agent is licensed in your state and represents multiple companies, not just one.
You will need your Medicare number, your Social Security number, and basic health information. The company will ask about recent hospitalizations, surgeries, and diagnoses. If you are within may provide issue, this information does not affect your approval or rate. If you are not, they will use it to decide whether to approve you and at what price.
Approval typically takes one to two weeks. Your coverage starts on the first of the month you requested, as long as you are approved by the 15th of the previous month. Medigap works alongside Original Medicare — you keep your Medicare card and your Medigap card, and you use both when you see a provider.
Red flags and common mistakes
Do not buy Medigap if you are enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. You cannot use both at the same time, and you will waste money. If you want to switch from Advantage to Medigap, you must first disenroll from Advantage, then buy Medigap within 63 days to keep may provide issue rights.
Do not assume the company with the lowest quote today will be the cheapest over time. A company with a history of 8 percent annual increases will cost more than a competitor with 3 percent increases within five years, even if the competitor starts higher.
Do not ignore the may provide issue window. If you miss it and develop a health condition, you may face denial or high rates. If you are unsure whether you want Medigap, buying during the window costs nothing extra and preserves your options.
Do not buy from an unlicensed agent or through a website that does not clearly identify the insurance company. Scams exist, and they typically involve collecting payment without actually enrolling you in a plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch Medigap companies after I buy?
Yes, you can switch at any time. However, if you switch outside your may provide issue window, the new company may use medical underwriting and charge more or deny you based on health. If you want to switch, do it during open enrollment (January 1 to March 31) when may provide issue applies in most states, or ask your state insurance commissioner about your state's rules.
Do all Medigap companies cover the same things?
Yes. Plan G from any company covers the same benefits as Plan G from any other company. The only differences are premium, customer service, and rate increase history. You are not paying for different coverage; you are paying for different prices and service quality.
What if a company stops selling Medigap in my state?
If your current company exits your state, you have a may provide issue right to buy from another company without medical underwriting, even if you are outside your initial enrollment window. Your state insurance commissioner can tell you which companies are still selling in your area.
Should I buy from a local company or a national one?
Neither is inherently better. Local companies sometimes have lower premiums and better local customer service; national companies sometimes have better technology and more stable rates. Compare the specific companies available in your zip code on Medicare.gov, check their complaint ratios, and choose based on price and service reputation, not size.
What happens if I cannot afford the premium?
Some states offer programs that help low-income people pay Medigap premiums, though these are limited and have strict income limits. Contact your state Medicaid office or your State Health Insurance information Program (SHIP) to learn what is available in your state. You can also choose a less comprehensive plan like Plan K or L, which have lower premiums but higher out-of-pocket costs.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.