Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Do When Your Attorney Sends You a Letter About Your Car Accident Case

What an attorney's letter means and why you received it

An attorney's letter about your car accident is usually one of three things: a response to a question you asked them, an update on what has happened in your case, or a formal notice that something has changed—like a settlement offer, a court date, or a important date you need to meet.

If you hired an attorney, they are required to keep you informed about your case in writing. If you did not hire an attorney but received a letter from one, it is usually from the other driver's insurance company's lawyer, or from a debt collector, or from the other driver themselves. The tone and content will tell you which.

Read the letter all the way through before you do anything. Many people panic at the first sentence and miss the actual point buried three paragraphs down.

Key Takeaways

  • A letter from your own attorney is a legal document you should keep in a folder with your case file, and you may need to refer back to it later.
  • A letter from the other side's attorney or insurance company is not a demand you have to answer when ready—check the letter for an actual important date.
  • If the letter asks you to do something (sign something, provide documents, appear somewhere), the important date is usually printed in bold or near the top.
  • Do not respond to a letter from the other side's attorney without talking to your own attorney first, even if you think the letter is wrong.
  • Keep the original letter and any envelope it came in, because the date it arrived may matter later.

Letters from your own attorney: what they contain and what you should do

If you hired an attorney to represent you in your car accident case, their letters to you serve as a record of what they have told you and what they are doing on your behalf. These letters often summarize conversations you have already had, confirm decisions you have made together, or explain next steps.

Common reasons your attorney writes to you include: confirming that they have filed a claim with the insurance company, telling you that the other side has made a settlement offer, notifying you of a court date or hearing, asking you to gather documents or medical records, or explaining why they recommend accepting or rejecting a settlement.

Keep every letter from your attorney in one place—a folder, a binder, or a digital file. Do not throw them away. If your case goes to court or if a dispute arises later about what was agreed, these letters are proof of what your attorney told you and when. If a letter contains a important date (for instance, "you must provide your medical records by March 15"), mark it on your calendar and meet it. Missing a important date your attorney set can harm your case.

Letters from the other side's attorney or insurance company: how to read them

A letter from the other driver's insurance company lawyer or from the other driver's attorney is different. It is not from someone working for you. These letters often sound formal and serious, and they may ask you to do something or tell you that you owe money. This is normal and does not mean you have done anything wrong.

Read the letter carefully to find out what it actually wants. Some letters are just informing you that a claim has been filed. Others ask you to provide a statement or documents. Some demand payment. A few threaten legal action. The real request is usually in the middle or near the end, not at the start.

Look for a important date. If the letter says "you must respond by [date]" or "failure to respond by [date] will result in," that is a real important date. If there is no important date written, you have more time than the letter's tone might suggest. Do not assume a important date exists just because the letter sounds urgent.

What to do if you have your own attorney

If you hired an attorney to represent you, forward any letter you receive from the other side to your attorney when ready. Do not respond to it yourself, do not call the number on the letterhead, and do not ignore it. Your attorney needs to see it and will tell you what to do next.

Your attorney may respond on your behalf, may advise you to ignore it, or may use it as part of settlement negotiations. But that is their job, not yours. Responding without your attorney's input can accidentally hurt your case or create a legal problem you did not expect.

If the letter contains a important date and you cannot reach your attorney before that important date, contact them by phone or email and tell them the important date date. Many law offices have systems to handle urgent mail, and they will prioritize it if they know the timeline.

What to do if you do not have an attorney yet

If you received a letter from the other side's attorney or insurance company and you do not have your own attorney, you have choices. You can respond yourself, you can hire an attorney to respond for you, or you can ignore the letter if it does not contain a real important date.

Before you respond, understand what the letter is asking for. If it is asking for a statement about the accident, you are not required to give one. If it is asking for medical records, you can ask them to get them from your doctor instead. If it is a settlement offer, you can accept, reject, or ask for more time to think about it.

If you are unsure whether you should respond or what you should say, a consultation with an attorney—even a short one—is worth the cost. Many attorneys offer free or low-cost initial consultations and can tell you in 15 minutes whether the letter requires action and what your options are.

Understanding settlement offers and demand letters

Two types of letters from the other side are especially important: a settlement offer and a demand letter.

A settlement offer is a proposal to end the case by paying you a certain amount of money. The letter will state the amount, what it covers (medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering), and usually a important date by which you must accept or reject it. Settlement offers often come from the insurance company's attorney. If you have your own attorney, they will advise you on whether to accept. If you do not, take time to think about it and consider whether the amount covers your actual losses. You can usually ask for more time or make a counter-offer.

A demand letter is a formal request for payment, usually sent before a lawsuit is filed. It states how much the other side believes you owe them and why. Demand letters often come with a important date—for example, "we demand payment of $5,000 by [date], or we will file a lawsuit." If you receive a demand letter and you have insurance, forward it to your insurance company when ready. If you do not have insurance and you believe the demand is unfair, this is a good time to consult an attorney.

Red flags: letters that need when ready attention

Most letters from attorneys can wait a few days while you figure out what to do. Some cannot. Contact an attorney right away if you receive a letter that includes any of these:

  • A court date or hearing date that has already passed or is coming up very soon.
  • A notice that a lawsuit has been filed against you.
  • A demand for payment with a important date fewer than 10 days away.
  • A notice that your wages or bank account will be garnished or frozen.
  • A letter saying your driver's license will be suspended.

If you see any of these, do not wait. Call an attorney the same day if possible. These situations have real important date, and missing them can result in a judgment against you, wage garnishment, or license suspension.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to respond to a letter from the other driver's insurance company?

Not always. If the letter is just informing you that a claim has been filed, you do not have to respond. If it asks you to do something—provide a statement, sign a form, or pay money—check whether there is a important date. If there is no important date and you have an attorney, let your attorney decide whether to respond.

What if the letter says something about me that is not true?

Do not respond by correcting it yourself. If you have an attorney, show them the letter and let them handle it. If you do not have an attorney and the letter contains false information that could harm you, consider hiring one to respond. A written correction from an attorney carries more weight than one from you.

Can I ignore a letter from an attorney?

If it contains a real important date and you ignore it, there can be consequences—a default judgment, a wage garnishment, or a lawsuit moving forward without your input. If there is no important date and no request for action, you can ignore it, but it is safer to show it to your attorney first.

What should I keep from the letter?

Keep the original letter and the envelope it came in. The postmark date may matter later. Do not write on the letter itself. Make a copy for your records and keep the original in a safe place with your other case documents.

What if I cannot afford an attorney to respond?

Many attorneys offer free initial consultations where they can tell you whether you need representation and what your options are. Some take cases on contingency, meaning they only get paid if you win or settle. Contact your local bar association or legal aid office for referrals to low-cost or free legal help.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.