What Boohoff Law's Track Record Shows About Commercial Vehicle Settlements
What Boohoff Law has settled in commercial vehicle cases
Boohoff Law is a personal injury firm that has handled commercial vehicle accident cases — primarily truck collisions, delivery vehicle crashes, and accidents involving vehicles used for business. Their public settlement history shows cases ranging from tens of thousands to over $1 million, though the firm does not publish a comprehensive database of all cases they have closed.
The cases they discuss publicly tend to involve serious injuries: spinal cord damage, traumatic brain injury, multiple fractures, and permanent disability. Most involve either a large commercial truck hitting a passenger vehicle, or a commercial driver operating a vehicle negligently. The settlements reflect the cost of long-term medical care, lost wages, and pain and suffering — not just emergency room bills.
What matters for your own situation is not what they settled five years ago, but what your specific injury, your state's laws, and your evidence are worth. A settlement from a similar case can give you a ballpark, but it cannot predict yours.
Key Takeaways
- Boohoff Law publishes some past settlements on their website, but these are selected cases and do not represent all cases they have handled or closed.
- Published settlements in commercial vehicle cases typically involve serious, permanent injuries and range widely depending on the injury type and state law.
- Your own case value depends on your medical records, the defendant's insurance policy limits, your state's damage caps, and the strength of liability evidence — not on what another person's case settled for.
- Settlement amounts are often confidential, so the cases you see published are not a complete picture of what the firm has recovered.
How commercial vehicle cases differ from regular car accidents
Commercial vehicles — trucks, vans, and cars used for business — are usually insured differently than personal vehicles. The insurance policy is often higher, which means more money is available to settle. The defendant may also be a company rather than an individual, which changes who you negotiate with and what records you can demand.
Commercial drivers are also held to a higher standard. If a truck driver was speeding, fatigued, or improperly trained, the company that employed them can be liable for negligent hiring or inadequate supervision. This creates more angles to prove fault and more defendants to pursue — the driver, the company, the vehicle owner, and sometimes the shipper or freight broker.
The injuries from commercial vehicle accidents tend to be more severe because of the size and weight difference. A fully loaded semi-truck weighs 80,000 pounds; a passenger car weighs 3,000 to 4,000. That physics matters in settlement value. Medical records showing permanent nerve damage, chronic pain, or lost function carry more weight in negotiation than records showing a minor sprain.
What settlement histories actually tell you
When a law firm publishes a settlement, they are showing you a case they won or negotiated well. This is not a random sample. Firms do not publish the cases that settled for less than expected, or the cases that went to trial and lost. This is called selection bias, and it means published settlements tend to be higher than the average of all cases the firm has handled.
Settlement amounts also depend heavily on state law. Some states cap non-economic damages (pain and suffering). Some states allow punitive damages (extra money meant to punish the defendant). Some states have comparative negligence rules that reduce your recovery if you were partly at fault. A $500,000 settlement in California may not be possible in a state with strict damage caps.
The insurance policy limit also sets a ceiling. If the defendant's commercial auto policy has a $250,000 limit, the settlement cannot exceed that no matter how severe your injury. Many commercial policies are higher, but not all. Your attorney will need to investigate the defendant's coverage before you know what is realistically available.
How to find information about a specific firm's cases
Most law firms publish selected settlements on their website under headings like "Case Results" or "Settlements." Boohoff Law does this. You can also search for the firm's name plus "settlement" or "verdict" to find cases they have discussed in press releases or legal databases.
Court records are public, so if a case went to trial and resulted in a judgment, you can find the verdict amount in the court docket. However, most cases settle before trial, and settlement amounts are often confidential — the agreement itself may prohibit the firm or the client from disclosing the number.
If you are considering hiring a firm, ask them directly: What is the average settlement in cases like mine? What is the range? How many cases have they closed in my state? How many went to trial versus settled? These questions will give you a better sense of their actual track record than any published case study.
What affects your settlement value more than the firm's history
The strength of liability evidence matters most. If the commercial driver ran a red light and hit you, liability is clear. If the accident happened in heavy traffic and fault is disputed, the case is worth less even if your injury is identical. Police reports, traffic camera footage, witness statements, and the defendant's own records (logbooks, GPS data, maintenance records) all shape what the case is worth.
Your medical records are the second major factor. Detailed documentation of your injury, treatment, and outcome carries far more weight than your own description. If you saw a specialist, had imaging (MRI, CT scan), underwent surgery, or required ongoing therapy, those records prove the severity. If you delayed treatment or missed appointments, the defense will argue your injury was not serious.
The defendant's insurance policy limit is a hard ceiling. If the policy is $100,000 and your damages are $500,000, you can recover the full $100,000 from insurance and then pursue the defendant personally for the rest — but personal assets are often uncollectible. Knowing the policy limit early helps your attorney set realistic expectations.
Questions to ask before hiring a firm based on their settlement history
Do not choose a firm only because they published a large settlement. Instead, ask whether they have handled cases in your state, whether they have experience with your type of injury, and what their actual success rate is. Ask how they charge (contingency, hourly, or a combination) and what happens if the case does not settle as hoped.
Ask whether they will handle the case themselves or refer it to another firm. Some firms take cases and then pass them to specialists, which can delay your case and add confusion about who is actually representing you. Ask what communication you can expect — will you hear from them weekly, monthly, or only when there is news?
Most importantly, ask what they think your case is worth and why. A firm that gives you a realistic range based on your specific facts is more trustworthy than one that points to a published settlement and says "yours could be similar." Every case is different.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a law firm's published settlement mean my case will settle for the same amount?
No. Published settlements are selected cases, usually the firm's best outcomes. Your case value depends on your injury severity, the strength of liability evidence, the defendant's insurance limits, and your state's laws — not on what another person's case settled for. A firm should evaluate your specific facts before predicting a range.
Are settlement amounts public record?
Not always. Verdicts from trials are public. Settlement amounts are often confidential under the agreement between the parties. This means the cases you see published are not a complete picture of what a firm has recovered — only the cases they chose to disclose.
What if the commercial vehicle driver's company has a low insurance limit?
You can pursue the company personally for damages beyond the policy limit, but collecting from a business is difficult and expensive. Your attorney will investigate the defendant's assets and insurance before advising whether to pursue a judgment. In many cases, the policy limit is all that is realistically recoverable.
How long does a commercial vehicle settlement usually take?
It varies widely. straightforward cases with clear liability may settle in months. Complex cases involving multiple defendants, serious injuries, or disputed fault can take one to three years. Your attorney should give you a timeline based on your specific case, not on how long other cases took.
Should I hire a firm because they have a big settlement history?
Settlement history is one factor, but not the most important one. Choose a firm that has handled cases in your state, understands your type of injury, communicates clearly, and gives you a realistic assessment of your case value. A firm with smaller published settlements but strong local experience may serve you better than one with impressive national cases.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.