Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Finding Buffalo Car Accident Lawyers With Strong Track Records

What verdict history actually tells you about a lawyer

A lawyer's highest verdict is not the same as their typical result, and it is not a promise about what your case will be worth. Verdicts are what juries award in cases that go to trial — most car accident cases settle before trial for less money, sometimes significantly less. A single large verdict can come from an unusual set of facts: a catastrophic injury, a defendant with deep insurance coverage, a sympathetic plaintiff, or a jury in a particular mood on a particular day.

What matters more than the headline number is the lawyer's pattern: Do they take cases to trial, or do they settle most of them? How often do they win at trial? What types of injuries do they typically handle? Do they have experience with the specific kind of accident you had — a rear-end collision, a truck accident, a pedestrian hit, an intersection crash? A lawyer who has won three large verdicts in catastrophic spinal cord cases may not be the right fit for a soft-tissue injury case, and vice versa.

Verdict databases and lawyer websites will show you the big numbers, but they will not show you the cases that settled quietly or the cases the lawyer lost. That incomplete picture is why you need to ask direct questions about their actual settlement and trial rates, not just their best day in court.

Key Takeaways

  • The highest verdict a lawyer has won tells you what is possible in an unusual case, not what your case is likely to be worth.
  • Most car accident cases settle before trial, so a lawyer's settlement history and negotiation skill matter more than trial verdicts alone.
  • You can find verdict information through the New York State Unified Court System records, legal databases, and lawyer websites, but you should verify any claims directly with the lawyer.
  • When comparing lawyers, ask about their trial rate, their settlement rate, their experience with your specific type of accident, and what percentage of their cases involve injuries similar to yours.
  • A lawyer with one very large verdict may have less overall trial experience than a lawyer with several moderate verdicts, so context matters more than a single number.

Where verdict information comes from in New York

New York State publishes civil court decisions through the Unified Court System, and these records are searchable by judge, court, and case type. However, the public database does not include all verdicts — it includes published decisions, which are typically cases that set legal precedent or involve novel issues. Most car accident verdicts are routine and are not published, so they will not appear in the state system.

Lawyer websites and legal databases like Justia, Google Scholar, and VerdictSearch maintain their own collections of verdicts, but these are voluntary submissions. A lawyer may choose to publish their largest wins and not publish their losses or smaller settlements. This creates a skewed picture. Some law firms subscribe to VerdictSearch or similar services and use those databases to research what comparable cases have been worth, but those databases are not free and are not complete.

The most reliable way to learn about a specific lawyer's track record is to ask them directly: request a list of cases similar to yours, ask for references from past clients, and ask what percentage of their cases go to trial versus settle. A lawyer who is confident in their record will provide this information.

Questions to ask when you contact a lawyer

Do not ask only "What is your highest verdict?" Instead, ask these questions in order:

  • What percentage of your car accident cases go to trial, and what percentage settle? This tells you whether the lawyer is comfortable taking cases to a jury or prefers to negotiate settlements. Neither is wrong, but you should know which type of lawyer you are hiring.
  • Of the cases that go to trial, what is your win rate? A lawyer who wins 60% of trials is different from one who wins 80%, and both are different from one who has tried only two cases.
  • Have you handled cases like mine — the same type of accident and the same type of injury? A lawyer experienced in truck accidents may not have handled many pedestrian cases, even if they have tried many cases overall.
  • What is the typical settlement range for a case like mine? This is more useful than the highest verdict, because it reflects what actually happens in cases similar to yours.
  • Can you provide references from clients with injuries similar to mine? Past clients can tell you whether the lawyer communicated clearly, met important date, and fought for them or pushed them toward a quick settlement.

A lawyer who gives you specific numbers and is willing to explain their reasoning is more trustworthy than one who says "every case is different" and refuses to discuss their track record. Every case is different, but patterns exist, and a good lawyer knows their own patterns.

Red flags when researching lawyer claims

Be skeptical of any lawyer who claims to have won "millions" without context. Millions in a case involving a permanent disability and a defendant with substantial insurance is different from millions in a case involving minor injuries. The injury, the defendant's insurance limits, and the jurisdiction all matter enormously.

Watch for lawyers who list verdicts from other lawyers in their firm as if they were their own. Some websites will say "Our firm has recovered $X" when only one or two lawyers in the firm actually tried those cases. Ask which lawyer on the team will actually handle your case and what that specific lawyer's record is.

Be wary of testimonials that sound scripted or generic. A real client review usually includes specific details — the lawyer returned calls, the settlement took longer than expected, the lawyer explained the process clearly. A review that says only "great lawyer, highly recommend" with no detail is often written by the firm itself.

If a lawyer's website shows a verdict from 2010 but nothing more recent, that is a sign they may not be trying cases anymore. Ask when their most recent trial was and what the outcome was.

How Buffalo courts and juries affect verdict amounts

Erie County juries (which includes Buffalo) have a reputation in the legal community for being more conservative than juries in some other New York counties. This means verdicts in Buffalo tend to be lower than verdicts for similar cases in New York City or Long Island. A lawyer who has won large verdicts in Buffalo has done so against that headwind, which is worth noting. A lawyer who has won large verdicts only in other counties may not have as much experience with the specific jury pool you will face.

The judge assigned to your case also matters. Some judges are more favorable to plaintiffs, some to defendants. A lawyer familiar with the judges in the Erie County Supreme Court and the Civil Court can tell you what to expect and how to prepare. This local knowledge is harder to quantify than a verdict amount, but it is often more valuable.

Settlement negotiations versus trial verdicts

Most car accident cases settle in the weeks or months before trial. The settlement amount is usually less than what a jury might award, but it is certain — you do not have to risk a jury finding you partly at fault or awarding less than you hoped. A lawyer's skill at negotiation often matters more than their trial record, because that is where most of your case will be decided.

Ask a lawyer not only about their trial verdicts but also about their settlement strategy. Do they negotiate early and often, or do they wait until trial is imminent? Do they use mediation or arbitration to resolve cases? Do they have relationships with insurance adjusters and defense counsel that help move cases forward? A lawyer who settles most cases for reasonable amounts may be more valuable to you than a lawyer who takes every case to trial and wins big in a few of them.

How to verify a lawyer's credentials and history

Start with the New York State Bar Association. You can search for any lawyer licensed in New York and see their disciplinary history, if any. A clean record does not mean the lawyer is good, but a history of complaints or discipline is a warning sign. The Bar Association website is nysba.org, and the lawyer lookup tool is free.

Check the lawyer's membership in professional organizations. Membership in the American Association for Justice (formerly the Association of Trial Lawyers of America) or the New York State Trial Lawyers Association suggests the lawyer is active in trial work. These organizations have membership requirements and continuing education standards.

Look for peer recognition. Lawyers listed in Best Lawyers in America, Super Lawyers, or similar publications have been vetted by other lawyers or by independent research. These lists are not perfect — they are partly based on self-nomination — but they are a useful filter. A lawyer who appears in multiple peer-recognition lists has a stronger track record than one who does not.

Ask for the lawyer's CV or biography. A good biography will list the lawyer's years of experience, the types of cases they handle, any notable cases or verdicts, and their education and bar admissions. If a lawyer will not provide this, that is a red flag.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I find all of a lawyer's verdicts online?

No. Only published decisions appear in public databases, and most car accident verdicts are not published. Lawyer websites may show their largest wins but not their losses or smaller settlements. The only way to get a complete picture is to ask the lawyer directly and request references from past clients.

Does a lawyer with a $5 million verdict necessarily charge more than one with a $500,000 verdict?

Not necessarily. Contingency fees (where the lawyer takes a percentage of the settlement or verdict) are usually set by contract, often at 33% for cases that settle and 40% for cases that go to trial. The verdict amount affects how much money you receive, not the percentage the lawyer takes. Always ask about the fee structure in writing before you hire anyone.

What if I cannot find much information about a lawyer's verdicts?

Many good lawyers do not advertise their verdicts heavily, especially if they handle mostly settlements. Ask the lawyer directly for their settlement and trial history, and ask for client references. A lawyer's willingness to answer these questions honestly matters more than their online presence.

Should I hire the lawyer with the highest verdict?

Not automatically. The lawyer with the highest verdict may have tried only a few cases, may specialize in catastrophic injuries that do not match yours, or may not be available for your case. Look for a lawyer with consistent results in cases like yours, not just one big win.

How do I know if a verdict claim on a lawyer's website is real?

Ask the lawyer for the case name, the court, and the year. You can then search the court records yourself or ask the lawyer to provide documentation. Any lawyer should be able to back up their claims with public records.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.