Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

Finding a Car Accident Attorney Who Will Take Your Case to Trial

What "trial experience" actually means when you're looking for a car accident lawyer

Trial experience means the attorney has stood in front of a judge or jury and argued a case from start to finish — not just settled it beforehand. This matters because most car accident cases do settle, but yours might not. If the insurance company won't offer fair money, or if liability is genuinely disputed, you need someone who knows how to build a case for court, not just negotiate in an office.

When you call an attorney and ask about trial experience, listen for specifics: How many car accident cases have they tried? In what courts? How recently? An attorney who tried cases ten years ago but hasn't been in a courtroom since is different from one who goes to trial twice a year. You're looking for someone who does this regularly enough that they know the judges, the local rules, and what juries in your area actually respond to.

The reason this matters to you right now is straightforward: insurance adjusters know which attorneys will actually go to trial and which ones won't. If your lawyer has a reputation for settling everything, you'll get a lower offer. If they have a reputation for being ready to try cases, the offers tend to be higher because the insurance company knows backing you into a corner will cost them more.

Key Takeaways

  • Trial experience means the attorney has actually argued cases in front of judges or juries, not just settled them — ask how many car accident cases they've tried and when.
  • Most car accident cases settle, but you need a lawyer prepared to go to trial if the insurance offer is too low or liability is disputed.
  • Insurance companies offer more money to claimants represented by attorneys known for taking cases to trial.
  • Local bar associations, state court records, and attorney review sites can show you who has real trial experience in your area.
  • The initial consultation should cover what your case would look like at trial, not just what settlement might be possible.

How to find attorneys with trial experience in your area

Start with your state bar association's website. Most state bars have a "find a lawyer" tool where you can search by practice area and location. Some also let you filter by whether the attorney is certified as a specialist in personal injury or civil trial work — this certification usually requires proof of trial experience and continuing education. Your state bar can also tell you if complaints have been filed against an attorney and how they were resolved.

Next, check your county courthouse records. Many courts now have searchable databases of recent cases. Search for car accident cases (often listed as "motor vehicle" or "auto negligence") and look at the attorney names. If you see the same attorney's name appearing in multiple trial verdicts, they're actually trying cases. Court records are public, and you can often see the outcome and the judge's name, which gives you real information instead of marketing language.

Ask your primary care doctor, your employer's HR department, or friends who have been through accidents for referrals. Personal referrals from people who actually hired the attorney are worth more than any online review, because they can tell you whether the attorney returned calls, explained things clearly, and fought for them or just pushed them toward a quick settlement.

What to ask during your first conversation

When you call, ask directly: "How many car accident cases have you tried to verdict in the last three years?" Listen for a number. If they say "I've tried many" or "I'm very experienced," that's not an answer — ask again. You want to know if it's two cases or twenty.

Then ask: "If we can't reach a fair settlement, are you prepared to take my case to trial?" Some attorneys will say yes when ready. Others will hedge or ask more questions first, which is fine — they're being honest that they need to know more about your case. But if they seem reluctant or start talking about how expensive trial would be, that's a signal they prefer to settle and may not push hard for you.

Ask about the specific judges in your county. A good trial attorney will know which judges are fair, which ones are skeptical of certain arguments, and what they expect in a courtroom. If the attorney can't talk about the judges by name, they probably don't try cases in your county regularly.

Finally, ask what your case would look like at trial. A trial-ready attorney can walk you through what evidence matters, what the other side will argue, and what a jury might award. If they can't or won't have that conversation, they're not thinking about trial as a real possibility.

Understanding the difference between settlement and trial

Settlement is faster and more predictable. You and the insurance company agree on a number, you sign paperwork, and you get paid within weeks. There's no risk of a jury deciding your case is worth less than you hoped. Most people settle because it's simpler and because they need money now, not months from now.

Trial is slower and uncertain. You'll wait months or longer for a court date. You'll have to testify and relive the accident. The jury might award you more than any settlement offer, or they might award you less. But trial is the only option if the insurance company's offer doesn't cover your actual losses — your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

An attorney with trial experience will be honest about which path makes sense for your case. If your injuries are minor and the insurance offer is reasonable, they might recommend settling. If your injuries are serious and the offer is low, they should be ready to prepare for trial and explain what that means for your timeline and costs.

What trial experience costs you and what it saves you

Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover — typically 33 percent if the case settles and 40 percent if it goes to trial. The higher percentage for trial reflects the extra work and risk the attorney takes on. You don't pay anything upfront.

Trial also means costs: informed witnesses, court filing fees, deposition transcripts, and investigation. These costs come out of your settlement or verdict, not from your pocket. Your attorney should explain these costs upfront and tell you what they expect to spend. Some attorneys will advance these costs; others will ask you to pay them as you go.

What you save by having a trial-ready attorney is often much larger than what you pay them. Insurance companies know which attorneys will actually go to trial, and they offer more money to those attorneys' clients. A lawyer who has tried ten car accident cases will likely get you a higher settlement offer than a lawyer who has tried none, even if both are equally skilled at negotiation. That difference in the offer often exceeds what you'll pay in attorney fees and trial costs.

Red flags that an attorney may not have real trial experience

Be cautious if an attorney's website or marketing focuses heavily on "getting you the most money" or "we fight for you" without mentioning specific cases, verdicts, or trial experience. Marketing language is cheap; trial experience is specific and verifiable.

Be cautious if the attorney seems to push you toward settling quickly without discussing what trial would look like. Some attorneys have high volume practices where they settle hundreds of cases a year for modest amounts. That works for them financially, but it may not work for you.

Be cautious if the attorney can't name recent judges they've tried cases in front of or recent verdicts they've won. If they've actually tried cases, they should be able to talk about them (within confidentiality limits).

Be cautious if the attorney discourages you from asking questions or seems annoyed when you want details. A good trial attorney expects you to ask hard questions and respects you for doing so.

How to verify an attorney's trial record

Ask the attorney directly for references from past clients who went to trial. They should be willing to provide at least two or three names of people who authorized them to share contact information. Call those people and ask what the trial experience was like, whether the attorney prepared them well, and whether they felt heard.

Search your county courthouse database for the attorney's name and look at recent verdicts. Many courts publish verdict amounts and the judge's name. If you see the attorney's name in multiple verdicts over the last few years, that's strong evidence of trial experience.

Check whether the attorney is listed in legal directories like Martindale-Hubbell or Best Lawyers, which require verification of experience and peer review. These directories aren't perfect, but they do require some proof of what they claim.

Ask the state bar whether the attorney has any disciplinary history. A few complaints are normal; a pattern of complaints about dishonesty or failure to communicate is a warning sign.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a trial attorney if I think my case will settle?

Most cases do settle, but you won't know that until you're deep into the process. Hiring an attorney who is prepared for trial — even if you settle — means you'll get a better settlement offer because the insurance company knows you're serious. It's like having a strong negotiating position from day one.

What if the attorney I want to hire hasn't tried many car accident cases?

Ask whether they've tried other types of civil cases and whether they're willing to work with a trial consultant or co-counsel who specializes in car accidents. Some good attorneys are newer to trial work but are willing to learn and prepare thoroughly. What matters most is whether they're honest about their experience and willing to get help if they need it.

How long does a car accident case take if it goes to trial?

From the accident to trial verdict typically takes one to three years, depending on how backed up your local courts are and how complex the case is. Settlement usually happens much faster — within six months to a year. Your attorney should give you a realistic timeline based on your county's court schedule.

Can I switch attorneys if the one I hired doesn't seem trial-ready?

Yes, though it's better to get it right the first time. If you realize your attorney isn't prepared for trial and you want one who is, you can fire them and hire someone else. You'll need to sign a new fee agreement, and the new attorney will need time to get up to speed on your case. It's not ideal, but it's possible.

What should I expect to pay in trial costs?

Trial costs vary widely depending on how complex your case is. straightforward cases might cost $2,000 to $5,000 in informed fees and court costs. Complex cases with multiple experts can cost $10,000 or more. Your attorney should give you an estimate after reviewing your case and explain which costs they'll advance and which you might need to cover.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.