Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Compare Trial Experience When Choosing a Car Accident Attorney

What trial experience actually means when you are choosing a car accident attorney

Trial experience does not mean an attorney has tried every kind of case or won every trial. It means they have stood in front of a judge or jury, presented evidence, cross-examined witnesses, and handled the unpredictable moments that happen when a case goes to court instead of settling. An attorney with trial experience has felt the rhythm of a courtroom, knows how judges in your specific county tend to rule, and can estimate what a jury in your area might award for your type of injury.

Most car accident cases settle before trial — somewhere between 85 and 95 percent, depending on the state and the insurance company involved. But the fact that settlement is likely does not mean trial experience is unimportant. Insurance adjusters know which attorneys will actually try a case, and that knowledge changes the settlement offer. An attorney who has never tried a case has less leverage in negotiation, because the adjuster knows the attorney will probably accept a lower offer rather than risk trial.

When you are comparing attorneys, trial experience is one factor among several — not the only one. An attorney with 20 years of trial experience but poor communication skills may not serve you well. An attorney with moderate trial experience but deep knowledge of your state's insurance laws and local court procedures may be more valuable. The question is not "who has tried the most cases" but "does this attorney have enough trial experience to credibly threaten trial, and enough local knowledge to do it well."

Key Takeaways

  • Trial experience means an attorney has actually presented cases in court before a judge or jury, not just settled cases or handled paperwork.
  • Insurance companies offer higher settlements to attorneys with a visible trial history, because they know the attorney will actually go to court if the offer is too low.
  • You can ask an attorney directly how many car accident cases they have tried in the past five years, and in which courts, and they should give you a specific number.
  • An attorney with moderate trial experience in your county's courts is often more valuable than one with extensive trial experience in other states or counties.
  • Trial experience matters most if your case involves serious injury, disputed liability, or an insurance company known for low settlement offers.

How to ask about trial experience without being misled

When you call or meet with an attorney, ask this specific question: "How many car accident cases have you tried to a verdict in the past five years?" A verdict is a decision by a judge or jury — it means the case actually went to trial and ended with a ruling, not a settlement before trial. This number tells you whether the attorney regularly tries cases or mostly settles them.

Listen for the difference between "tried" and "handled." An attorney who says "I have handled thousands of car accident cases" may have settled most of them without ever stepping into a courtroom. An attorney who says "I have tried 47 car accident cases to verdict in the past five years" is giving you a real number you can evaluate. If an attorney is vague or says something like "I try cases when necessary," that usually means they do not try many cases and may not be comfortable in court.

Ask where those trials took place. If an attorney tried cases in your county's courts, they know the judges, the local rules, and how juries in your area typically value injury claims. If they tried cases in other states or counties, that experience is less directly useful to you, though it still counts as trial experience. You can also ask whether they have tried cases in front of the specific judge assigned to your case, if you know who that is.

Trial experience varies widely by attorney and by state

Some attorneys try 20 or 30 cases a year. Others try two or three. Some have tried hundreds of cases over a 30-year career. Others have been practicing for 15 years and tried fewer than 10 cases. There is no national standard for what counts as "experienced" — it depends on the attorney's practice style, the types of cases they take, and the local court system they work in.

In rural counties, an attorney with 15 trials might be considered highly experienced because the court system is smaller and fewer cases go to trial. In a large urban county, an attorney with 15 trials might be considered less experienced because the volume of cases is much higher. When you compare attorneys, compare them within the same county or region, not across the country.

Some attorneys specialize in trial work and take cases specifically because they expect to try them. Others specialize in settlement negotiation and take cases they believe will settle quickly. Neither approach is wrong — it depends on what your case needs. If your case is strong and the insurance company is being unreasonable, you want an attorney who is comfortable and skilled at trial. If your case is weaker or you need money quickly, an attorney with strong settlement skills might serve you better, even if they have less trial experience.

What to look for beyond the raw number of trials

The number of trials an attorney has done matters, but it is not the only measure of trial readiness. Ask whether they have tried cases similar to yours — a car accident case with a serious injury, or a case involving a disputed liability question, or a case against the specific insurance company you are dealing with. An attorney who has tried 50 cases but none involving serious spinal injury may be less prepared for your case than an attorney who has tried 15 cases, three of which involved serious spinal injury.

Ask what the outcomes were. Did they win or lose? By how much? This is harder information to get — some attorneys are reluctant to discuss losses — but it matters. An attorney who has tried 30 cases and won 25 has a different track record than one who tried 30 and won 10. You are not looking for a perfect record (no attorney has one), but you are looking for evidence that they win more often than they lose.

Ask whether they have tried cases in front of juries or only in front of judges. Jury trials and bench trials (judge only) are different skills. Some attorneys are excellent with juries but less comfortable with judges, or vice versa. If your case is likely to go to jury trial, you want an attorney with jury trial experience. If it is likely to go to a judge, judge trial experience matters more.

How trial experience affects settlement negotiations

Insurance adjusters know which attorneys try cases and which ones do not. When an adjuster receives a demand letter from an attorney with a strong trial record in the local courts, the adjuster takes the threat of trial seriously. That seriousness translates into a higher settlement offer. When an adjuster receives a demand letter from an attorney with no trial history, the adjuster knows the attorney is less likely to actually go to trial, and the offer reflects that.

This dynamic is one reason trial experience matters even in cases that will probably settle. You do not need to actually try your case for trial experience to help you — you just need the adjuster to believe you will try it if the settlement offer is not reasonable. An attorney with visible trial experience creates that belief. An attorney without it does not.

The effect is strongest in cases involving serious injury or disputed liability, where the potential damages are high enough to make trial a real possibility. In a minor injury case where the damages are small, trial experience matters less because the cost of trying the case would exceed the potential recovery. But in any case where significant money is at stake, trial experience affects the settlement offer.

Red flags when an attorney discusses trial experience

Be cautious if an attorney claims to have tried "hundreds" of cases but cannot name specific cases, judges, or courts. Real trial experience is specific and verifiable. An attorney who has tried many cases should be able to describe a few of them in detail — what the injury was, what the liability question was, what the outcome was, which judge or jury decided it.

Be cautious if an attorney says they "always" win or have a "perfect" trial record. No attorney wins every case. If someone claims they do, they are either not trying many cases, or they are not being truthful about the outcomes. A realistic attorney will tell you they win most of their cases but have lost some, and will be able to discuss what they learned from the losses.

Be cautious if an attorney refuses to discuss their trial record or says it is "confidential." Trial outcomes are public record — they are filed in the courthouse and anyone can look them up. An attorney who will not discuss their record is either hiding something or does not have much of a record to discuss.

Trial experience in your specific county matters most

When you are comparing attorneys, prioritize trial experience in your county's courts. An attorney who has tried 30 cases in your county knows the judges, knows how they rule on motions, knows what evidence they allow, and knows what juries in your county typically award for your type of injury. An attorney who has tried 100 cases but all in other counties does not have that local knowledge.

You can ask the attorney which judges in your county they have appeared before, and how many times. You can ask whether they know the judge assigned to your case and what that judge's tendencies are. An attorney with deep local experience can give you specific, useful answers. An attorney without it will give you general answers or admit they do not know.

If you live in a small county with few attorneys, you may not have many options for trial experience. In that case, look for an attorney with trial experience in nearby counties, or one who is willing to bring in a co-counsel with stronger trial credentials. Some attorneys partner with trial specialists when a case is likely to go to court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an attorney need trial experience to handle my car accident case?

Not necessarily. Most car accident cases settle, and an attorney with strong settlement negotiation skills may serve you well even without extensive trial experience. But if your case involves serious injury, disputed liability, or an unreasonable insurance company, trial experience becomes more important because it gives the attorney credibility in settlement negotiations.

How many trials should an attorney have done before I hire them?

There is no magic number. In a small county, 10 to 15 trials might indicate solid experience. In a large urban county, 30 to 50 trials might be the baseline for "experienced." What matters more is whether they have tried cases similar to yours, in your county, and whether they won more often than they lost.

Can I look up an attorney's trial record myself?

Yes. Court records are public. You can visit your county courthouse or access the court's online database and search for cases the attorney has tried. You will see the case name, the judge, the outcome, and sometimes the verdict amount. This is a good way to verify what an attorney tells you about their trial experience.

What if the attorney I want to hire has no trial experience?

Ask whether they are willing to bring in a co-counsel with trial experience if your case goes to court. Some attorneys do this routinely. You can also ask whether they have a relationship with a trial specialist they refer cases to. If they have neither option and your case looks like it might need trial, consider finding a different attorney.

Does trial experience in a different state count?

It counts as evidence that the attorney can handle a courtroom, but it is less valuable than experience in your state and county. Laws differ by state, judges differ, juries differ, and local court procedures differ. An attorney with trial experience in your county is more useful than one with the same number of trials in another state.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.