Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Find a Car Accident Attorney With a Track Record of Trial Success

What "trial wins" actually means when you're looking for a car accident attorney

A car accident attorney with trial wins has taken cases to court and won verdicts in front of a judge or jury—not just settled them beforehand. This matters because it shows the attorney has experience presenting evidence, cross-examining witnesses, and arguing your case when the insurance company won't offer a fair settlement. Trial experience is different from settlement experience: an attorney who settles most cases may be skilled at negotiation, but you won't know whether they can hold their ground in a courtroom if negotiations break down.

When you're researching attorneys, "trial wins" usually means the attorney has a public record of jury verdicts or bench trial judgments in their favor. This is verifiable information—you can look it up through court records, bar association databases, and the attorney's own website. Not every case needs to go to trial, and most don't, but knowing your attorney has won at trial gives you leverage in settlement talks because the insurance company knows you're not bluffing about being willing to fight.

Key Takeaways

  • Trial experience means the attorney has actually presented cases in court and won verdicts, which is different from settling cases before trial.
  • You can verify trial wins through court records, state bar association websites, and attorney review sites that cite specific verdicts.
  • An attorney's trial record should match your injury type—a win in a spinal cord case matters more for your case than a win in a minor whiplash case.
  • Settlement rates and trial records both matter: an attorney who settles 95% of cases may be excellent, but you need to know they can also win when a case goes to court.
  • References from past clients and peer ratings from other attorneys are more reliable than marketing claims about "winning" or "success rates."

Where to find verifiable information about an attorney's trial record

Start with your state bar association's website. Most state bars maintain a public directory where you can search for attorneys and see disciplinary history, but not all publish trial records there. The next step is to search the attorney's name plus "verdict" or "jury award" on Google, which often surfaces press releases or legal databases that track verdicts. Sites like Justia, Google Scholar (scholar.google.com), and PACER (Public Access to Court Electronic Records) let you search federal and state court records directly.

Ask the attorney directly for a list of trial verdicts they've won in the past three to five years. A reputable attorney will have this information ready and will tell you the case name, the year, the injury type, and the verdict amount. If they're vague or say they don't track this, that's a red flag. You can also call the courthouse where they practice and ask the clerk's office for records of cases they've tried—this is public information and courthouse staff can point you toward the right database.

Attorney review sites like Avvo, Super Lawyers, and Best Lawyers sometimes list trial records or note that an attorney has trial experience, but these sites vary in how they verify information. Read the reviews themselves rather than relying on star ratings. Look for reviews from people who actually went to trial, not just people who settled. A review that says "my attorney took my case to trial and won" is more useful than a generic five-star rating.

How to evaluate whether an attorney's trial wins match your situation

Not all trial wins are equal. An attorney who won a $2 million verdict in a catastrophic spinal cord injury case has different experience than one who won a $50,000 verdict in a minor soft tissue case. Look at the injury type first: if you have a traumatic brain injury, you want to see trial wins in traumatic brain injury cases, not just any car accident case. If your case involves a commercial truck, you want an attorney with trial experience in truck accident cases, because those have different liability rules and insurance limits than passenger vehicle accidents.

Look at the verdict amounts in relation to the injuries. A $500,000 verdict for a broken arm is a strong win; a $100,000 verdict for the same injury might suggest the attorney faced a tough jury or weak evidence. You can't know the full story from the number alone, but you can ask the attorney to explain the verdict and what made it successful. Ask what percentage of their cases go to trial—if it's less than 5%, they may not have much trial experience despite a few wins.

Ask about losses too. No attorney wins every trial. An attorney who has lost cases and can talk honestly about what went wrong and what they learned is often more trustworthy than one who only lists wins. Ask how many trials they've done in the past five years. Someone who has tried 20 cases and won 18 has more trial experience than someone who has tried 2 cases and won both.

Questions to ask an attorney about their trial experience

When you meet with an attorney, ask these specific questions: "How many car accident cases have you taken to trial in the past three years?" "What was the outcome of those trials?" "Have you tried cases involving injuries similar to mine?" "What's your settlement rate, and why do cases settle versus go to trial?" "If my case goes to trial, who will be the lead attorney presenting it—you or someone else in your firm?" "What's your experience with the judges in this county?" and "Can you walk me through what happened in one of your recent trial wins?"

Listen to how they answer. A good attorney will give you specific numbers, will name the judges, and will be honest about both wins and losses. If they spend most of the conversation talking about how good they are at settling rather than trying cases, ask directly whether they're comfortable taking your case to trial if needed. Some attorneys are genuinely better at settlement negotiation than trial work, and that's okay—but you need to know which type you're hiring.

Red flags when researching an attorney's trial record

Be skeptical of vague claims like "award-winning attorney" or "top trial lawyer" without specific verdicts attached. Be skeptical of websites that list dozens of verdicts without dates or case names—these are often inflated or outdated. If an attorney claims a 95% or higher success rate, ask what "success" means. Does it include cases that settled for less than the client hoped? Does it count cases dismissed before trial?

Avoid attorneys who pressure you to decide quickly or who promise a specific outcome. No honest attorney can may provide a verdict amount or even a win. Be cautious of attorneys who advertise heavily on billboards or late-night TV—advertising spend doesn't correlate with trial skill. If you can't find any information about an attorney's trial record after searching court records and asking directly, that's a sign they may not have much trial experience, even if they claim to.

How trial experience affects your settlement negotiations

Insurance companies know which attorneys have trial experience and which don't. When your attorney has a strong trial record, the insurance adjuster knows that if they lowball your offer, your attorney might actually take the case to trial and win. This knowledge often leads to better settlement offers before trial ever happens. An attorney without trial experience may get lower offers because the adjuster knows the attorney is unlikely to follow through on a threat to go to court.

This doesn't mean every case with a trial-experienced attorney will settle for more money. Settlement depends on the strength of your evidence, the severity of your injuries, and the insurance policy limits. But trial experience gives your attorney credibility in negotiations, which matters. If your case does go to trial, you want an attorney who has done it before and knows how to present your case effectively to a judge or jury.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does an attorney with more trial wins always get better settlements?

Not always. Settlement amounts depend on the strength of your evidence, your injuries, and the insurance policy limits. But an attorney with trial experience often negotiates better settlements because insurance companies take them seriously. Trial wins show the attorney can back up their demands in court if needed.

What if I can't find any trial verdicts for an attorney I'm considering?

Ask the attorney directly for their trial record. If they've tried cases, they should be able to tell you about them. If they say they don't track verdicts or have very few trials, ask whether they're comfortable taking your case to trial if settlement talks fail. Some attorneys focus on settlement work, which is fine—but you need to know that upfront.

How recent should an attorney's trial wins be?

Recent wins (within the past three to five years) are more relevant because laws, jury attitudes, and insurance practices change. An attorney with a big win from 15 years ago may not have tried many cases since. Ask about their trial activity in the past few years specifically.

Can I find trial records myself, or do I need to hire the attorney first?

You can search court records yourself through your state court website, Google Scholar, or PACER. You can also call the courthouse clerk and ask for cases tried by a specific attorney. This is public information and you don't need to hire anyone to access it.

What does it mean if an attorney has trial wins but mostly in cases different from mine?

It means they have courtroom experience, which is valuable, but they may not have specific experience with your injury type or accident circumstances. Ask whether they've handled cases similar to yours and whether they'd bring in a co-counsel with more specialized experience if needed.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.