What a Broken Bone from a Car Accident Means for Your Claim
Why a broken bone changes what your claim is worth
A broken bone from a car accident is not the same as soft tissue damage in how the law treats it. The injury is documented clearly — X-rays, CT scans, medical records with dates and healing timelines all exist in writing. That documentation makes your damages easier to prove to an insurance company or a court. A broken arm, leg, rib, or collarbone also typically means higher medical bills, longer recovery, and lost wages, which all add up to a larger claim value.
The reason you might need an attorney is not the break itself, but what happens next. Insurance companies know that fractures are provable, so they often move faster on settlement offers — but those offers are frequently lower than what the injury actually costs you over time. An attorney's job is to make sure the number reflects your real expenses and your real recovery time, not just what the insurer wants to pay.
Key Takeaways
- Broken bones create a clear paper trail through medical imaging and records, which makes your damages easier to document than soft tissue injuries.
- Insurance companies often settle fracture claims faster but at lower amounts, so knowing your actual costs — medical, lost wages, and ongoing care — matters before you accept an offer.
- An attorney can request your full medical file, imaging results, and treatment plans to build a complete picture of what the injury cost you.
- The value of your claim depends on the bone, the break type, whether surgery was needed, and how long recovery took — not just the fact that something broke.
What documentation you need to gather now
Start collecting records as soon as you can, even if you have not yet decided whether to hire an attorney. The hospital or urgent care where you were treated will have your initial X-rays, the radiologist's report, and the doctor's notes from that visit. Request these in writing — do not wait for them to be mailed; ask for digital copies so you have them when ready. The report will say what broke, where, and how severe the fracture is (straightforward, compound, comminuted, or other classifications that matter to your claim).
Next, collect every follow-up visit: orthopedic specialist appointments, physical therapy records, imaging done weeks or months later to check healing progress, and any surgical reports if you had surgery. Keep receipts for out-of-pocket costs — crutches, braces, pain medication, transportation to appointments, home care help. Write down the dates you missed work and how much you lost in wages. If you had to turn down a job offer or miss school, document that too. Insurance companies will ask for all of this, and having it organized before you talk to them puts you in a stronger position.
How an attorney values a broken bone claim
An attorney does not use a single formula. Instead, they look at the specific break and what it cost you. A straightforward fracture of the wrist that healed in eight weeks with a cast is valued differently than a compound fracture of the femur that required surgery, months of physical therapy, and left you unable to work for six months. The type of bone matters — a broken ankle that affects your ability to stand for your job is worth more than the same break would be for someone who works at a desk.
The calculation includes medical expenses (all bills, past and future), lost income (wages you did not earn during recovery and any reduced earning capacity if the injury affects your work long-term), and pain and suffering (which varies by state and by how the injury changed your daily life). An attorney will also look at whether the break caused complications — infection, improper healing, permanent weakness, or chronic pain — because those extend the value of the claim significantly.
Insurance companies use their own formulas, which is why their first offer is often much lower. An attorney's job is to show why your specific situation justifies a higher number, using your medical records, your lost wages, and informed opinions if needed.
When you should talk to an attorney before settling
If the insurance company has already made you an offer, do not accept it yet if you have not had a conversation with an attorney. Many attorneys offer free initial consultations where they will review your medical records and the offer side by side and tell you whether the number is reasonable. This takes an hour and costs you nothing. If the offer is significantly lower than what your actual expenses and recovery time suggest, an attorney can usually recover far more than their fee will cost.
You should also talk to an attorney if the insurance company is denying part of your claim, saying the break was pre-existing, or arguing that you caused the accident. These are disputes that require legal knowledge to resolve. Similarly, if you are still in active treatment — still in physical therapy, still unable to work — an attorney can help you understand what your claim might be worth once healing is complete, rather than settling now for an amount based on incomplete recovery.
What happens if you hire an attorney
Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, which means they take a percentage of what you recover — usually 25 to 40 percent depending on the state and whether the case goes to trial. You pay nothing upfront. The attorney will request your medical records directly from providers, obtain the police report, get statements from witnesses if there are any, and request the insurance company's file on your claim. They will also order your lost wage documentation from your employer.
Once the attorney has everything, they send a demand letter to the insurance company that lays out exactly what the injury cost you and what they believe the claim is worth. The insurance company then has time to respond — usually 30 days. Many cases settle at this stage. If not, the attorney can file a lawsuit, which moves the case into court. Most broken bone cases still settle before trial, but the lawsuit threat often moves the insurance company to a higher offer.
What the insurance company will ask you
Expect detailed questions about your medical history before the break, your current health, and whether you have had similar injuries. They will ask for authorization to speak to your doctors and to see your full medical file — not just records related to the accident. This is legal, and you have to provide it. They may also ask you to be examined by a doctor they hire, called an independent medical examination or IME. You cannot refuse, but you can have your attorney present.
The insurance company will also investigate the accident itself — how it happened, who was at fault, and whether you did anything that contributed to the crash. If they find evidence that you were partially at fault, your claim value will be reduced by your percentage of fault. This varies by state; some states bar you from recovering anything if you are more than 50 percent at fault, while others allow partial recovery. An attorney knows your state's rules and can argue about fault allocation on your behalf.
How long this process takes
If you are still in active treatment, most attorneys will wait until you have finished healing or reached what doctors call maximum medical improvement — the point where further treatment is unlikely to improve your condition. This can take months. Once treatment is complete, the attorney sends the demand letter, and the insurance company has 30 days to respond. Negotiation can take weeks or months. If the case goes to lawsuit, it typically takes 6 to 18 months to reach trial, though most settle before then.
The timeline also depends on how busy the court is in your area and how complex the case is. A straightforward broken arm with clear liability usually moves faster than a case where fault is disputed or where the break caused complications that are still being treated.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will I have to go to court if I hire an attorney?
Most broken bone cases settle without going to trial. Your attorney will negotiate with the insurance company, and if they reach an agreement, you sign a settlement and the case closes. Court is only necessary if settlement talks fail and your attorney decides to file a lawsuit. Even then, many lawsuits settle before trial begins.
What if the insurance company says the break was my fault because I was speeding?
Fault for the accident and the severity of your injury are separate questions. Even if you were speeding, the other driver may still bear responsibility for how they hit you. An attorney can argue about fault allocation and may hire an accident reconstructionist to show how the collision happened and who caused it. Your state's laws determine whether partial fault reduces your recovery.
Can I still hire an attorney if I already accepted a settlement?
Once you sign a settlement agreement and release, you generally cannot reopen the case or sue again for the same injury. This is why it is important to talk to an attorney before accepting any offer. If you have already settled and believe the amount was too low, an attorney can review the agreement to see if there are any grounds to challenge it, but options are limited.
How much will an attorney cost me?
Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, so you pay nothing unless you recover money. If you win or settle, the attorney takes a percentage — typically 25 to 40 percent of what you receive. Some attorneys also charge for costs like medical records requests or informed reports, which come out of your recovery. Ask about this in your first conversation.
What if I have health insurance that already paid for my treatment?
Your health insurance company may have a right to reimbursement from your settlement, called a lien. This means part of what you recover goes back to the insurance company to cover what they paid. Your attorney handles these negotiations and will work to reduce the lien amount. You still keep the rest of your settlement.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.