When and Why You Might Need a Trial Attorney After a Car Accident
What a trial attorney does after a car accident
A trial attorney is a lawyer who represents you in court if your car accident claim goes to trial. Most accident claims settle before trial—your insurer and the other driver's insurer negotiate a payment, and you sign a release. But if the two sides cannot agree on fault, injury value, or damages, the case moves to court, and a trial attorney presents your case to a judge or jury.
Trial attorneys handle the legal work that settlement negotiations do not: filing court documents, gathering evidence that proves your version of events, cross-examining the other driver's witnesses, and arguing why you deserve the damages you are seeking. They also know the rules of evidence—what testimony and documents a judge will allow—and how to present your case in a way that persuades a jury.
The key difference between a trial attorney and a settlement negotiator is courtroom experience. Many personal injury lawyers focus on settling cases quickly. Trial attorneys specialize in taking cases all the way through trial, which requires different skills and preparation.
Key Takeaways
- A trial attorney represents you in court if your accident claim does not settle and a judge or jury will decide the outcome.
- You typically hire a trial attorney only after settlement talks have stalled, not when ready after the accident.
- Trial attorneys charge on contingency (they take a percentage of what you win) or hourly rates, depending on the agreement you make.
- The decision to go to trial is expensive and time-consuming; your attorney should explain the costs and odds before you commit.
- Not all personal injury lawyers regularly try cases in court, so you need to confirm trial experience before hiring.
When you need a trial attorney instead of a settlement lawyer
You do not need a trial attorney when ready after an accident. Most cases settle during the claims process or during pre-trial negotiations. You hire a trial attorney only when settlement talks have broken down and both sides agree (or a court orders) that the case will go to trial.
The signs that trial may be necessary include: the other driver's insurer denies fault entirely, the two sides disagree sharply on how much your injuries are worth, the other driver was uninsured or underinsured and you need to pursue your own coverage, or liability is unclear (for example, both drivers claim the other ran a red light). If your personal injury lawyer has been negotiating for months and the gap between what you are asking and what the insurer is offering has not narrowed, trial may be the only way forward.
Some lawyers handle both settlement and trial work. Others specialize in one or the other. If your current lawyer does not regularly try cases, they may refer you to a trial attorney at this stage. This is normal and does not mean your first lawyer failed—it means the case has moved into a different phase that requires different informed.
How trial attorneys charge for their work
Trial attorneys typically work under one of two fee arrangements: contingency or hourly.
On contingency, the attorney takes a percentage of the money you win at trial—usually 25 to 40 percent, though this varies. You pay nothing upfront and nothing if you lose. The attorney covers the costs of filing, informed witnesses, and court preparation out of their own pocket, betting that they will win and recoup those costs plus their fee from the judgment. Contingency is common in car accident cases because it aligns the attorney's interest with yours: they only make money if you win.
On an hourly rate, you pay the attorney for every hour they work on your case, whether you win or lose. Hourly rates for trial attorneys range widely depending on location and experience, but trial work is expensive because preparing for and conducting a trial takes many hours. You may also pay a retainer—a lump sum upfront—that the attorney draws from as they bill hours.
Before you hire a trial attorney, ask which fee structure they use and get the terms in writing. If they work on contingency, confirm what percentage they take and whether they deduct costs (informed fees, filing fees, court reporters) before or after calculating their cut.
What happens during a car accident trial
A trial typically unfolds in stages. First, both sides present opening statements—your attorney explains your version of events and what you will prove, and the other side does the same. Then your attorney presents your case: witnesses testify (including you), documents and photos are entered as evidence, and informed witnesses (like accident reconstructionists or medical doctors) explain technical details.
The other side then presents their case and cross-examines your witnesses, trying to poke holes in your story. Your attorney cross-examines their witnesses in return. After both sides rest, each attorney makes a closing argument—a final pitch to the judge or jury about why their client should win.
The judge or jury then deliberates and reaches a verdict. If you win, the court issues a judgment ordering the other driver (or their insurer) to pay you a specific amount. If you lose, you receive nothing, and you may have the right to appeal—a process where a higher court reviews whether the trial was conducted fairly.
Trials are unpredictable. Even strong cases can lose if a jury does not connect with your testimony or if the other side's informed is more persuasive. Your trial attorney should discuss the risks honestly before you commit to going to court.
The costs and timeline of going to trial
Going to trial is expensive and slow. Even on contingency, you may pay costs upfront: filing fees (typically $200 to $500), informed witness fees ($1,000 to $5,000 or more per informed), court reporters ($300 to $500 per day), and deposition costs (questioning witnesses before trial). These add up quickly.
The timeline is also long. From the moment you hire a trial attorney to the day a verdict is reached, expect 12 to 24 months or longer, depending on the court's schedule and case complexity. During this time, you are waiting for resolution while managing your injuries and medical bills.
Before you decide to go to trial, your attorney should give you a realistic estimate of costs and timeline. They should also explain the range of outcomes—what you might win, what you might lose, and what a settlement offer looks like compared to the risk of trial. If the math does not make sense (for example, if trial costs $20,000 and the difference between the settlement offer and what you might win is only $5,000), settling may be the wiser choice.
How to find and hire a trial attorney
If your current personal injury lawyer does not try cases regularly, ask them for a referral to a trial attorney. They often have relationships with specialists and can make an introduction. You can also search your state bar association's website for attorneys who list trial experience, or contact your local bar association's lawyer referral service.
When you meet with a trial attorney, ask about their trial record: How many car accident cases have they tried? What was the outcome? Do they have experience with cases similar to yours? Ask for references from past clients if possible. A trial attorney should be willing to discuss their experience and answer your questions.
Before you sign a fee agreement, make sure you understand the costs, the fee structure, and what happens if you lose. Get everything in writing. A good trial attorney will also be honest about whether your case is strong enough to justify the time and expense of trial, even if it means recommending settlement instead.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch lawyers if my settlement attorney will not go to trial?
Yes. If your attorney believes the case should settle and you want to pursue trial, you can hire a different attorney. You will need to sign a substitution of counsel form, and your new attorney will take over the case. Make sure your first attorney transfers all documents and files to your new one.
What if I lose at trial and owe the other side money?
In most car accident cases, the loser does not pay the winner's attorney fees or costs—each side bears their own. However, if the judge finds that your case was frivolous or brought in bad faith, they may order you to pay some of the other side's costs. Your attorney should discuss this risk before trial.
How much can I expect to win if my case goes to trial?
There is no fixed amount. A jury considers your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages. The verdict depends on the strength of your evidence, how the jury views your credibility, and how persuasive the other side's defense is. Your attorney can estimate a range based on similar cases, but no outcome is may provide.
Do I have to testify if my case goes to trial?
Usually yes. You are the person who experienced the accident and your injuries, so your testimony is central to your case. Your attorney will prepare you for cross-examination by the other side's lawyer, but you will need to take the stand and answer questions under oath.
What happens if the other driver does not have insurance?
If the other driver is uninsured, you may pursue a claim under your own uninsured motorist coverage (if you have it) or sue the driver directly. A trial attorney can explain which route makes sense in your situation and whether the other driver has assets worth pursuing.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.