What Hit and Run Restitution Means and How It Works
Hit and Run Restitution: What You Need to Know
Restitution in a hit and run case is money the court orders the at-fault driver to pay to cover the victim's losses — vehicle damage, medical bills, lost wages, and sometimes pain and suffering. It is separate from any criminal penalty the driver faces; restitution goes directly to the person harmed, not to the state. The court decides the amount based on documented losses, and the driver must pay it as part of their sentence or as a condition of probation.
The key difference between restitution and a civil lawsuit is who collects it. In criminal court, the judge orders restitution as part of the case outcome. In civil court, you sue the driver yourself and keep whatever you win. Many victims pursue both — the criminal case for restitution and a civil case for damages the criminal court did not cover, like pain and suffering.
Key Takeaways
- Restitution is ordered by a criminal court judge and requires the at-fault driver to pay the victim for documented losses like medical bills and vehicle repair costs.
- You do not have to file a separate lawsuit to receive restitution — the prosecutor's office handles presenting your losses to the judge.
- Restitution covers actual out-of-pocket expenses but typically does not include pain and suffering unless your state law specifically allows it.
- The driver's ability to pay does not prevent a restitution order, though it may affect how fast you receive the money.
- If the driver does not pay, you can ask the court to enforce the order through wage garnishment, asset seizure, or other collection methods.
How Restitution Gets Ordered in Criminal Court
When a hit and run case goes to criminal court, the prosecutor represents the state, not you. However, you have the right to submit a victim impact statement or a list of your losses to the court. This document should include receipts, medical records, repair estimates, and any other proof of what the crash cost you.
After the driver is convicted or pleads guilty, the judge holds a sentencing hearing. At this hearing, the prosecutor presents your losses, and the judge decides whether to order restitution and in what amount. You may be allowed to speak directly to the judge about your losses. The judge is not required to order restitution for every loss you claim — they order only what the evidence supports and what the law in your state allows.
The restitution order becomes part of the sentence. The driver must pay it on a schedule set by the court, often monthly. If they do not pay, the court can enforce it the same way it enforces child support or other financial obligations.
What Losses Restitution Can Cover
Restitution covers economic losses — costs you can prove with receipts or bills. This includes vehicle repair or replacement, medical treatment, prescription medications, physical therapy, and lost wages if you missed work because of injury. Some states also allow restitution for transportation costs while your vehicle was being repaired, or for rental car expenses.
What restitution typically does not cover is pain and suffering — the emotional harm or reduced quality of life from the crash. A few states allow judges to order restitution for pain and suffering in hit and run cases, but most do not. That is why many victims also file a civil lawsuit: the civil court can award pain and suffering damages that the criminal court cannot.
You must document every loss with receipts, invoices, medical records, or pay stubs. The judge will not order restitution for amounts you cannot prove. If you have insurance that covered some of your losses, the judge may reduce the restitution order by that amount, depending on your state's law.
The Difference Between Restitution and a Civil Lawsuit
Restitution and a civil lawsuit are two separate paths, and you can pursue both. In the criminal case, the judge orders restitution as part of sentencing. In a civil case, you sue the driver in civil court and ask a judge or jury to award you damages.
The advantage of restitution is that you do not have to hire a lawyer or file a separate lawsuit — the prosecutor's office presents your case. The disadvantage is that restitution is limited to what the judge thinks is fair based on the evidence, and you cannot recover pain and suffering in most states. A civil lawsuit gives you more control and the chance to recover broader damages, but it costs money upfront and takes longer.
If you win both restitution and a civil judgment, you cannot collect the same loss twice. For example, if restitution covers your medical bills, you cannot also collect those bills in the civil case. However, you can collect pain and suffering in the civil case even if the criminal court did not award it in restitution.
Collecting Restitution When the Driver Cannot Pay
The court does not require the driver to have money in order to order restitution. A judge can order a driver with no job and no assets to pay restitution, and the obligation stays in place until it is paid. However, collecting from someone with no income is difficult.
If the driver does not pay, you can ask the court to enforce the restitution order. Common enforcement methods include wage garnishment (the court takes money from the driver's paycheck), bank account seizure, driver's license suspension, or placing a lien on property the driver owns. Some states also allow the court to extend the restitution important date or reduce the monthly payment if the driver's financial situation changes.
You do not have to wait passively. Contact the prosecutor's office or the court's restitution unit and ask them to file a motion to enforce. Provide proof that the driver has not paid — copies of the restitution order and records showing no payments received. The court will then hold a hearing and decide what enforcement action to take.
Your Role as a Victim in the Criminal Case
You are not a party to the criminal case — the state is. The prosecutor decides whether to charge the driver and what charges to bring. However, most states give you the right to be notified of court dates, to submit a victim impact statement, and to speak at sentencing about your losses and how the crash affected you.
Contact the prosecutor's office that is handling the case and ask to speak with the victim advocate or the prosecutor assigned to your case. Provide them with all documentation of your losses: repair estimates or invoices, medical bills, records of missed work, and receipts for any out-of-pocket expenses. The earlier you provide this information, the more time the prosecutor has to present it to the judge.
You also have the right to ask the court to order restitution. If the prosecutor does not mention your losses at sentencing, you can ask to speak or submit a written statement. The judge is not required to follow your request, but judges often do when the losses are clearly documented.
Restitution and Your Insurance Claim
If you filed a claim with your own insurance company, they may have already paid for your losses. Your insurance company may then pursue subrogation — the legal right to recover what they paid from the at-fault driver. This means your insurance company may have a claim against any restitution the driver is ordered to pay.
Check your insurance policy and ask your claims adjuster whether they plan to subrogate. If they do, the restitution money may go partly to your insurance company and partly to you, depending on what your policy says and what your state law allows. In some cases, your insurance company will wait for the criminal restitution to be paid before they pursue their own claim.
This does not prevent you from also filing a civil lawsuit. However, you cannot recover the same loss twice — if your insurance company recovers $5,000 in subrogation, you cannot also recover that $5,000 in a civil judgment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get restitution if the hit and run driver is never found?
No. Restitution is ordered only after someone is convicted or pleads guilty. If the driver is never identified or caught, there is no criminal case and no restitution order. However, you may be able to file a claim with your own insurance company under your uninsured motorist coverage, which covers losses from drivers who cannot be identified.
What if the driver pleads guilty but the judge does not order restitution?
You can ask the judge to reconsider at sentencing, or you can file a civil lawsuit. Some judges order restitution only for certain losses or only if the victim requests it. If the judge declines to order restitution, you still have the right to sue the driver in civil court for all your documented losses.
How long does it take to receive restitution after the driver is sentenced?
It depends on the payment schedule the judge sets and whether the driver actually pays. Some drivers pay in full when ready; others pay monthly over years. If the driver does not pay, you may have to ask the court to enforce the order, which adds time. There is no standard timeline.
Can restitution be ordered if the driver is found not guilty?
No. Restitution is part of the sentence and can only be ordered after a conviction or guilty plea. If the driver is acquitted, there is no criminal sentence and no restitution. You would then need to file a civil lawsuit to recover your losses.
Do I need a lawyer to get restitution?
No. The prosecutor's office handles presenting the case to the judge, and you can submit your losses in writing or speak at sentencing yourself. However, a lawyer can help you document your losses, prepare your victim statement, and enforce the restitution order if the driver does not pay.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.