How Insurance Companies Investigate and Pay Hit-and-Run Claims
What happens when you file a hit-and-run claim with your insurance company
When you report a hit-and-run to your insurance company, they will assign a claims adjuster to investigate whether the other driver can be identified. The adjuster will request the police report, review your vehicle damage, interview you about what you saw, and check whether any witnesses or nearby cameras recorded the incident. If the other driver is never found, your claim moves into a different payment track than a normal accident — one that depends on what coverage you carry.
The key distinction is whether you have uninsured motorist coverage (UM) or uninsured motorist property damage coverage (UMPD). These are optional add-ons in most states, and whether you have them determines whether your own insurance pays for the damage or whether you must pay out of pocket. If you do not have either, your insurance company will deny the claim, and you would need to pursue the other driver through small claims court if you ever identify them.
The investigation itself typically takes two to four weeks, though it can extend longer if the adjuster is waiting for police records or video footage from nearby businesses. During this time, your claim remains open and you cannot settle it.
Key Takeaways
- Hit-and-run claims require your insurance company to investigate whether the other driver can be identified before they decide whether to pay.
- Uninsured motorist coverage (UM) covers your medical bills and lost wages if you have uninsured motorist property damage coverage (UMPD) covers the vehicle itself, but these are optional add-ons you must have purchased before the accident.
- If the other driver is never found and you lack UM or UMPD coverage, your insurance company will deny the claim and you will bear the cost yourself.
- You must report the hit-and-run to police and provide your insurance company with the police report number to file a claim.
- If you later identify the other driver, you can reopen your claim and pursue them through their insurance instead.
Why the police report matters to your insurance company
Your insurance company will not pay a hit-and-run claim without a police report. This is not a company policy — it is a requirement written into most state insurance codes. The police report serves as third-party documentation that the accident happened, that you were not at fault, and that you made a good-faith effort to identify the other driver.
When you call the police non-emergency line to report a hit-and-run, you will receive a report number. Some police departments provide the full written report when ready; others mail it or make it available online within a few days. You must obtain this report and give the report number to your insurance company before they will open an investigation. Without it, they can deny your claim outright.
The police report also becomes evidence if you later identify the other driver and need to prove they caused the damage. If you skip the police report and try to file a claim later, your insurance company will question whether the accident actually happened and may refuse to pay.
What uninsured motorist coverage actually covers in a hit-and-run
Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage pays for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering if you are injured in a hit-and-run. It does not pay to fix your car. The coverage limit is usually between $25,000 and $100,000 per person, depending on what you selected when you bought the policy.
To use UM coverage for a hit-and-run, you must meet two conditions: you must have been injured, and the police must have filed a report. Some states also require that the other vehicle actually made contact with yours — a sideswipe counts, but a near-miss does not. Your insurance company will ask for medical records, bills from treatment, and proof of lost income to calculate what they owe you.
UM coverage is separate from your medical payments coverage (MedPay), which pays medical bills regardless of fault and does not require a police report. If you have both, MedPay usually pays first and UM covers anything above that limit.
What uninsured motorist property damage coverage covers
Uninsured motorist property damage (UMPD) coverage pays to repair or replace your vehicle after a hit-and-run. It works like collision coverage but applies only when the other driver cannot be identified. The coverage limit is usually equal to your vehicle's actual cash value, and you pay a deductible (typically $500 to $1,000) out of pocket before the insurance company pays the rest.
UMPD is not available in all states — it is optional in some and not offered at all in others. If your state does not offer it and you do not have collision coverage, you have no way to recover vehicle damage from a hit-and-run through insurance. You would have to pay for repairs yourself or pursue the other driver in small claims court if you identify them later.
When you file a UMPD claim, the insurance company will inspect your vehicle, get repair estimates, and either pay the repair shop directly or reimburse you after you pay. The process is the same as a collision claim, except the adjuster must first confirm that the other driver was never identified.
How insurance companies investigate to find the other driver
The adjuster assigned to your claim will take several concrete steps to try to identify the other driver. They will review the police report for any witness statements or descriptions of the other vehicle. They will ask you detailed questions: what color was the car, what make and model, what direction did it go, what time of day, were there any identifying marks or damage to it. They will also ask whether you saw the license plate, even partially.
If the accident happened in a parking lot or on a street with nearby businesses, the adjuster may contact those businesses to request security footage. Some will cooperate; others will not without a subpoena. The adjuster can request a subpoena through the police department or through their company's legal team, but this takes time and is not always successful.
The adjuster will also check whether any other insurance claims were filed for damage to another vehicle at the same time and location. If someone else reported hitting your car, their claim becomes evidence that the other driver exists and can be identified.
If after two to four weeks of investigation the other driver has not been found, the adjuster will close the investigation and move forward with paying your claim under UM or UMPD coverage — or denying it if you do not have either.
What happens if you identify the other driver later
If you identify the other driver weeks or months after the accident, you can reopen your claim and pursue them through their insurance company instead of your own. This is called subrogation — your insurance company pays your claim first, then tries to recover the money from the other driver's insurance.
To reopen a claim, contact your adjuster with the other driver's name, insurance company, and policy number. Your insurance company will then file a claim against their policy. If the other driver's insurance accepts liability, they will reimburse your company. If they deny it, your insurance company may pursue a lawsuit, though they will only do this if the amount is large enough to justify the cost.
If you identify the other driver but do not have UM or UMPD coverage, you can file a claim directly against their insurance company yourself, or you can pursue them in small claims court for the damage amount. You do not need a lawyer for small claims court, and the filing fee is usually under $100.
Why some hit-and-run claims are denied
The most common reason for denial is that you do not have uninsured motorist coverage or uninsured motorist property damage coverage. If your policy includes only liability and collision, collision will not pay for a hit-and-run because collision covers accidents you cause or accidents where the other driver is identified. A hit-and-run with an unidentified driver falls outside both categories.
A second reason for denial is that you did not file a police report. Without one, your insurance company has no way to verify that the accident happened or that you made a good-faith effort to find the other driver. Some people skip the police report because they think it will raise their rates or because they are in a hurry, but this choice will cost them the entire claim.
A third reason is that the adjuster determines the accident did not actually occur — for example, if you cannot describe the other vehicle, if no witnesses corroborate your account, or if the damage pattern does not match a hit-and-run. This is rare but does happen when someone files a fraudulent claim.
A fourth reason, in some states, is that the other vehicle did not make physical contact with yours. Some state laws require actual contact for a hit-and-run claim to may have access to for UM coverage. If another car swerved into you and you both swerved to avoid each other but did not touch, that may not count as a hit-and-run in your state.
How hit-and-run claims affect your rates and record
Filing a hit-and-run claim under UM or UMPD coverage usually does not raise your insurance rates because you were not at fault. Your insurance company may not even report it to the insurance score databases that other companies use to set rates. However, it will appear on your claims history, which some insurers review when you renew or switch companies.
The accident itself will appear on your driving record because it was reported to police, but again, because you were not at fault, it should not affect your rates. If you are worried about rate increases, contact your insurance agent and ask directly whether this specific claim will trigger a premium change.
If you file multiple hit-and-run claims in a short period, some insurance companies may become suspicious and investigate more thoroughly or even drop you as a customer. This is rare but can happen if you file three or more claims in two years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to file a police report to claim a hit-and-run?
Yes. Your insurance company will not pay a hit-and-run claim without a police report number. Call the non-emergency police line, report the accident, and ask for the report number. You will need this number when you contact your insurance company.
What if I did not get the other driver's license plate?
You can still file a claim. The adjuster will investigate using the vehicle description, witness statements, and any available video footage. If the other driver is never identified, your claim will be paid under UM or UMPD coverage if you have it. Not having the plate does not disqualify you.
Will my rates go up if I file a hit-and-run claim?
Probably not. Because you were not at fault, most insurance companies do not raise rates for hit-and-run claims. However, the claim will appear on your record, and some insurers review claims history when you renew. Ask your agent whether this specific claim will affect your premium.
Can I use collision coverage instead of uninsured motorist property damage?
No. Collision coverage does not pay for hit-and-runs because it covers accidents where the other driver is identified or where you are at fault. If you do not have UMPD coverage, you will need to pay for repairs yourself or pursue the other driver in small claims court if you identify them later.
What if the other driver is found after I settled my claim?
You can reopen your claim and your insurance company will pursue the other driver's insurance through subrogation. Contact your adjuster with the other driver's information and your insurance company will file a claim against their policy to recover what they paid you.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.