Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How Insurance Handles a Hit and Run Claim

What your insurance does when you're hit and the other driver leaves

If another vehicle hits yours and the driver leaves the scene, your own insurance—not the absent driver's—typically covers the damage. This is called uninsured motorist property damage coverage (UMPD), and it works differently from a normal collision claim. Instead of filing against the other driver's policy, you file against your own, usually with a lower deductible than collision coverage.

The catch is that you must have UMPD on your policy for it to work. Many states do not require it, so some drivers carry only liability coverage and have no protection in a hit-and-run. If you do not have UMPD, your only option is collision coverage, which typically costs more in deductible and may not cover the full damage.

Your insurer will still investigate—they want to know whether the other vehicle can be identified, whether police were called, and whether you have any information about the other driver. The more details you provide, the faster the claim moves. But even if the other driver is never found, UMPD pays out as long as you meet the policy conditions.

Key Takeaways

  • Uninsured motorist property damage coverage (UMPD) on your own policy pays for hit-and-run damage, not the absent driver's insurance.
  • You must have UMPD on your policy before the accident happens; you cannot add it after a hit-and-run occurs.
  • A police report strengthens your claim and is required by many insurers, so call police even if the damage seems minor.
  • Your deductible for UMPD is often lower than collision coverage, but you still pay it out of pocket before insurance pays the rest.
  • If you have only liability coverage and no UMPD, you may have no insurance recovery unless you can identify and sue the other driver.

Why your own insurance pays instead of the other driver's

In a normal accident, the at-fault driver's liability insurance pays for your damage. But in a hit-and-run, there is no at-fault driver to bill—or at least not one you can identify. Your insurer cannot collect from someone they cannot find.

That is why states created uninsured motorist coverage. It treats a hit-and-run the same way it treats an accident with an uninsured driver: your own policy steps in. You are not claiming that the other driver was uninsured; you are claiming that you cannot identify them, which puts them in the same category for insurance purposes.

This is why UMPD must be on your policy before the accident. You cannot buy it after a hit-and-run and use it retroactively. If you do not have it, you have no insurance recovery unless you later identify the other driver and sue them directly—a slow and uncertain process.

What your insurer will ask for and why

When you file a hit-and-run claim, your insurer will request several pieces of information. They need a police report number, a description of the other vehicle (color, size, any visible damage), the location and time of the accident, and any witness contact information. They will also ask whether you saw the other driver or the license plate, even partially.

Your insurer uses this information to determine whether the claim is legitimate and whether the other vehicle can be traced. If you have dash-cam footage or photos of the scene, provide those when ready. If witnesses saw the other car leave, their statements matter. The more concrete details you have, the less room there is for your insurer to deny the claim as unverifiable.

You will also need to provide your own vehicle information, repair estimates, and proof of ownership. Some insurers require you to obtain a police report before they will process the claim; others will accept a report number you file yourself. Ask your insurer what they need before you start the claim.

The police report requirement

Most insurance companies require a police report for a hit-and-run claim, though the requirement varies by state and insurer. Some will process a claim without one if you have strong corroborating evidence, but a report makes the claim much simpler. The police report creates an official record that you did not cause the damage and that you reported it promptly.

Call the police non-emergency line if the accident happened in a parking lot or on a quiet street and no one was injured. For accidents on a busy road or with injuries, call 911. Give the dispatcher the location, time, and a description of the other vehicle. The police will file a report and give you a report number; your insurer will use that number to verify the claim.

If police decline to file a report—which can happen in minor parking-lot accidents—ask your insurer whether they will accept a written statement from you instead. Some will; others will not. Knowing this before you leave the scene helps you decide whether to push for a report or move forward with your claim another way.

How the deductible works on a hit-and-run claim

When you file a UMPD claim, you pay your UMPD deductible, not your collision deductible. Many insurers set the UMPD deductible lower—often $250 or $500—because hit-and-run claims are harder to dispute and the insurer has less reason to deny them. Your collision deductible might be $1,000 or higher.

Check your policy to see what your UMPD deductible actually is. Some policies tie it to collision; others set it separately. If you have a high deductible and the damage is minor, you may decide not to file a claim at all, since you would pay the deductible and the insurer would pay only a small amount on top of it.

The deductible is what you owe; the insurer pays the rest of the repair cost up to your policy limit. If repairs cost $3,000 and your UMPD deductible is $500, you pay $500 and your insurer pays $2,500. If the damage exceeds your policy limit, you are responsible for the overage.

What happens if the other driver is later identified

If police find the other driver after you have already filed a UMPD claim and your insurer has paid, your insurer may pursue subrogation—recovering the money they paid from the other driver's insurance. This does not affect your claim or your deductible; it is between the two insurers.

In some cases, the other driver's insurer will reimburse yours. In others, the other driver may not have insurance, or the case may be too small to pursue. Your insurer will not ask you to repay them if subrogation fails. The point of UMPD is to protect you regardless of whether the other driver is ever found.

If you identify the other driver yourself before filing a claim, you can report them to police and potentially file a claim against their liability insurance instead of using your own UMPD. This avoids using your deductible and keeps your claim history cleaner. But if you cannot identify them, UMPD is your protection.

If you do not have uninsured motorist coverage

If your policy includes only liability coverage and no UMPD, you have no insurance recovery for a hit-and-run unless you identify the other driver. This leaves you with two options: pay for repairs out of pocket, or attempt to sue the other driver if they are later found.

Suing is slow and uncertain. You would need to hire an attorney, prove the other driver caused the damage, and collect a judgment—all of which costs money and takes months or years. Many people in this situation straightforward absorb the cost.

If you do not have UMPD now, you can add it to your policy at any time, but it will not cover accidents that already happened. Adding it protects you going forward. The cost is usually modest—often $5 to $15 per month depending on your deductible and state—and it is worth having if you live in an area with heavy traffic or park on the street.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to file a police report to claim hit-and-run damage?

Most insurers require a police report, though some will accept a written statement if police decline to file one. Call your insurer before you decide whether to pursue a report. If they require one and you do not get one, they may deny your claim. A report also protects you if the other driver later disputes the accident.

Will my insurance rates go up after a hit-and-run claim?

Rates typically do not increase for a hit-and-run claim filed under UMPD, because you were not at fault. Some insurers treat it the same as comprehensive coverage—a claim that does not affect your rate. Check your policy or ask your agent. If your insurer does raise rates, you can shop for a new policy with a different company.

What if the repair cost is less than my deductible?

If repairs cost $400 and your UMPD deductible is $500, filing a claim makes no sense—you would pay $400 out of pocket anyway, and the insurer would pay nothing. In this case, pay for repairs yourself and skip the claim. Filing a claim you do not use does not affect your rate, but it does create a record.

Can I claim a hit-and-run if I did not see the other car hit me?

You can file a claim if you have evidence that another vehicle caused the damage—a witness, dash-cam footage, or damage patterns that show impact. If you straightforward found damage in a parking lot with no evidence of how it happened, your insurer may deny the claim as unverifiable. A police report helps prove the damage was caused by another vehicle.

What if I identify the other driver weeks later?

Report them to police when ready and provide the information to your insurer. If you have already filed a UMPD claim and been paid, your insurer will attempt subrogation. If you have not filed yet, you can file against the other driver's liability insurance instead, which may be better for you. Either way, tell your insurer as soon as you have a name or license plate.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.