Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How To Check What Cases an Accident Lawyer Has Actually Tried

What you're really looking for when you check a lawyer's trial experience

When you call an accident lawyer, they will almost certainly tell you they have trial experience. What matters is whether they have tried cases like yours — and whether they tried them recently, in front of a jury, and didn't lose badly. A lawyer who settled 200 cases without going to trial has zero trial experience, even if they say otherwise. A lawyer who tried three car accident cases to verdict in the last five years has real trial experience.

You need to know three specific things: how many cases they have actually taken to trial (not settled), what kind of cases those were, and how those trials ended. The difference between a lawyer who talks about trial experience and one who has it shows up in court records, not in their website.

Key Takeaways

  • Ask the lawyer directly how many cases they have tried to verdict in the last five years, and ask them to name the cases and the outcomes — vague answers mean limited trial experience.
  • Court records are public; you can search your state's court database to confirm whether cases the lawyer names actually went to trial and what the verdict was.
  • A lawyer who settled 50 cases and tried 2 has much less trial experience than one who tried 15, even if both say they "handle trials."
  • Jury verdicts matter more than bench trials (judge-only trials) for car accident cases, because juries tend to award more for pain and suffering.
  • Recent trial experience (last three to five years) is more relevant than old cases, because laws, jury attitudes, and insurance company tactics change.

The questions to ask directly

Start with the lawyer themselves. Call or email and ask: "How many cases have you taken to trial in the last five years?" Then ask: "How many of those were car accident or motor vehicle injury cases?" Then ask: "What were the outcomes — how many did you win, how many did you lose, and what were the verdict amounts?"

If the lawyer gives you a number but won't name specific cases or outcomes, that is a red flag. A lawyer with real trial experience can tell you "I tried the Smith v. State Farm case in 2022 and won a $180,000 jury verdict" or "I tried the Johnson case in 2021 and the jury awarded $45,000." If they say "I've tried many cases" or "I have extensive trial experience" without numbers or case names, they are being deliberately vague.

Ask also whether those trials were jury trials or bench trials (where a judge decides instead of a jury). For car accident cases, jury trials usually matter more, because juries tend to award higher amounts for pain and suffering than judges do. A lawyer who has tried 10 bench trials but no jury trials has a different skill set than one who has tried jury cases.

How to verify what they tell you in court records

Every state maintains a public court database where you can search cases by name, case number, or lawyer name. The process varies by state, but most allow free searching online. Search your state's court system website (usually found under "Court Records" or "Case Search") and look for the cases the lawyer named.

When you find a case, look for the final judgment or verdict. This document will show whether the case went to trial, what the verdict was, and who won. If the lawyer told you they won a $150,000 verdict but the court record shows a $50,000 settlement, that is a material difference. If the record shows the case was dismissed or the lawyer's client lost, that matters too.

Some states also publish jury verdict databases or trial outcome reports. Your state bar association may have a public record of disciplinary actions or complaints against the lawyer, which is a separate but important check. A lawyer with a history of complaints or discipline may still be competent, but you should know about it before you hire them.

What "trial experience" actually means in practice

A lawyer who has tried 50 cases to verdict has a very different skill set than one who has tried 2. Trial experience is not binary — it exists on a spectrum. A lawyer who tried their first jury trial last year is not the same as one who has tried 20 jury trials. Both have trial experience, but one has much more of it.

For car accident cases specifically, ask whether the lawyer has tried cases involving the type of injury you have. A lawyer who has tried 10 car accident cases but all of them involved minor soft-tissue injuries may not have the courtroom experience to handle a case involving a spinal cord injury or traumatic brain injury. The stakes are different, the medical testimony is more complex, and the jury dynamics shift.

Also ask whether the lawyer has tried cases against the insurance company that insured the person who hit you. If you were hit by someone with State Farm coverage, a lawyer who has tried multiple cases against State Farm knows how that company's adjusters and defense lawyers typically behave, what their settlement patterns are, and what juries in your area tend to award against them. That specific experience is valuable.

Red flags that suggest limited or no real trial experience

A lawyer who cannot name a single case they tried to verdict in the last five years does not have recent trial experience. Period. They may have tried cases 10 or 15 years ago, but trial law changes, and old experience is not the same as current experience.

A lawyer who says "I'm prepared to go to trial" or "I don't back down from trial" is not the same as a lawyer who has actually tried cases. Willingness to try a case is not the same as skill at trying a case. Many lawyers will say they will take a case to trial if settlement talks fail, but they have never actually done it.

A lawyer whose website lists trial experience but cannot give you numbers or case names when you ask directly is being evasive. A lawyer who says "I've tried hundreds of cases" but cannot name three is lying or exaggerating. Trust the specific, named cases over the general claims.

What to do if the lawyer has limited trial experience

Limited trial experience does not automatically mean the lawyer is bad. Many car accident cases settle before trial, and a lawyer who is skilled at negotiation and settlement may get you a better outcome than a lawyer who is eager to try every case. The question is whether the lawyer's skills match what your case needs.

If your case is straightforward — clear liability, moderate injuries, no dispute about fault — a lawyer with settlement experience may be fine. If your case is complex, involves serious injuries, or the other side is refusing to settle reasonably, you need a lawyer with real trial experience. That lawyer will have leverage in settlement negotiations because the insurance company knows they can actually try the case.

If a lawyer you like has limited trial experience, ask whether they work with a trial counsel or co-counsel — another lawyer who handles the trial phase if the case does not settle. Some law firms divide labor this way. If they do, ask about that other lawyer's trial experience using the same questions you asked the first lawyer.

Understanding what the verdict or settlement amount actually tells you

A high verdict does not always mean the lawyer is skilled; it may mean the injuries were severe or liability was crystal clear. A low verdict does not always mean the lawyer performed poorly; it may mean the injuries were minor or the jury straightforward did not believe the client's account. Verdict amounts vary wildly by location, injury type, and the specific facts of the case.

What matters more than the dollar amount is the pattern. A lawyer who has tried 10 cases and won 8 of them has a better track record than one who tried 10 cases and won 3. A lawyer whose verdicts are consistently in the range of $100,000 to $300,000 for moderate injuries shows consistency. A lawyer with one huge verdict and many tiny ones may have gotten lucky once.

Ask the lawyer also about cases they lost. Every trial lawyer loses some cases. A lawyer who will not talk about losses is hiding something. A lawyer who can explain why they lost a case — "the jury did not believe the medical testimony" or "liability was genuinely unclear" — is being honest with you about the limits of trial work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I look up a lawyer's trial record myself without asking them?

Yes. Search your state's court database by the lawyer's name or the case names they mention. Court records are public. You can also call the courthouse directly and ask whether a specific case went to trial and what the outcome was. This takes time but gives you independent verification.

What if a lawyer says they tried a case but I can't find it in court records?

Ask them for the case number, the court where it was tried, and the year. If they cannot give you those details, they may be misremembering or exaggerating. If they give you the details and you still cannot find it, the case may have been settled after a trial started, or the record may be archived. Ask the lawyer to provide a copy of the judgment or verdict.

Does a lawyer need trial experience to handle my car accident case?

Not necessarily. Most car accident cases settle without trial. What matters is whether your lawyer has the skill to negotiate a fair settlement and the credibility to convince the insurance company they will try the case if needed. A lawyer with trial experience has that credibility. A lawyer without it may still get you a good settlement, but you have less leverage.

What's the difference between a jury trial and a bench trial for my case?

In a jury trial, 6 to 12 people decide the outcome. In a bench trial, the judge decides. For car accident cases, juries typically award more for pain and suffering than judges do. If your case goes to trial, you probably want a jury. Ask the lawyer whether they have jury trial experience specifically.

Should I hire a lawyer with no trial experience if they offer a lower fee?

Cost matters, but trial experience affects what you actually receive. A cheaper lawyer with no trial experience may settle your case for less than a more expensive lawyer with real trial experience could negotiate. Ask what the lawyer's settlement amounts typically are, not just what they charge. The fee is only part of the picture.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.