Questions To Ask Your Car Accident Attorney Before You Hire Them
What to ask before you sign anything
Before you hire an attorney to handle your car accident claim, you need to know how they charge, what they will actually do for you, and whether they have handled cases like yours before. Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover instead of charging you an hourly fee—but the percentage varies, and so do what costs they deduct before you get paid. The questions below will tell you whether an attorney is a fit for your situation and what to expect if you move forward.
Do not feel rushed to decide. A good attorney will answer these questions clearly and will not pressure you to sign a contract the same day you meet. If an attorney becomes impatient or vague when you ask for details, that is a signal to talk to someone else.
Key Takeaways
- Ask whether the attorney works on contingency (takes a percentage of your recovery) or charges hourly, and what percentage or hourly rate applies to your case.
- Find out what costs the attorney will deduct from your settlement before you receive your share—medical records fees, court filing fees, and informed witness costs add up quickly.
- Ask how many car accident cases the attorney has taken to trial, not just settled, because settlement experience and trial experience are different skills.
- Clarify what the attorney will do personally versus what paralegals or junior attorneys will handle, because you may not speak to the attorney again after the first meeting.
- Ask for the attorney's estimate of how long your case will take and what happens if the other driver's insurance denies your claim.
How the attorney charges and what you actually pay
Start by asking: "Do you work on contingency or hourly?" Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, but some do not. If contingency, ask what percentage they take. Standard percentages range, but you should hear a specific number—often 25 to 40 percent depending on whether the case settles before trial or goes to court. A case that settles early may have a lower percentage; a case that requires trial usually has a higher one.
Then ask: "What costs come out of my settlement before I get paid?" This is the question most people forget, and it matters. The attorney will deduct costs such as medical records requests, court filing fees, informed witness fees, and sometimes investigator fees. Ask for a written list of what costs the attorney typically deducts and whether you have to approve large expenses before they are incurred. Some attorneys deduct costs automatically; others ask your permission first. You want to know which applies to you.
Ask whether the attorney advances these costs (pays them upfront and deducts them later) or whether you pay them as they come due. If you are injured and have limited money, this distinction matters. Also ask: "If my case does not result in a recovery, do I owe you anything?" Under a true contingency agreement, you should owe nothing if you lose—but confirm this in writing before you sign.
The attorney's experience with cases like yours
Ask: "How many car accident cases have you handled?" and then follow up: "How many went to trial versus settled?" An attorney who has settled 50 cases but never tried one may not be prepared if the other driver's insurance refuses a reasonable offer. Conversely, an attorney who tries every case may be less skilled at negotiating a settlement, which is where most cases end.
Ask specifically about cases similar to yours. If you were hit by a commercial truck, ask how many truck accident cases the attorney has handled. If you have a serious injury, ask about cases involving similar injuries. If the other driver was uninsured, ask whether the attorney has experience with uninsured motorist claims. Experience in your specific type of accident matters because the law and negotiation tactics differ.
Ask: "What is your success rate in cases like mine?" Be skeptical of vague answers. A good attorney will give you a range—for example, "In cases where the other driver is clearly at fault and the injuries are documented, we recover the full policy limit about 70 percent of the time." That tells you something real. "We win most of our cases" tells you nothing.
Who will actually work on your case
Ask: "Will you personally handle my case, or will a paralegal or junior attorney do most of the work?" This is not a trick question—many law firms assign cases to junior attorneys or paralegals, and that is sometimes fine. But you should know upfront. Ask: "How often will I speak directly with you?" Some attorneys meet with you once and then you communicate only with staff. Others stay in regular contact. Know which you are getting.
Ask: "Who will negotiate with the insurance company?" If a junior attorney or paralegal will handle negotiations, ask about their experience. Ask: "If I need to make a decision about settling or going to trial, will I speak with you directly?" You should. Settlement decisions are yours to make, and you should make them with the attorney who knows your case best.
Timeline and what happens if the insurance company says no
Ask: "How long do you expect my case to take?" The answer depends on whether you are still treating for injuries, whether liability is clear, and whether the insurance company is cooperative. A straightforward case with clear liability and minor injuries might resolve in three to six months. A case with serious injuries or disputed liability can take a year or longer. Ask for a realistic range, not a best-case scenario.
Ask: "What happens if the insurance company denies my claim?" You need to know whether the attorney will file a lawsuit, what that costs, and how much longer it takes. Ask: "What is your experience with lawsuits in this county?" Some attorneys are comfortable in local courts; others are not. If your case might require a lawsuit, you want an attorney who has tried cases in your jurisdiction.
Ask: "Will you keep me updated, and how?" Some attorneys send monthly updates; others contact you only when something changes. Ask how you will receive updates—email, phone call, or in-person meeting—and how quickly the attorney responds to your calls or messages. If you are anxious about your case, you want to know the attorney's communication style before you hire them.
What the attorney needs from you
Ask: "What documents and information do you need from me?" You will need to provide your insurance policy, the police report, medical records, and proof of lost wages if you missed work. Ask whether the attorney will obtain some of these documents for you or whether you have to gather them. Ask: "What should I do or not do while my case is pending?" Most attorneys will tell you not to post about the accident on social media, not to discuss the case with the other driver, and not to accept any settlement offer without consulting the attorney first.
Ask: "Can you send me a written fee agreement before I decide?" Any attorney worth hiring will provide a contract that spells out the contingency percentage, what costs you owe, and what services the attorney will provide. Read it carefully. If anything is unclear, ask before you sign. Do not sign a contract that has blank spaces or terms you do not understand.
Red flags that mean you should keep looking
If an attorney guarantees a specific outcome—"I will get you $50,000" or "You will definitely win"—that is a red flag. No attorney can may provide a result. If an attorney pressures you to sign a contract the same day you meet, that is a sign they are more interested in taking your case than in making sure it is a good fit. If an attorney cannot or will not answer your questions clearly, you will have a hard time working with them later.
If an attorney tells you not to worry about anything and that they will handle it all, be cautious. You are the client, and you have the right to understand your case and make decisions about it. An attorney who treats you as a passive bystander is not serving you well. If an attorney has no trial experience and your case might require trial, ask whether they will bring in another attorney for that phase or whether they will learn on your case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I hire the first attorney I talk to?
No. Talk to at least two or three attorneys before you decide. Most offer free initial consultations. Use that time to ask these questions and get a feel for how the attorney communicates. You want someone who answers clearly, listens to you, and does not rush you into a decision.
What if the attorney I want to hire is very busy and says they cannot take my case right now?
Ask whether they can refer you to another attorney they trust. A referral from an attorney you respect is often better than finding someone on your own. If they cannot refer you, keep looking. A busy attorney is not necessarily a better attorney.
Can I change attorneys if I am unhappy after I hire one?
Yes, but it can be complicated. You can fire your attorney at any time, but you may owe them for work they have already done. Ask your new attorney about this before you make the switch. Some attorneys will negotiate a lower fee if you are switching because of a genuine problem.
What if I cannot afford an attorney?
Most car accident attorneys work on contingency, so cost should not be a barrier. If an attorney refuses to take your case on contingency, ask why—it may be because they think your case is weak, or it may be because they are very busy. Keep looking for an attorney who will take your case on contingency.
Should I sign a contract that says the attorney gets 40 percent instead of 33 percent?
That depends on the circumstances and what you negotiate. If the case is straightforward and will settle quickly, a lower percentage is reasonable. If the case is complex and might require trial, a higher percentage may be justified. Ask the attorney to explain why they are asking for that percentage, and do not sign if you are not comfortable with it.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.