Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Do When You Receive a Subpoena After a Car Accident

A subpoena after a car accident means a lawyer or court is asking you to provide evidence or testify about the crash

A subpoena is a legal order requiring you to appear in court, provide documents, or give a statement under oath. After a car accident, you might receive one if the case goes to trial, if someone files a lawsuit, or if there is a dispute over who caused the crash. The subpoena will name the case, tell you what is being asked of you, and give you a date and location.

You cannot ignore a subpoena. Failing to respond can result in fines, a contempt of court charge, or a warrant for your arrest. If you receive one, you must take it seriously and understand what it requires. The good news is that responding is straightforward once you know what the other side is asking for and what your rights are.

Key Takeaways

  • A subpoena is a court order that requires you to provide documents, appear in court, or give a deposition, and ignoring it can result in legal penalties.
  • You have the right to object to a subpoena if it asks for something unreasonable, protected by attorney-client privilege, or unrelated to the case.
  • If you are the defendant in the accident case, your own insurance company's lawyer may represent you at no cost to you.
  • A deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session with the other side's lawyer, usually held before trial, and you can bring your own lawyer.
  • Responding promptly and honestly is your best protection; lying under oath or missing a court date creates far worse legal problems than the accident itself.

Types of subpoenas you might receive after an accident

A subpoena to testify orders you to appear in court on a specific date and answer questions about the accident under oath. This usually happens if the case goes to trial. You will be questioned by both the plaintiff's lawyer (the person suing) and the defendant's lawyer (the person being sued), or their representatives.

A subpoena for documents asks you to provide records related to the accident—your insurance policy, medical records, repair estimates, photos you took, text messages, or your phone records. You do not have to appear in court; you send the documents to the court or the lawyer who issued the subpoena by a important date.

A subpoena for a deposition requires you to appear at a lawyer's office (not a courtroom) to answer questions under oath. A court reporter records everything you say. Depositions usually happen before trial and allow both sides to hear your account of the accident and test your credibility. You can bring your own lawyer to a deposition, and many people do.

Who can issue a subpoena and why

Either side in a lawsuit can issue a subpoena—the person suing (plaintiff) or the person being sued (defendant). A lawyer, judge, or court clerk can issue one. After a car accident, subpoenas are most common when someone files a personal injury lawsuit, when there is a dispute over fault that insurance cannot resolve, or when a criminal case results from the accident.

The other side issues a subpoena because they want your version of events, your medical records, or evidence that supports their case. If you are the defendant (the person being sued), the plaintiff's lawyer will likely subpoena you to lock in your testimony and look for inconsistencies. If you are a witness to someone else's accident, you might be subpoenaed by either side.

Your right to object to a subpoena

You can object to a subpoena if it is unreasonable, asks for something that does not relate to the case, or seeks information protected by law. Common grounds for objection include requests for attorney-client communications (conversations between you and your lawyer), medical records unrelated to the accident, or documents that would be extremely burdensome to gather.

To object, you must file a written motion with the court before the important date on the subpoena. You will need to explain why the request is improper. If the court agrees, it can modify or cancel the subpoena. If you do not object in writing and on time, you lose the right to object later. This is why consulting a lawyer before responding is often worth the cost.

Do not straightforward ignore a subpoena because you think it is unfair. Ignoring it and then objecting later will not work. You must object in writing and on time, or comply with the subpoena.

What happens if you are the defendant in the accident case

If you are being sued for the accident, your auto insurance company has a legal duty to defend you. This means they will hire a lawyer to represent you at no cost to you. That lawyer will advise you on how to respond to the subpoena, what to say in a deposition, and how to prepare for trial. You should contact your insurance company when ready after receiving a subpoena and give them a copy.

Your insurance company's lawyer works for you, not the insurance company, during the lawsuit. You can ask them questions about the subpoena, what to expect, and how to prepare. They will also tell you if the subpoena is unreasonable and help you object if necessary. Do not respond to a subpoena on your own if your insurance company has already assigned you a lawyer—let your lawyer handle it.

How to prepare for a deposition or court testimony

If you are being deposed or called to testify, preparation is essential. Review the accident report, any photos or videos you took, your medical records if you were injured, and any written statements you gave to police or your insurance company. Write down what you remember about the accident: the time, weather, road conditions, traffic, what you saw the other driver do, and what happened when ready before and after the crash.

Meet with your lawyer before the deposition or trial date. Your lawyer will explain the types of questions you will be asked, how to answer clearly and honestly, and what to do if you do not know the answer. The most important rule is to tell the truth. Lying under oath is perjury, a criminal offense that carries jail time and fines far worse than any civil judgment in the accident case.

During the deposition or testimony, listen carefully to each question, take a moment to think before answering, and answer only what is asked. Do not volunteer extra information, do not guess, and do not try to help your side by exaggerating. If you do not remember something, say so. If you do not understand a question, ask the lawyer to rephrase it.

What to do when you receive a subpoena

Read the subpoena carefully and note the important date. The subpoena will say whether you must appear in person, provide documents, or both. It will list the documents requested and the date, time, and location where you must appear or deliver them.

Contact your insurance company or your own lawyer when ready. If you are the defendant, your insurance company's lawyer will take over. If you are a witness or the plaintiff, you may want to hire a lawyer to review the subpoena and advise you on your rights. Many lawyers offer a free initial consultation.

Gather the documents requested. If you cannot find all of them, write down which ones you have and which ones you do not have. Do not destroy or alter any documents, even if you think they make you look bad. Destroying evidence is a crime.

If you believe the subpoena is unreasonable, work with your lawyer to file a written objection before the important date. If you do not object, you must comply by the important date. Deliver documents by the method the subpoena specifies (mail, email, or in person) and keep a copy for yourself. If you must appear, arrive early, bring any documents you were asked to bring, and bring your lawyer if you have one.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if I ignore a subpoena?

Ignoring a subpoena is contempt of court. The judge can fine you, order you to pay the other side's legal fees, or issue a warrant for your arrest. If you cannot comply by the important date for a legitimate reason, contact your lawyer or the court when ready to ask for an extension.

Can I be subpoenaed if I was not the driver in the accident?

Yes. If you were a passenger, a witness, or even someone who arrived after the crash and helped, you can be subpoenaed. Either side may want your account of what happened or what you observed. You have the same obligation to respond as the driver does.

Do I have to answer every question in a deposition?

You must answer most questions truthfully. Your lawyer can object if a question is improper, but you still have to answer unless the judge agrees with the objection. You do not have to answer questions about attorney-client communications or information protected by privilege.

What if the other side's lawyer is rude or aggressive during a deposition?

Stay calm and professional. Your lawyer can object to abusive questions and ask the court to intervene if necessary. Do not argue with the lawyer or lose your temper. The court reporter is recording everything, and juries notice when a witness remains composed under pressure.

Can I bring documents to court even if I was not asked for them?

You can bring documents to show your lawyer before trial, but do not bring extra documents to court unless your lawyer tells you to. Bringing unsolicited documents can backfire if they contain information that hurts your case. Let your lawyer decide what evidence to present.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.