Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens After Your Car Accident Arbitration Decision

The arbitrator's decision is binding, which means you cannot appeal it to a court

Once an arbitrator makes a decision in your car accident case, that decision is final. You cannot take it to court, ask a judge to review it, or ask for a new hearing based on the outcome. This is the trade-off you made when you chose arbitration instead of a lawsuit: the process is faster and cheaper, but you give up the right to appeal.

If you won the arbitration, the other party is legally required to pay the amount the arbitrator ordered. If you lost, you owe nothing further — the case is closed. Either way, the decision stands as written.

Key Takeaways

  • An arbitrator's decision is final and cannot be appealed to court, even if you believe the arbitrator made a mistake.
  • If you won, the other party has a set time (usually 30 days) to pay the award before you can pursue collection.
  • If the other party does not pay, you will need to file a separate collection action in small claims or civil court to enforce the award.
  • The arbitration agreement you signed determines whether you can recover attorney fees or costs from the other party.
  • Some arbitration decisions can be challenged only on very narrow grounds, such as fraud or corruption by the arbitrator.

What happens if you won the arbitration

The arbitrator will issue a written decision stating the amount the other party must pay you. This is called the award. The decision will include the date by which payment is due — typically 30 days from the date the decision is issued.

In most cases, the losing party pays directly to you or your attorney. If they do not pay by the important date, you will need to take a separate step to collect. This is not automatic. You cannot straightforward wait and expect the money to appear; you have to pursue it through the court system if the other party refuses to pay voluntarily.

Some arbitration agreements allow you to recover the costs of arbitration (filing fees, arbitrator fees) and sometimes attorney fees from the losing party. Check your original arbitration agreement or ask your attorney whether this applies to your case, because the rules vary widely depending on who required arbitration and what they agreed to.

Collecting the award if the other party does not pay

If 30 days pass and you have not received payment, you will need to file what is called a motion to enforce the arbitration award in civil court. This is a separate legal action, and it requires filing paperwork with the court in the county where the other party lives or works.

The process is simpler than a full lawsuit — you are not relitigating the case, only asking the court to enforce a decision that has already been made. In most states, this takes between two and six weeks, though it can be longer if the other party contests it.

Once the court confirms the award, the other party can be ordered to pay through wage garnishment, bank account levy, or a lien on their property, depending on what the court allows in your state. If they still refuse, they can face contempt of court charges.

The very narrow grounds for challenging an arbitration decision

Although you cannot appeal an arbitration decision because you disagree with the outcome, a handful of circumstances allow you to ask a court to overturn it. These are extremely limited and rarely succeed.

You can challenge the award only if you can prove one of these: the arbitrator was biased or had a financial interest in the outcome; the arbitrator committed fraud or corruption; the arbitrator refused to hear evidence that was central to the case; or the arbitrator exceeded the authority given to them in the arbitration agreement. straightforward believing the arbitrator made a wrong decision is not enough.

If you think one of these narrow grounds applies, you must file a motion to vacate the award in the same court where you would enforce it. You will need an attorney for this, and the burden of proof is on you. Courts almost never overturn arbitration awards on these grounds.

What happens if you lost the arbitration

If the arbitrator decided against you, the case is over. You owe the other party nothing beyond what the arbitrator ordered (if anything). You cannot appeal, file a new case on the same facts, or ask for reconsideration.

The only exception is if you can prove one of the narrow grounds listed above — fraud, bias, or corruption by the arbitrator. This is a very high bar and requires evidence, not just suspicion.

If the arbitration agreement required you to pay the other party's costs or attorney fees, those will be included in the award you owe. Make sure you understand the full amount before the decision is issued, because you will be responsible for paying it.

How arbitration decisions affect your insurance and future claims

An arbitration award does not automatically appear on your driving record or insurance history. However, if the award was against you and you do not pay it, the other party can sue you in court to enforce it — and that court judgment will affect your record and your insurance rates.

If you won the arbitration and the other party's insurance company was involved, the insurance company is bound by the decision just as the individual is. They cannot reopen the case or dispute the award in a separate claim.

Future insurance companies may ask about arbitration awards when you explore for coverage, particularly if the award was large or if you have a pattern of disputes. Being honest about the outcome is important; lying on an insurance process can void your coverage.

What to do with the arbitration paperwork after the decision

Keep the arbitrator's written decision, the arbitration agreement, and all correspondence related to the case. If you need to enforce the award or if the other party later tries to challenge it, you will need these documents.

If you won and are collecting the award, your attorney will likely file the decision with the court as part of the enforcement process. If you lost and the other party is collecting, they will do the same. Either way, the paperwork becomes part of a court record.

Do not assume the case is truly finished until any payment has been made and received. Keep records of payments, and if the other party pays in installments, get written confirmation of each payment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I appeal an arbitration decision if I think the arbitrator made a mistake?

No. Arbitration decisions are final and binding. You cannot appeal to a court straightforward because you disagree with the outcome. The only exceptions are fraud, bias, or corruption by the arbitrator — a much higher bar than disagreeing with their judgment.

How long do I have to collect the award if I won?

The arbitrator typically gives the other party 30 days to pay. After that, you can file a motion to enforce the award in court. There is no time limit on how long you can wait to enforce it, but the sooner you act, the more likely you are to collect before the other party's financial situation changes.

What if the other party claims they cannot pay the award?

That does not erase the debt. You can still pursue collection through wage garnishment, bank levies, or liens on property. The court can also hold them in contempt if they refuse to pay without a legitimate reason. Inability to pay is different from unwillingness to pay.

Does an arbitration award show up on my credit report?

Not directly. However, if you do not pay and the other party sues to enforce the award, the resulting court judgment will appear on your credit report and affect your credit score. Paying the award promptly prevents this.

Can the other party sue me again for the same accident after arbitration?

No. Arbitration is final. Once the arbitrator has decided the case, neither party can bring it back to arbitration or file a new lawsuit based on the same accident and the same claims. The case is closed.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.