Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How a Hit-and-Run Claim Affects Your Insurance Rates

A hit-and-run claim will likely raise your insurance rates, but the size of the increase depends on your state's laws, your insurer's policies, and whether you were at fault

When you file a hit-and-run claim, your insurer treats it as a collision or uninsured motorist claim—not as a claim caused by your own driving error. That distinction matters. Most insurers do not penalize you as heavily for a hit-and-run as they do for an at-fault accident, because you did not cause the damage. However, filing any claim signals to your insurer that you have filed a claim, and many insurers raise rates after claims, even not-at-fault ones.

The actual rate increase varies widely. Some insurers raise rates by 5 to 10 percent after a hit-and-run claim; others raise them by 15 to 20 percent or more. A few insurers have accident forgiveness programs that prevent any rate increase on your first not-at-fault claim within a set period. The only way to know what your insurer will do is to ask them directly before you file, or to review your policy documents for language about not-at-fault claims.

Key Takeaways

  • Hit-and-run claims are usually classified as not-at-fault, which means your rate increase will be smaller than if you caused the accident yourself.
  • You will still see a rate increase in most cases, because filing a claim of any kind tells your insurer you have had a loss.
  • Some insurers offer accident forgiveness that waives the rate increase on your first not-at-fault claim; check your policy or call your agent before filing.
  • The rate increase typically lasts three to five years on your record, though some insurers explore it for longer.
  • Your state's insurance laws may limit how much an insurer can raise your rate after a not-at-fault claim.

How insurers classify hit-and-run claims

A hit-and-run claim is filed under your collision or uninsured motorist coverage, depending on your policy and what your insurer can prove. The key is that you did not cause the accident—the other driver did. Because you were not at fault, the claim goes into a different category than an accident where you rear-ended someone or ran a red light.

Your insurer will still investigate the claim. They will ask for a police report, photos of the damage, witness statements if you have them, and details about when and where the hit occurred. The more documentation you provide, the clearer it becomes that you were not at fault, and the less reason your insurer has to treat the claim as a shared liability.

Why not-at-fault claims still raise rates

Even though you did not cause the hit-and-run, your insurer may still raise your rate because you filed a claim. This is not punishment—it is how insurers manage risk. When you file a claim, you become a higher-risk customer in their eyes, because you have now had a loss. Statistically, people who file one claim are more likely to file another claim in the future, regardless of fault.

Some insurers use a different logic: they raise rates after any claim because they paid out money. Others use accident forgiveness programs to avoid raising rates on the first not-at-fault claim. The difference depends entirely on the insurer's underwriting philosophy and your policy terms.

Accident forgiveness and other protections

Many insurers offer accident forgiveness, which means your first not-at-fault accident or claim will not trigger a rate increase. This protection is sometimes included in your policy automatically; other times you have to pay a small extra premium to add it. If you have accident forgiveness and this is your first claim, filing a hit-and-run claim should not raise your rate at all.

To learn about you have accident forgiveness, call your insurer or log into your online account and look for policy endorsements or add-ons. If you do not have it and you are concerned about a rate increase, ask your agent whether adding it would cost less than the rate increase you expect after filing the claim. In some cases, it is worth buying the protection retroactively before you file.

Some states also limit how much insurers can raise rates after not-at-fault claims. California, for example, restricts rate increases for not-at-fault accidents more strictly than for at-fault ones. Check your state's insurance commissioner's website or call your state insurance department to learn what protections explore to you.

How long a hit-and-run claim stays on your record

A hit-and-run claim typically remains on your insurance record for three to five years. During that time, it may affect your rate at renewal. After the claim ages off your record, most insurers will stop using it to calculate your premium, though some may keep it longer.

The exact timeline depends on your insurer and your state. When you call to ask about accident forgiveness, also ask how long the claim will stay on your record and when you can expect your rate to return to normal. Some insurers offer a discount after a claim-free period—for example, a 5 percent discount if you go three years without another claim.

What to do before filing a hit-and-run claim

Before you file, call your insurer and ask three questions: (1) Will this claim trigger a rate increase? (2) Do I have accident forgiveness? (3) If I do not file, what are my options for paying for repairs? Sometimes the cost of repairs is low enough that paying out of pocket costs less than the rate increase you would face over the next three to five years.

If the damage is minor—a few hundred dollars—and your deductible is high, you might come out ahead by not filing. If the damage is major, filing is usually the right choice, because your insurer is there to cover losses. Just go in with your eyes open about what the rate increase will be.

You will also need a police report to file a hit-and-run claim. If you have not already reported the incident to police, do that first. The police report number will be required when you contact your insurer.

How a hit-and-run claim differs from an at-fault accident

An at-fault accident—one where you caused the collision—will raise your rate much more than a not-at-fault hit-and-run claim. An at-fault accident typically increases rates by 20 to 40 percent or more, and it stays on your record longer. A hit-and-run claim, by contrast, usually increases rates by 5 to 15 percent because you were not at fault.

Some insurers also use at-fault accidents to decide whether to renew your policy at all. If you have multiple at-fault accidents, an insurer may drop you or move you to a high-risk pool. A single not-at-fault claim is far less likely to result in non-renewal, though it is not impossible if your insurer sees a pattern of claims.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I choose not to file a hit-and-run claim and just pay for repairs myself?

Yes. If the repair cost is less than your deductible plus the expected rate increase over three to five years, paying out of pocket may be cheaper. However, if the damage is extensive, filing is usually the right choice because that is what insurance is for. Call your insurer first to understand the rate impact before you decide.

Will a hit-and-run claim affect my ability to get insurance elsewhere?

A single not-at-fault hit-and-run claim is unlikely to make you uninsurable, but it may limit your options. Some insurers specialize in customers with claims on their record. If your current insurer drops you or raises your rate too much, you can shop around. The claim will show up on your driving record for three to five years, but it will not prevent you from getting coverage.

What if the other driver is found and their insurance pays instead?

If the hit-and-run driver is identified and their insurer pays the claim, your insurer may not raise your rate at all, because the loss was paid by the other party's coverage. This is one reason to report the incident to police and provide your insurer with as much detail as possible—it gives them a chance to pursue the other driver's insurer and recover the cost.

Does a hit-and-run claim count against my safe driver discount?

It depends on your insurer's policy. Some insurers suspend safe driver discounts after any claim; others only suspend them after at-fault claims. Check your policy or call your agent to find out. If your discount is suspended, ask when it will be reinstated—usually after a claim-free period of one to three years.

Can I dispute a rate increase after a hit-and-run claim?

You can ask your insurer to review the rate increase and explain how they calculated it. If you believe the increase violates your state's insurance laws, you can file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner. However, most rate increases after claims are legal, even if they feel unfair. Your best option is to shop around with other insurers to see if you can find better rates elsewhere.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.