How a Hit and Run Claim Affects Your Insurance Rates in Texas
A hit and run claim will likely raise your insurance rates in Texas, even though you were not at fault
When you file a hit and run claim with your insurance company in Texas, your rates usually go up. This happens because the claim goes on your driving record as a collision or comprehensive claim—depending on how your insurer codes it—and insurers use claims history to set premiums. The increase varies by company and by how much damage occurred, but most drivers see a rate bump of 10 to 25 percent for three to five years after the claim.
The unfairness stings: you did nothing wrong, yet you pay more. This is because insurers treat claims as signals of risk, not as judgments of fault. A hit and run also signals to them that you were in the wrong place at the wrong time, and they price that uncertainty into your premium. Texas law does not prevent insurers from raising rates after a not-at-fault claim, though some states do.
Whether you should file the claim at all depends on the repair cost, your deductible, and how long you plan to keep the car. If the damage is minor—under $1,500—paying out of pocket often costs less than the rate increase you will absorb over the next few years.
Key Takeaways
- Hit and run claims filed with your insurer typically raise your rates by 10 to 25 percent for three to five years, even though you were not at fault.
- Texas law allows insurers to raise rates after not-at-fault claims, unlike some states that prohibit this practice.
- If repair costs are less than your deductible plus the long-term cost of rate increases, paying out of pocket may save you money overall.
- Reporting the hit and run to police creates a separate record that may help if the other driver is found, but does not prevent your insurer from raising rates.
- Your rate increase depends on your insurer's specific formula, your driving history, and the type of coverage that paid the claim.
How Texas insurers code and rate hit and run claims
Most Texas insurers classify a hit and run as a comprehensive claim if you did not see the other vehicle (like a parking lot ding), or a collision claim if you were driving when it happened. The distinction matters because some insurers rate them differently, though both typically trigger a rate increase.
When you file, the claim goes into the CLUE report (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange), a database that tracks your claims history. Future insurers can see this report when you shop for quotes, so the claim follows you even if you switch companies. The report does not say whether you were at fault—only that a claim was filed—but insurers use it to decide whether to insure you and at what price.
Your specific rate increase depends on your insurer's underwriting model. Some companies penalize not-at-fault claims less than at-fault ones. Others treat them the same. A few—like USAA and some regional carriers—offer accident forgiveness programs that waive the first not-at-fault claim, but these are not standard in Texas and usually cost extra or require a clean driving history to may have access to.
When filing a claim costs more than paying yourself
The math of filing a hit and run claim is straightforward: compare the out-of-pocket repair cost to the total cost of the rate increase over time. If your deductible is $1,000 and repairs are $2,500, you pay $1,000 and your insurer pays $1,500. But if your rate goes up $100 per month for four years, you will have paid an extra $4,800 in premiums—a net loss of $3,800.
This calculation shifts if the damage is severe. A $15,000 repair with a $1,000 deductible makes sense to claim, because even a significant rate increase will cost less than paying $14,000 out of pocket. The break-even point for most drivers in Texas is somewhere between $3,000 and $5,000 in damage, depending on their current premium and insurer.
Before you decide, call your insurer and ask what your rate increase would be if you filed. Some companies will give you an estimate; others will not. If they will not, ask what their typical increase is for a not-at-fault comprehensive claim in your area. Then multiply that percentage by your annual premium and your expected years of increase to get a rough total cost.
The difference between reporting to police and filing an insurance claim
You can report a hit and run to the police without filing an insurance claim. The police report creates an official record that may help if the other driver is later found, and it documents the incident for your own records. Reporting does not automatically trigger an insurance claim or raise your rates.
Filing an insurance claim is a separate decision. You choose when and whether to file. If you report to police but do not file a claim, your insurer will not know about the incident unless you tell them. However, if you later file a claim, you must disclose the police report number, and your insurer will review it as part of the claim process.
The strategic move for minor damage is often to report to police (so there is an official record) but not file an insurance claim (so your rates stay flat). If the other driver is found and their insurer contacts you, you can then file a claim against their policy instead of your own, which avoids the rate increase on your end.
How long the rate increase lasts and what you can do about it
Most Texas insurers keep a not-at-fault claim on your record for three to five years. After that period, the claim stops affecting your rates, though it may still appear on the CLUE report. Some insurers drop the impact after three years; others hold it for five. Your insurer's policy is in the fine print of your declarations page or in their rate guide, which you can request.
You cannot remove a claim from your record once it is filed, but you can shop for a new insurer. Some companies weight older claims less heavily, and a few specialize in insuring drivers with recent claims. If your current insurer's rate increase is steep, getting quotes from three to five other companies may reveal a carrier that rates you lower. The savings can offset the claim's impact, especially if you have other factors (good credit, bundled policies, safety features) that earn discounts elsewhere.
If you believe the claim was coded incorrectly—for example, if it was marked as at-fault when it should have been not-at-fault—contact your insurer's claims department and ask them to review the coding. Mistakes happen, and correcting them can lower your rate increase. Ask for the decision in writing.
What happens if the other driver is found
If police locate the other driver and their insurance company accepts liability, you may be able to recover your deductible and any out-of-pocket costs. The other driver's insurer will pay your insurer back for the claim, and your insurer should refund your deductible. However, this does not erase the claim from your record or reverse the rate increase—the claim still happened and still affects your rates.
In practice, hit and run cases rarely result in the other driver being found, especially in parking lots or low-speed incidents. If the damage is minor and you did not get the other vehicle's license plate, the odds of recovery are very low. This is another reason to weigh the cost of filing against the likelihood of ever being made whole.
If you do recover your deductible, ask your insurer in writing whether recovering funds will affect your rate increase. Most will not reverse the increase, but some may reduce it slightly. Getting the answer in writing protects you if there is a dispute later.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I file a hit and run claim without it affecting my rates?
No. Once you file a claim with your insurer, it goes into your claims history and typically raises your rates, regardless of fault. The only way to avoid a rate increase is to not file the claim and pay for repairs yourself.
Does Texas law protect me from rate increases after a not-at-fault claim?
No. Texas allows insurers to raise rates after not-at-fault claims. Some states prohibit this, but Texas does not. Your insurer can increase your premium based on the claim alone, even though you did nothing wrong.
What if I report the hit and run to police but do not file an insurance claim?
Reporting to police creates an official record but does not trigger a rate increase on your own policy. If the other driver is later found and their insurer contacts you, you can then file a claim against their policy instead, which avoids raising your own rates.
How much will my rates go up after a hit and run claim?
Most Texas drivers see a 10 to 25 percent increase for three to five years, but this varies widely by insurer, your driving history, and the damage amount. Call your insurer for an estimate before you file.
Should I pay for repairs myself or file a claim?
If repairs cost less than your deductible plus the total cost of rate increases over three to five years, paying yourself usually costs less. For damage over $5,000, filing is usually the better choice. For damage between $2,000 and $5,000, do the math with your insurer's estimated rate increase.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.