Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Do After a Fatal Car Accident: Legal Steps and Your Options

A fatal car accident creates when ready legal obligations for everyone involved

When a car crash results in a death, the legal landscape changes significantly from a standard accident. Police will conduct a criminal investigation, the deceased's family may pursue civil claims, and anyone involved—whether as a driver, passenger, or witness—may face questions from law enforcement, insurance companies, and attorneys. Understanding what happens next and what your own legal position is can prevent mistakes that cost money or create liability you did not anticipate.

The Yarmouth Police Department, like all law enforcement agencies, will document the scene, interview witnesses, and determine whether criminal charges are warranted. That investigation runs parallel to insurance claims and potential civil lawsuits. Your when ready steps depend on whether you were the driver, a passenger, a witness, or the family of the deceased.

Key Takeaways

  • If you were driving, do not speak to police beyond providing your name, address, and insurance information—anything else should wait for a lawyer.
  • Police will investigate whether the crash was criminal (reckless driving, DUI, speeding) or civil (negligence), and the outcome affects both criminal and civil liability.
  • The family of the deceased can file a wrongful death claim against the at-fault driver's insurance, which is separate from any criminal case.
  • Witness statements given at the scene become part of the police report and can be used in both criminal prosecution and civil lawsuits.
  • Medical records, toxicology results, and vehicle inspection reports take weeks or months to complete and determine what charges or claims are possible.

What happens in the police investigation

Yarmouth Police will find the scene, photograph vehicle damage and road conditions, and collect statements from the driver, passengers, and witnesses. They will request medical records from the hospital, toxicology results from the medical examiner, and vehicle maintenance records. This process typically takes several weeks.

The investigation determines two things: whether the driver committed a crime (such as operating under the influence, reckless driving, or negligent homicide) and who was at fault for the crash. These are separate questions. A driver can be found criminally responsible and also civilly liable, or one without the other. The police report becomes public record once the investigation closes, and both the prosecutor and the deceased's family will use it to decide next steps.

If you were the driver involved in the crash

Do not give a recorded statement to police without a lawyer present. You are required to provide your name, address, driver's license, and insurance information, but anything beyond that—how fast you were going, whether you saw the other vehicle, what you were doing before the crash—should be discussed only with an attorney first. Police will ask detailed questions; answering them can create evidence that is used against you in both criminal and civil cases.

Contact a criminal defense attorney when ready. Even if you believe the crash was not your fault, police may be investigating you for a crime, and you need legal counsel before that information is made. Your attorney can also advise you on whether to speak with your insurance company and what to say.

Do not post about the crash on social media, do not discuss it with friends or family in writing, and do not contact the family of the deceased. Anything you say can be discovered by the prosecutor or the family's attorney and used against you.

If you were a passenger or witness

Police will ask you for a statement at the scene or later. You can provide factual information about what you saw—the vehicles involved, the direction they were traveling, the weather, the road condition—without legal representation. However, if you are asked about the driver's behavior, speed, or state of mind, and you are uncertain, say so rather than guessing.

Your statement becomes part of the police report and may be used in criminal prosecution or a civil lawsuit. If you witnessed the crash and believe you have important information, you can contact Yarmouth Police directly to give a formal statement. Keep a record of when you spoke to police and what you told them.

Wrongful death claims and civil liability

The family of the deceased can file a wrongful death claim against the at-fault driver's insurance company. This claim seeks compensation for funeral expenses, lost income the deceased would have earned, and the family's loss of companionship. The claim is filed through the at-fault driver's liability insurance, not through a separate lawsuit initially.

If the insurance company denies the claim or the family believes the settlement offer is too low, the family's attorney can file a civil lawsuit in Superior Court. That lawsuit is separate from any criminal case and uses a lower standard of proof (preponderance of the evidence rather than beyond a reasonable doubt). A driver can be acquitted of criminal charges and still be found liable in civil court.

The family typically has three years from the date of death to file a wrongful death lawsuit, though this important date can be extended in some circumstances. An attorney representing the family will review the police report, medical examiner's findings, and witness statements to determine whether a claim is viable.

Criminal charges and sentencing

The prosecutor will review the police investigation and decide whether to bring charges. Possible charges range from negligent homicide (the least serious) to second-degree murder (the most serious), depending on the driver's conduct. Operating under the influence, excessive speed, or a pattern of reckless driving increases the severity of charges.

If the driver is charged, the case moves through the criminal justice system: arraignment, discovery, pretrial motions, and either a plea agreement or trial. The sentence for a fatal crash conviction varies widely based on the specific charge and the driver's history. A conviction can result in prison time, license suspension, and a permanent criminal record.

Accessing the police report and investigation records

Once the police investigation is complete, the report becomes public record. You can request a copy from Yarmouth Police Records Division by submitting a public records request. The report will include the officer's narrative, witness statements, diagrams, and photographs. Some information—such as the identity of juvenile witnesses or ongoing investigative details—may be redacted.

If criminal charges are filed, the prosecutor's file (called discovery) becomes available to the defendant's attorney and, in some cases, to the public. Medical examiner's reports and toxicology results are also public record once the investigation closes. An attorney can help you understand what the records show and what they mean for your case.

When you need a lawyer

If you were the driver, you need a criminal defense attorney before you speak to police beyond providing basic identification and insurance information. If you were a passenger or witness, you do not need a lawyer to give a statement to police, but you should understand that your statement is permanent and may be used in court.

If you are the family of the deceased, a wrongful death attorney can review the police report and advise you on whether a claim against the driver's insurance is viable and what compensation you may be may have access to to. Many attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of any settlement or judgment rather than charging an upfront fee.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be charged with a crime if the other driver caused the crash?

No, not based on the crash alone. However, if you were driving recklessly, under the influence, or violating traffic laws at the time, you could be charged regardless of who caused the collision. The police investigation determines fault and whether your conduct was criminal.

What if I was a passenger and the driver was my friend or family member?

You can still give a truthful statement to police. Your statement is not a betrayal; it is factual information about what happened. If you witnessed the crash, police will want to know what you saw. You are not required to protect the driver by lying.

How long does it take for police to finish investigating a fatal crash?

Most investigations take four to eight weeks, though complex cases can take longer. The timeline depends on how quickly the medical examiner completes the autopsy, toxicology results come back, and vehicle inspections are finished. Police will notify you when the investigation is closed.

Can the family sue even if the driver is not convicted of a crime?

Yes. A civil wrongful death lawsuit uses a lower standard of proof than a criminal case. A driver can be acquitted in criminal court and still be found liable in civil court for the death. The family's attorney will pursue the civil claim based on the evidence available.

What should I do if I hit a parked car and left the scene?

Contact a criminal defense attorney when ready. Leaving the scene of a crash that results in death is a serious crime. An attorney can advise you on whether to turn yourself in and what to expect. The sooner you act, the better your position in negotiations with the prosecutor.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.