How Disney's Motion to Dismiss Works in Wrongful Death Cases
What Disney's motion to dismiss actually does
When Disney files a motion to dismiss in a wrongful death case, it is asking the court to throw out the lawsuit before trial — not because the facts are wrong, but because the law does not allow that particular claim to proceed. A motion to dismiss does not decide who is right about what happened. It decides whether the person suing has the legal right to sue at all, or whether the claim is structured in a way the law recognizes.
The most common reason a company files this motion is to argue that the plaintiff cannot hold them responsible under the law, even if everything the plaintiff says is true. For example, Disney might argue that a specific state law shields them from liability, or that the plaintiff did not follow the legal steps required to bring a wrongful death case. The judge reads both sides' arguments and decides: does this case have a legal leg to stand on, or should it be dismissed now?
If the judge grants the motion, the case ends — though the plaintiff can usually appeal. If the judge denies it, the case moves forward to discovery, settlement talks, or trial.
Key Takeaways
- A motion to dismiss argues the lawsuit should end before trial because the law does not allow this type of claim, not because the facts are disputed.
- Disney typically argues either that state law shields them from liability or that the plaintiff did not follow required legal procedures.
- The judge decides the motion based on the legal arguments alone — not on whether Disney's version of events is true.
- If the motion is denied, the case continues; if granted, the plaintiff can usually appeal to a higher court.
- The outcome of a motion to dismiss does not determine fault or damages — it only determines whether the case can proceed.
Common legal arguments Disney uses in these motions
Disney often relies on assumption of risk — the argument that by entering a theme park, a visitor accepts certain inherent dangers. Theme parks involve moving rides, crowds, and mechanical equipment. Disney argues that visitors understand these risks and cannot sue the park for injuries that result from those ordinary hazards. This argument is stronger in some states than others, and courts weigh it differently depending on what actually caused the death.
Another frequent argument is sovereign immunity or governmental immunity, which applies when Disney operates under a government contract or license. Some states grant theme parks limited immunity for certain types of claims. Disney will cite these statutes to argue the court lacks the power to hear the case.
Disney may also argue that the plaintiff did not follow notice requirements — rules that say you must notify the park of an injury within a certain time frame, or file a claim within a specific window. If the plaintiff missed these important date, the motion to dismiss can succeed even if the underlying claim is strong.
A fourth argument involves comparative fault. Disney might claim that the person who died was partly responsible for their own death — for instance, by ignoring safety instructions or entering a restricted area. Some states bar wrongful death claims if the deceased was more than 50 percent at fault. Disney uses this argument to say the claim should be dismissed or reduced.
What happens during the motion to dismiss process
The plaintiff's lawyer files a wrongful death complaint, laying out the facts and the legal claims. Disney then has a set time — usually 21 days in federal court, but it varies by state — to file a motion to dismiss. Disney's lawyers write a brief explaining why the court should not hear the case, citing specific laws and court rulings.
The plaintiff's lawyer files a response brief arguing why the motion should be denied. Disney may file a reply. In some cases, the judge holds a hearing where both sides argue in person; in others, the judge decides based on the written briefs alone.
The judge then issues a ruling. If the motion is granted in full, the case ends. If it is granted in part, some claims survive and others are dismissed. If it is denied, discovery begins — the process where both sides exchange documents, take depositions, and gather evidence.
How the judge decides a motion to dismiss
The judge must accept all of the plaintiff's factual claims as true for purposes of the motion. The question is not whether those facts are actually true, but whether they are legally sufficient — meaning, if a jury believed them, would the law allow the plaintiff to win?
The judge also looks at whether the complaint is clear enough. If the plaintiff's claims are so vague or confused that Disney cannot understand what it is being accused of, the motion may succeed on those grounds alone.
The judge applies the law of the state where the case is filed. A motion to dismiss in Florida might succeed based on Florida's recreational use statute, while the same motion in California might fail because California's law is different. This is why the location of the lawsuit matters enormously in wrongful death cases.
What a successful motion to dismiss means for the plaintiff
If Disney wins the motion, the case does not end permanently — the plaintiff can appeal to a higher court. An appeal of a motion to dismiss ruling focuses on whether the lower court applied the law correctly, not on the facts of what happened. Appeals take months or years, and the higher court may reverse the dismissal and send the case back to trial.
The plaintiff may also have the chance to file an amended complaint — a revised version that addresses the judge's legal concerns. For example, if the judge dismissed the case because the complaint was unclear, the plaintiff can rewrite it more clearly and file it again. Disney can then file another motion to dismiss, but the amended complaint might survive.
If the appeal fails and the case is dismissed with prejudice (meaning it cannot be refiled), the plaintiff's case is over. If it is dismissed without prejudice, the plaintiff can sometimes start over in a different court or with a different legal theory.
Why Disney files these motions even when facts are disputed
A motion to dismiss is a low-cost way to end a case before the expense of discovery and trial. Even if Disney believes it will win at trial, dismissing the case early saves millions in legal fees and avoids the risk of a jury verdict. From a business perspective, it is worth filing the motion even if the chances of success are modest.
These motions also buy time. While the motion is pending, the case does not move forward. If Disney wins, the case ends. If Disney loses, it has still delayed the plaintiff's path to trial by months, which can pressure the plaintiff to settle.
Additionally, a successful motion to dismiss can set a legal precedent in that state or district, making it easier for Disney to dismiss similar cases in the future.
What to expect if you are involved in a wrongful death case against a large company
A motion to dismiss is standard in wrongful death litigation against major corporations. It does not mean Disney is confident it will win at trial, and it does not mean the case is weak. It is a routine legal tactic. Expect Disney to file one, expect the plaintiff's lawyer to oppose it, and expect the judge to take weeks or months to rule.
If you are the plaintiff in such a case, your lawyer should explain the specific legal arguments Disney is making and why they believe the motion will be denied. If your lawyer thinks the motion has a real chance of succeeding, you should discuss settlement options now, before the case is dismissed.
If you are considering filing a wrongful death claim, understand that the location of the lawsuit — which state's courts hear it — will heavily influence whether a motion to dismiss succeeds. Your lawyer's choice of where to file can determine the outcome before any facts are even presented.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a motion to dismiss mean Disney admits the facts in the complaint?
No. For purposes of the motion, the judge assumes the facts are true, but Disney is not admitting anything. Disney is saying: even if everything you claim happened, the law does not allow you to sue us for it. The motion is purely a legal argument, not a factual concession.
Can a case be refiled after a motion to dismiss is granted?
Sometimes. If the judge dismisses the case without prejudice, you can file again — usually with an amended complaint that addresses the legal problems the judge identified. If the dismissal is with prejudice, the case is over and cannot be refiled in that court. You may be able to appeal instead.
How long does it take for a judge to rule on a motion to dismiss?
It varies widely. Some judges rule within weeks; others take several months. The timeline depends on the judge's workload, the complexity of the legal issues, and whether a hearing is held. Your lawyer should have a sense of the typical timeline in that particular court.
What is the difference between a motion to dismiss and a summary judgment motion?
A motion to dismiss argues the case should end before discovery because the law does not allow it. A summary judgment motion comes later, after discovery, and argues there are no real facts in dispute — so even if a jury heard the evidence, Disney would win as a matter of law. Summary judgment is a stronger tool for the defendant.
If the motion to dismiss is denied, does that mean the plaintiff will win at trial?
No. Denying the motion means the case can proceed — that the law allows the claim. It says nothing about whether the plaintiff will actually win. Disney can still win at trial, or the case may settle before trial. The motion to dismiss is only a threshold question about whether the case is legally valid.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.