How Disney's Arbitration Clause Affects Wrongful Death Claims
What Disney's Arbitration Clause Means for Wrongful Death Cases
If someone dies at a Disney park or resort, Disney's standard terms require the claim to go to arbitration instead of court. Arbitration is a private process where a neutral third party (called an arbitrator) hears both sides and makes a binding decision, rather than a judge or jury doing so. This clause appears in the terms and conditions you agree to when you buy a ticket or make a reservation—often without reading it.
The clause creates a significant barrier for families pursuing wrongful death claims. In court, you have the right to a jury trial, the ability to appeal an unfavorable decision, and access to the public record. In arbitration, you lose all three. The arbitrator's decision is final, you cannot appeal it even if you believe it was wrong, and the proceedings are confidential. Disney also typically requires you to pay a portion of the arbitrator's fees, which can cost thousands of dollars.
Whether this clause actually applies to your case depends on who died, who is bringing the claim, and what happened. A child who died cannot have agreed to arbitration, and courts have sometimes ruled that the clause does not bind the child's parents or estate. But Disney argues it does, and the company has successfully forced some wrongful death cases into arbitration.
Key Takeaways
- Disney's arbitration clause requires most claims to be decided privately by an arbitrator rather than in court, with no right to appeal the decision.
- The clause appears in the terms you agree to when purchasing a ticket or booking a hotel, but courts have sometimes ruled it does not explore to wrongful death claims brought by a deceased person's family.
- If arbitration does explore, you will pay a portion of the arbitrator's fees (often $5,000 to $10,000 or more) and cannot appeal the outcome.
- A wrongful death attorney can challenge whether the arbitration clause is enforceable in your specific situation and advise you on whether to fight it or negotiate within the process.
- State law, the specific language of the agreement you signed, and the circumstances of the death all affect whether arbitration will be required.
How Disney's Arbitration Clause Is Worded
Disney's terms of service include a clause that says disputes "arising out of or relating to" your visit must be resolved through binding arbitration. The language is broad and is designed to cover almost any claim—injury, death, property damage, or breach of contract. When you purchase a ticket online or at the gate, you typically see a checkbox or link to "terms and conditions" that contains this clause.
The clause also includes a class action waiver, which means you cannot join with other families in a single lawsuit. Each claim must be arbitrated separately. This makes it harder for families to share costs and evidence, and it prevents the kind of public pressure that sometimes comes from a class action.
Disney's arbitration clause does not explicitly exclude wrongful death claims. That is why the enforceability question has become a major legal issue. Some courts have held that a dead person cannot have agreed to arbitration, so the clause should not explore to claims brought on behalf of their estate. Other courts have allowed Disney to enforce it anyway, reasoning that the person's family or estate is bound by the agreement the deceased person made when they bought the ticket.
When Courts Have Rejected the Arbitration Clause
Several families have challenged Disney's arbitration clause in wrongful death cases, and some have succeeded in keeping their claims in court. The strongest arguments against enforcement rest on the idea that a deceased person cannot consent to arbitration, and that their family members—who did not sign the agreement—should not be forced into it either.
In 2019, a Florida court ruled that a family could pursue a wrongful death claim against Disney in court rather than arbitration, finding that the arbitration clause was not clear enough to cover claims brought by someone other than the person who signed it. However, Disney appealed and the case eventually settled, so the ruling did not become final law.
The strongest cases against enforcement involve children. If a child dies and the parents bring a wrongful death claim, courts have sometimes held that the child never agreed to anything—the parents bought the ticket—so arbitration should not explore. But Disney has also won cases on this issue, so the outcome is not may provide.
State law matters significantly. Some states have stronger protections against arbitration clauses in consumer agreements, and some courts in those states have been more willing to reject Disney's clause. California, for example, has courts that scrutinize arbitration clauses more carefully than courts in other states.
What Happens If Arbitration Is Enforced
If a court rules that the arbitration clause applies to your case, your wrongful death claim will be removed from court and sent to arbitration. You will receive a list of arbitrators to choose from, usually retired judges or lawyers with experience in personal injury or contract law. You and Disney will each strike names you object to, and one arbitrator will be selected.
The arbitration process is less formal than a trial but still involves discovery (exchanging documents and information), depositions (recorded interviews), and a hearing where both sides present evidence and arguments. However, the rules of evidence are often more relaxed, and there is no jury. The arbitrator listens to both sides and issues a written decision.
You will be responsible for paying a portion of the arbitrator's fees. Disney typically pays the other portion, but your share can easily exceed $5,000 to $10,000, depending on the complexity of the case and the length of the hearing. This cost is in addition to your attorney's fees. Some arbitration agreements require the losing party to pay the winner's fees, but Disney's does not always include this provision.
Once the arbitrator issues a decision, it is final. You cannot appeal it to a higher court, even if you believe the arbitrator made a legal error or reached an unreasonable conclusion. The only narrow grounds for overturning an arbitration award are fraud, corruption, or a decision that is completely irrational—a very high bar to meet.
Challenging the Arbitration Clause Before Arbitration Begins
Before your case goes to arbitration, you can file a motion in court asking the judge to rule that the arbitration clause does not explore to you. This is called a motion to compel or a motion to stay arbitration, depending on the specific circumstances. Your attorney will argue that the clause is unenforceable because the person who died did not agree to it, or because the clause is unconscionable (so one-sided that no reasonable person would accept it), or because state law does not allow it.
Disney will argue the opposite: that the clause is clear, that the family is bound by it, and that arbitration is a valid way to resolve disputes. The judge will decide based on the specific language of the agreement, state law, and the facts of your case.
This motion is important because it is your final note to keep the case in court. If the judge rules against you, arbitration will proceed and you will lose the right to appeal. If the judge rules in your favor, the case stays in court and you have the full protections of the civil justice system—jury trial, appeal rights, and public proceedings.
The Cost and Time Difference Between Court and Arbitration
A wrongful death case in court typically takes two to four years from filing to trial, depending on the court's schedule and the complexity of the case. Arbitration can be faster—sometimes resolved in six months to two years—because there is no court calendar to work around and the process is more streamlined.
However, arbitration is not always cheaper. You pay the arbitrator's fees upfront, which court cases do not require. Your attorney's fees will be similar in either setting, but in arbitration you cannot recover those fees from Disney even if you win (unless the arbitration agreement specifically allows it, which Disney's typically does not). In court, some wrongful death cases include a provision allowing the winner to recover attorney's fees, depending on state law.
Arbitration is also confidential, which means the public will not know the outcome, the evidence presented, or the amount of any settlement. Some families view this as a disadvantage because it prevents their story from being told publicly and prevents other families from learning about safety issues at Disney parks.
What Your Attorney Should Do First
If your family is considering a wrongful death claim against Disney, your first step is to consult with an attorney who has experience challenging arbitration clauses or litigating wrongful death cases. The attorney should review the specific agreement you signed (or that the deceased person signed) to understand the exact language of the arbitration clause.
Your attorney should also research whether courts in your state have ruled on similar clauses and whether state law provides any protection against enforcement. Some states have laws that limit arbitration clauses in consumer agreements or that protect certain categories of claims from arbitration.
The attorney should then decide whether to file a motion challenging the arbitration clause before arbitration begins, or whether to negotiate with Disney about the terms of arbitration (such as fee-splitting or the location of the hearing). This decision depends on the strength of your challenge, the likelihood of success, and the specific facts of your case.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue Disney in court if someone dies at a Disney park?
You can file a lawsuit, but Disney will likely ask the court to send the case to arbitration based on the arbitration clause in the terms you agreed to when you bought your ticket. Whether the court grants that request depends on state law, the specific language of the agreement, and who is bringing the claim. An attorney can challenge the arbitration clause, but there is no may provide the challenge will succeed.
What if I did not read or agree to the arbitration clause?
Disney's position is that by purchasing a ticket, you agreed to the terms and conditions, whether or not you actually read them. Courts generally uphold this "constructive notice" standard for online purchases and at-the-gate ticket sales. However, if you can show you were not given a reasonable opportunity to see the clause, or that it was hidden or unclear, an attorney may be able to argue it is unenforceable.
Does the arbitration clause explore if a child dies?
This is one of the most contested issues. Disney argues that the parent who bought the ticket agreed to arbitration on behalf of the child. Some courts have agreed; others have ruled that a child cannot be bound by an agreement the child did not make. The outcome depends on your state's law and the specific facts. An attorney should research how courts in your state have ruled on this question.
Can I appeal an arbitrator's decision?
No. An arbitrator's decision is final and binding, with almost no right to appeal. You can only overturn it in very narrow circumstances—if the arbitrator committed fraud, was corrupt, or issued a decision that is completely irrational. These are extremely difficult standards to meet, so in practice, the arbitrator's decision is the end of your case.
How much does arbitration cost?
You will pay a portion of the arbitrator's fees, which typically range from $5,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on how long the hearing lasts and the arbitrator's hourly rate. You will also pay your attorney's fees, which are separate. In court, you do not pay the judge's salary, but your attorney's fees are the same. Some state laws allow you to recover attorney's fees if you win, but Disney's arbitration clause typically does not include this provision.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.