Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Discovery Documents a Wrongful Death Plaintiff Must Exchange

What Discovery Means in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit

Discovery is the legal process where both sides of a lawsuit exchange documents, answer written questions, and provide testimony before trial. In a wrongful death case, discovery is how the plaintiff's attorney (representing the deceased's family) and the defendant's attorney gather evidence to build their cases. Neither side can surprise the other at trial with documents or facts that should have been shared earlier.

As the plaintiff in a wrongful death case, you and your attorney will both request documents from the defendant and provide documents the defendant requests from you. The defendant will also ask you written questions under oath, called interrogatories, and may depose you—meaning you answer questions in person while a court reporter records everything you say.

Discovery is mandatory in civil cases. You cannot refuse to hand over documents or answer questions straightforward because the answers hurt your case. The court enforces discovery rules, and failure to comply can result in sanctions, dismissal of your case, or a judgment against you before trial even begins.

Key Takeaways

  • Discovery requires you to produce documents related to the deceased, the incident, and your damages—medical records, financial records, communications, and photographs are common examples.
  • You must answer written interrogatories under oath and sit for a deposition where the defendant's attorney questions you while a court reporter records your testimony.
  • The defendant will request documents and information from you, and you have a legal duty to search for and produce everything that is relevant, even if it helps their case.
  • Failure to produce documents or answer discovery requests can result in court sanctions, including fines, dismissal of your case, or a default judgment in the defendant's favor.
  • Your attorney can object to certain requests on legal grounds—such as attorney-client privilege or trade secrets—but objections must be specific and documented in writing.

Types of Documents You Will Produce as a Plaintiff

As the plaintiff, you will produce documents in several categories. First are documents related to the deceased: birth certificate, death certificate, medical records from the time of injury through death, autopsy reports (if available), and any prior medical history that shows the defendant's conduct caused the fatal injury.

Second are documents about the incident itself: photographs or video of the scene, police reports, witness statements you have collected, your own written accounts of what happened, text messages or emails about the incident, and any communications with the defendant or their insurance company. If the incident involved a vehicle, product, or property, you may also produce maintenance records, inspection reports, or prior complaints about similar incidents.

Third are documents showing your damages—the financial and emotional harm caused by the death. These include funeral and burial bills, probate or estate administration documents, the deceased's tax returns and pay stubs (to show lost earnings), medical bills for the deceased's final care, and receipts for any services you hired because the deceased is no longer alive to provide them. You may also produce journals, photographs, or written accounts of your grief and the impact of the death on your family.

Fourth are documents about you and your household: your own tax returns, employment records, insurance policies, and any prior lawsuits or claims you have filed. The defendant uses these to understand your financial situation and credibility as a witness.

Written Questions You Must Answer Under Oath

Interrogatories are written questions the defendant's attorney sends to you. You must answer them in writing, under oath, within a set time frame—usually 30 days, though your attorney can request an extension. Your attorney helps you draft the answers, but you sign them under penalty of perjury, meaning you are swearing the answers are true.

Interrogatories in a wrongful death case typically ask: How did you learn of the deceased's death? What is your relationship to the deceased? What damages have you suffered? What medical treatment did the deceased receive? What witnesses do you know? What documents do you have? What is the basis for your claim that the defendant is liable? Have you discussed the case with anyone, and if so, who?

You cannot refuse to answer interrogatories straightforward because the answer is unfavorable. You can object only on specific legal grounds—for example, if the question asks for attorney-client communications, or if the question is so vague it is impossible to answer fairly. Any objection must be stated in writing and must explain why you are objecting. If you object without a valid reason, the court can order you to answer, and you may face sanctions.

Depositions: In-Person Questioning Under Oath

A deposition is a meeting where the defendant's attorney questions you in person while a court reporter sits nearby and records every word. Your own attorney will be present and can object to questions, but cannot tell you what to say. The deposition usually takes place in a conference room or law office, not in a courtroom, and typically lasts between two and eight hours depending on the complexity of the case.

Before the deposition, the defendant's attorney will send you a notice stating the date, time, and location. Your attorney will prepare you by reviewing likely questions, reminding you to answer only what is asked, and coaching you on how to stay calm if the questioning becomes aggressive. The defendant's attorney will ask about your relationship to the deceased, the circumstances of the death, your knowledge of the defendant's conduct, your damages, and your credibility as a witness.

You must answer truthfully. Lying at a deposition is perjury and can result in criminal charges. If you do not know the answer to a question, say so rather than guessing. If you do not understand the question, ask for clarification. If your attorney objects, stop talking and wait for the attorney to explain the objection before you answer.

The defendant's attorney may also depose other witnesses—the deceased's employer, medical providers, police officers, or family members. Your attorney can attend those depositions and object to questions, but the witness must answer unless your attorney's objection is sustained.

What the Defendant Must Produce to You

Discovery is two-way. Your attorney will send the defendant written requests for documents and interrogatories as well. The defendant must produce documents in their possession or control that are relevant to the case—for example, business records showing negligence, communications about the incident, insurance policies, prior complaints about similar incidents, and any statements the defendant made about what happened.

If the defendant is a business or government entity, they must search their files thoroughly and produce everything that exists, even if it is damaging to their case. If a document has been lost or destroyed, the defendant must explain when and how it was lost. If the defendant claims a document is privileged—such as a communication with their attorney—they must list it and explain why it is privileged.

Your attorney will review everything the defendant produces and may depose the defendant's employees, the defendant themselves, or informed witnesses the defendant plans to use at trial. These depositions give your attorney a chance to lock in the defendant's story and identify weaknesses in their defense.

Objections and Disputes Over Discovery

Either side can object to a discovery request on specific legal grounds. Attorney-client privilege protects communications between you and your lawyer about the case. Work product doctrine protects documents your attorney created in preparation for trial, such as legal strategy memos or witness interview notes. Trade secrets may be protected if the defendant claims a document contains confidential business information.

An objection must be stated in writing and must explain the legal basis. A blanket refusal to produce documents—saying "this is private" or "I do not want to answer"—is not valid. If the defendant objects to your request and your attorney believes the objection is improper, your attorney can file a motion to compel, asking the court to order the defendant to produce the document or answer the question. The court will decide whether the objection is valid.

If you fail to produce a document without a valid objection, or if you produce it late, the defendant can file a motion for sanctions. Sanctions can include fines, an order that you pay the defendant's attorney fees for the dispute, or in serious cases, dismissal of your case or a default judgment in the defendant's favor.

Timeline and important date for Discovery

Discovery important date are set by the court's scheduling order, which is issued early in the case. Typically, the parties have 30 days to respond to document requests and interrogatories, though the court can extend this time if the parties agree or if one side shows good cause. Depositions are usually scheduled weeks or months after document requests, giving both sides time to review what has been produced.

Discovery is not a one-time event. It continues throughout the case until the court sets a discovery important date, usually 60 to 90 days before trial. After that date, neither side can request new documents or take new depositions without court permission. Your attorney will manage these important date and remind you when you need to provide information or appear for a deposition.

If you miss a important date, notify your attorney when ready. Your attorney can request an extension from the other side or file a motion asking the court for extra time. Missing a important date without seeking relief can result in sanctions and can seriously damage your case.

How to Prepare Documents for Production

When your attorney tells you to produce documents, gather everything in the categories the defendant requested. Search your email, text messages, cloud storage, and physical files. If you have documents stored on your phone or computer, make sure your attorney knows how to access them. Do not delete anything, even if you think it is irrelevant or unhelpful—that is called spoliation and is illegal. Destroying documents after a lawsuit is filed can result in severe sanctions.

Your attorney will review the documents before they are sent to the defendant. The attorney may redact (black out) information that is privileged or irrelevant, but redactions must be clearly marked and explained. All documents should be organized logically—by date, by category, or by both—so the defendant's attorney can find what they need.

Keep copies of everything you produce. You may need to refer to documents during your deposition, and your attorney will want to review them with you beforehand. If the defendant claims you did not produce a document, you will need proof that you did.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I refuse to answer a discovery question because it is embarrassing or private?

No. Discovery is designed to uncover all relevant facts, even uncomfortable ones. You can object only on specific legal grounds—attorney-client privilege, work product, trade secrets, or if the question is so vague or burdensome it is unreasonable. Personal embarrassment is not a valid objection. Your attorney will advise you on what you must answer.

What happens if I lie during a deposition?

Lying under oath is perjury, a criminal offense. The defendant's attorney will use the false testimony to attack your credibility at trial, and the court may refer you to the prosecutor for criminal charges. Always tell the truth, even if the answer hurts your case. Your attorney can help you explain the answer in context.

Can the defendant ask me about my personal life or finances that have nothing to do with the death?

The defendant can ask about your finances and background to understand your damages and credibility, but the questions must be relevant to the case. If a question is clearly irrelevant or harassing, your attorney can object. The court will decide whether the objection is valid. Some personal information may be discoverable even if it seems unrelated.

What if I cannot find a document the defendant requested?

Tell your attorney when ready. Your attorney will search your files and may file a declaration (a sworn statement) explaining that the document does not exist or cannot be located. If the document was destroyed or lost, explain when and how. Do not claim a document is lost if you straightforward have not looked for it carefully.

Can my attorney tell me what to say at my deposition?

Your attorney can prepare you by reviewing likely questions and coaching you on how to answer clearly and truthfully. Your attorney cannot tell you to lie or to refuse to answer a valid question. During the deposition itself, your attorney can object to questions but cannot instruct you on what answer to give. You must answer in your own words.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.