How to Evaluate Wrongful Death Attorneys Using Their Settlement History
What past settlements tell you about an attorney's track record
A wrongful death attorney's settlement history is one of the few concrete ways to measure whether they have actually won cases like yours. Settlements are real money paid to real clients—not promises or credentials. When you look at what an attorney has recovered in past cases, you learn three things: whether they win at all, what kinds of cases they win, and roughly what range of money similar cases have brought.
The catch is that settlement amounts alone are misleading. A $2 million settlement in a case where the deceased earned $30,000 a year means something very different from a $2 million settlement where the deceased was a surgeon. The circumstances of each death, the defendant's insurance coverage, the state's damage caps, and how aggressively the attorney negotiated all change what "good" looks like. You need to know what questions to ask and what numbers actually matter.
Key Takeaways
- Ask for settlements in cases similar to yours—same type of death, same state, same defendant type—because a $5 million medical malpractice settlement tells you nothing about a car accident case.
- Settlements are often confidential, so attorneys may show you ranges or case descriptions instead of exact amounts; ask why a settlement is not disclosed before assuming the attorney is hiding something.
- Compare the settlement to what the deceased would have earned over their lifetime, not to the raw dollar number, because a larger settlement in a lower-income case may represent better negotiation.
- Ask whether the attorney took the case to trial or settled before trial, because settlement amounts often reflect what the insurance company was willing to pay, not what a jury might have awarded.
- Request the attorney's loss rate—how many cases they have lost or dismissed—because winning some cases is different from winning most cases.
How to request settlement information from an attorney
Most wrongful death attorneys will provide some settlement history during an initial consultation, but what they show you depends on what you ask for. Start by being specific: tell the attorney the type of death (car accident, medical error, workplace injury, product defect), the state where it happened, and roughly what the deceased earned. Then ask whether the attorney has settled similar cases and what the range was.
If an attorney says they cannot disclose exact amounts, ask why. Many settlements include confidentiality clauses that prevent the attorney from naming the amount or the defendant. That is a legitimate reason. But the attorney should still be able to tell you the range—"between $800,000 and $1.2 million"—or describe the case in enough detail that you can evaluate it. If an attorney refuses to give you any numbers or ranges, that is a red flag worth noting.
Ask for at least three to five cases, not just one. A single large settlement might be an outlier. Multiple cases show you what the attorney typically recovers. Also ask whether those cases went to trial or settled before trial, because the path to settlement changes what the number means.
What to compare beyond the dollar amount
The raw settlement number is the least useful piece of information. What matters is what that money represents relative to the deceased's economic loss. If the deceased was 28 years old and earned $45,000 a year, they had roughly 37 years of earning potential left—about $1.67 million in lost wages alone, before adding medical expenses, funeral costs, and pain and suffering damages. A $1.8 million settlement in that case is modest. A $1.8 million settlement for a 72-year-old who earned $35,000 a year is substantial, because their remaining earning years were fewer.
Compare the settlement to the defendant's insurance coverage. If the defendant had a $1 million policy limit and the attorney recovered $950,000, they negotiated well within the constraints. If the defendant had a $5 million policy and the attorney recovered $950,000, that suggests either the case was weak or the negotiation was not aggressive. Ask the attorney what the policy limits were in the cases they describe.
Also compare across case types. A medical malpractice settlement is not comparable to a car accident settlement because juries and insurance companies value them differently. A product liability case is not comparable to a workplace death. Ask the attorney for settlements in the specific category your case falls into.
Trial verdicts versus pre-trial settlements
An attorney who tells you about a $3 million jury verdict is showing you something different from an attorney who settled for $3 million before trial. A verdict is what a jury decided the case was worth. A settlement is what the insurance company was willing to pay to avoid trial. Settlements are usually lower than verdicts because the defendant avoids the risk of a larger award.
Ask the attorney how many of their cases went to trial and how many settled. An attorney who settles 95 percent of cases may be good at negotiation, or may be avoiding trial because they lose there. An attorney who takes 40 percent of cases to trial may be more aggressive, or may be turning down straightforward settlements. Neither is automatically better—it depends on the outcomes. But the ratio tells you something about the attorney's strategy.
If an attorney shows you a trial verdict, ask what the jury awarded for economic damages (lost wages and expenses) versus non-economic damages (pain and suffering). That breakdown matters because it shows you what the jury thought the death was worth beyond just the money the deceased would have earned.
Red flags in an attorney's settlement history
Be cautious if an attorney refuses to discuss losses. Every attorney loses cases or has cases dismissed. If an attorney only talks about wins and never mentions a case that did not result in a settlement, they are not giving you the full picture. Ask directly: "What percentage of your wrongful death cases result in a settlement or verdict?" A realistic answer is usually 60 to 80 percent, depending on the type of case.
Be cautious if all the settlements are very old. If the most recent case the attorney describes settled five years ago, ask why. Have they taken fewer wrongful death cases recently? Have they moved to a different practice area? Recent cases are more relevant because law, insurance practices, and damage awards change.
Be cautious if the attorney cannot explain why a particular settlement was the amount it was. A good attorney can tell you: "The deceased was 34, earned $52,000 a year, and had 31 years of earning potential. The defendant had a $2 million policy. We settled for $1.9 million, which was essentially the policy limit." That explanation shows they understand the math. If they just say "we got a great result," that is not enough.
Be cautious if the attorney's settlements are all in cases where the defendant was obviously at fault (like a drunk driver) or where the defendant had very high insurance coverage. Those cases are easier to settle. Ask about cases where liability was disputed or the insurance was lower, because those are harder and more instructive.
Questions to ask during your consultation
Bring a list of specific questions to your initial consultation. Ask: "What is the range of settlements you have recovered in cases like mine?" Ask: "What was the deceased's age and income in those cases?" Ask: "What was the defendant's insurance coverage?" Ask: "Did those cases go to trial or settle before trial?" Ask: "What percentage of your wrongful death cases result in a settlement or verdict, and what percentage are dismissed or lost?"
Ask whether the attorney will provide references from past clients. Some attorneys cannot because of confidentiality agreements, but some can. A past client can tell you whether the attorney communicated clearly, whether the settlement process took longer than expected, and whether they felt the attorney fought for them.
Ask whether the attorney works with an investigator or informed witnesses, because cases with stronger evidence tend to settle for more. An attorney who describes hiring an accident reconstructionist or a medical informed is showing you they invest in building the case, not just negotiating.
How settlement ranges vary by state and case type
Wrongful death settlements vary significantly by state because each state has different damage caps, different jury pools, and different insurance practices. A settlement that is typical in California may be unusually high or low in another state. If your case is in a state where the attorney primarily practices in a different state, ask them specifically about cases in your state.
Settlements also vary by how the death occurred. Medical malpractice cases often settle for more than car accidents because juries view them as more culpable. Workplace deaths may be limited by workers' compensation laws. Product liability cases depend heavily on whether the product was obviously defective. Ask the attorney for settlements in the specific category your case fits.
If an attorney has very few cases in your state or case type, that is not necessarily disqualifying—they may be excellent—but it means their settlement history is less relevant to your case. In that situation, ask whether they have consulted with local attorneys or experts who know your state's market.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an attorney refuse to tell me about past settlements?
An attorney can refuse to disclose exact amounts if the settlement included a confidentiality clause. But they should provide a range or describe the case in enough detail for you to evaluate it. If an attorney refuses to give you any information about past cases, that is a sign to look elsewhere.
What if an attorney has only one or two wrongful death cases?
One or two cases is not much history to evaluate. Ask how long they have practiced, whether they have handled similar cases in other practice areas, and whether they work with other attorneys or experts on wrongful death cases. An attorney new to wrongful death work is not automatically a bad choice, but you should know that going in.
Should I choose the attorney with the highest settlements?
Not necessarily. The highest settlements often come from cases with the most obvious liability or the highest insurance coverage. A lower settlement in a harder case may reflect better negotiation. Compare settlements in cases similar to yours—same type of death, same state, same defendant type—rather than looking for the highest number overall.
What does it mean if an attorney settled a case for less than I expected?
It could mean the case was weak, the insurance was limited, the deceased's earning potential was low, or the attorney did not negotiate aggressively. Ask the attorney to explain the settlement in detail: what was the deceased's age and income, what was the defendant's insurance, and what was the liability situation? That context tells you whether the settlement was reasonable.
How recent should an attorney's settlements be?
Recent cases are more relevant because law and insurance practices change. If the most recent settlement is more than three years old, ask why. But a settlement from five or six years ago is still useful if it is in a case similar to yours and the attorney can explain what has changed since then.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.