Reading a Wrongful Death Lawyer's Jury Verdicts and Case Results
What jury verdicts actually tell you about a wrongful death attorney
A lawyer's past jury verdicts are one piece of information about their courtroom skill, but they are not the whole picture and they can mislead you if you read them wrong. A large verdict sounds impressive until you learn the defendant was a major corporation with deep insurance, the injuries were catastrophic and obvious, or the jury pool was unusually sympathetic. The same lawyer might lose or settle for much less in a case with a sympathetic defendant, disputed facts, or a jury that straightforward does not believe the client's version of events.
What matters is not the single biggest verdict, but the pattern: Does the lawyer win more often than they lose? Do their verdicts hold up on appeal? Do they settle cases for reasonable amounts when trial is risky? And critically—do they take cases similar to yours, or are they listing verdicts from car accidents when you need someone who handles medical malpractice wrongful death claims?
Key Takeaways
- A single large verdict tells you almost nothing; look instead for the percentage of cases won, the range of verdict amounts, and whether the lawyer regularly handles cases like yours.
- Verdicts from cases with different defendants, injuries, or jury locations are not directly comparable to your situation and may not predict your outcome.
- Settled cases often outnumber jury verdicts and may be more relevant to your case, so ask what percentage of cases settle and at what stage.
- Verdicts that were appealed and reduced or overturned are less meaningful than final judgments, so ask whether the lawyer's verdicts have held up in appeals court.
- The best question is not "What is your biggest verdict?" but "How many wrongful death cases like mine have you taken to jury, and what was the average result?"
The difference between a verdict and a final judgment
A jury verdict is what the jury decides in the courtroom. A final judgment is what remains after all appeals are exhausted. These are not the same thing. An appeals court can reduce a verdict, throw it out entirely, or order a new trial. A lawyer who advertises a $5 million verdict that was later cut to $1.2 million on appeal is technically not lying, but they are showing you the number that looks best, not the number that stuck.
When you ask about verdicts, also ask: "Of the verdicts you list, how many have been appealed? How many were reduced or overturned?" If a lawyer cannot or will not answer this, that is a red flag. A strong track record includes verdicts that survived appeal, not just verdicts that looked good on the day the jury spoke.
Why the type of case matters more than the size of the verdict
A $3 million verdict in a case where a drunk driver killed a 30-year-old with no dependents is not the same as a $3 million verdict in a case where a hospital's negligence killed a 45-year-old surgeon who was the sole provider for three children. The damages are calculated differently. The jury's sympathy is different. The defendant's resources and insurance are different. A verdict that looks large in one context might be small in another.
Before you look at any numbers, ask the lawyer: "What percentage of your wrongful death cases involve medical malpractice?" or "How many cases have you tried where the defendant was a hospital?" or whatever category fits your situation. If the lawyer's big verdicts come from car accident cases and you have a medical malpractice claim, those verdicts do not tell you much about how they will perform in your case.
What to ask about settlement amounts and case outcomes
Most wrongful death cases settle before trial. A lawyer who takes 100 cases to settlement and 5 to jury might have a 100% settlement rate but a 20% trial rate. Both numbers are true and both matter. A high settlement rate can mean the lawyer is skilled at negotiation, or it can mean they take weak cases that should not go to trial. A high trial rate can mean the lawyer is aggressive and confident, or it can mean they turn down reasonable settlements and waste clients' money on long shots.
The right question is: "Of the wrongful death cases you have handled in the past five years, what percentage settled, what percentage went to trial, and what was the average settlement amount?" This tells you whether the lawyer is realistic about case value and whether they know when to push and when to accept a reasonable offer. Ask also whether they have a policy about when they recommend settlement versus trial, and what factors they consider.
How to compare verdicts across different cases and locations
A $2 million verdict in rural Mississippi is not the same as a $2 million verdict in Manhattan. Jury pools, cost of living, wage expectations, and local attitudes toward plaintiffs all vary. A verdict from 2010 is not the same as one from 2024 because inflation, jury expectations, and case law have all shifted. A verdict against a small business is not the same as one against an insurance company or a hospital system.
If a lawyer lists verdicts, ask where they were tried, when, and against what type of defendant. If all the big verdicts are from one county or one type of case, that tells you the lawyer may be strong in that specific context but you cannot assume they will perform the same way in yours. Ask also: "Have you tried cases in the county where my case would be filed? What were the results?" Local experience matters.
Red flags in how lawyers present their verdicts
Be skeptical of a lawyer who lists only the biggest verdict and not the range. Be skeptical of verdicts that are listed without dates, defendant types, or injury descriptions. Be skeptical of a lawyer who cannot explain why a verdict was what it was—what the injuries were, what the liability issues were, what the jury seemed to care about. Be skeptical of a lawyer who lists verdicts from cases they did not try themselves but were part of a larger firm team.
Ask directly: "Did you personally try this case to jury, or were you part of a team?" and "Can you walk me through what happened in this case—what the liability issue was, what the main evidence was, what the jury seemed to focus on?" A lawyer who knows their cases can answer these questions. A lawyer who is just reading from a list cannot.
What questions to ask about the lawyer's overall track record
Instead of asking "What is your biggest verdict?", ask these questions: "How many wrongful death cases have you tried to jury in the past five years?" "What percentage resulted in a plaintiff verdict?" "What was the range of verdicts—the highest, the lowest, the median?" "How many were appealed and what happened?" "What percentage of your cases settle, and at what stage?" "For cases similar to mine, what would you estimate as a realistic range of outcomes?"
A lawyer who can answer these questions with specifics—not round numbers, not vague ranges, but actual data—is showing you they track their work and understand their own performance. A lawyer who deflects or gives you only the highlight reel is not giving you the information you need to make a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a bigger verdict mean the lawyer is better?
Not necessarily. A large verdict can reflect the severity of the injuries, the wealth of the defendant, or the luck of the jury pool, not just the lawyer's skill. A lawyer with a $1 million average verdict across 20 cases may be more reliable than one with a $5 million verdict and a 10% trial rate. Ask about the range and frequency, not just the peak.
Should I care more about verdicts or settlements?
Both matter, but for different reasons. Verdicts show courtroom skill. Settlements show negotiation skill and realistic case evaluation. Most wrongful death cases settle, so a lawyer's settlement track record may be more relevant to your case than their trial record. Ask about both.
What if the lawyer has no jury verdicts, only settlements?
That does not disqualify them. Many skilled lawyers settle most cases because they are good negotiators or because they take cases that are strong on liability but uncertain on damages. Ask why they settle, what their average settlement amounts are, and whether they have tried cases when settlement was not possible.
Can I trust verdicts listed on the lawyer's website?
Verdicts on a website are selected by the lawyer to look good, so they are not a random sample of their work. They are real cases, but they are the best cases. Ask for a more complete picture: the range of outcomes, the percentage of cases won, and the percentage that went to trial. Ask also whether they can provide references from recent clients.
What if the lawyer's verdicts are old?
Older verdicts are less relevant because jury expectations, case law, and damage calculations change. A verdict from 2015 tells you less about what to expect today. Ask about recent cases and recent verdicts. If the lawyer's most recent big verdict is more than three years old, ask why and what their recent cases have looked like.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.