What Wrongful Death Interrogatories Ask the Plaintiff — and Why
What interrogatories are and why defendants use them in wrongful death cases
Interrogatories are written questions that one side in a lawsuit sends to the other side, who must answer them under oath. In a wrongful death case, the defendant's lawyer uses interrogatories to ask the plaintiff (the person suing) detailed questions about the death, the relationship to the deceased, the damages claimed, and the basis for the lawsuit itself. The plaintiff's lawyer then has a set number of days—usually 30—to provide written answers.
Interrogatories serve a practical purpose: they force both sides to lay out what they know and what they claim before trial. The defendant learns the plaintiff's version of events, the evidence the plaintiff has, and how much money the plaintiff is seeking. The plaintiff's answers become part of the court record and can be used against them later if their testimony changes or contradicts what they wrote.
Unlike a deposition, where a lawyer asks questions out loud and a court reporter records the answers, interrogatories are written. This means the plaintiff's lawyer has time to research, consult with the client, and craft careful answers. But it also means every word is permanent and will be read by the judge and jury.
Key Takeaways
- Interrogatories are written questions the defendant sends to the plaintiff, who must answer under oath within 30 days.
- Common interrogatories ask about the plaintiff's relationship to the deceased, the circumstances of the death, medical history, and the basis for the lawsuit.
- The plaintiff's lawyer should review each answer carefully because interrogatory responses become evidence and can be used to challenge the plaintiff's credibility at trial.
- Objections to interrogatories are allowed when a question is overly broad, seeks privileged information, or asks for something already produced in documents.
- Incomplete or evasive answers can result in court sanctions and damage the plaintiff's case before trial even begins.
Typical interrogatories about the deceased and the relationship
The defendant's lawyer will ask the plaintiff to provide detailed information about who the deceased was and how the plaintiff was related to them. These questions establish whether the plaintiff has legal standing to sue—that is, whether the law recognizes them as someone who can bring a wrongful death claim. Questions typically ask for the deceased's full name, date of birth, date of death, occupation, and marital status at the time of death.
The plaintiff will also be asked to describe their relationship to the deceased: whether they were a spouse, child, parent, or other family member. If the plaintiff is a minor child, the interrogatory may ask who their guardian is and whether the guardian is also a plaintiff. The defendant wants to know whether the plaintiff has a direct financial or emotional interest in the case, and whether there are other potential plaintiffs who should be part of the lawsuit.
Some interrogatories ask the plaintiff to list all people who depended on the deceased for financial support, or all people the deceased supported. This helps the defendant understand the scope of the damages claim and whether the plaintiff's loss of financial support is real or exaggerated.
Interrogatories about the circumstances of the death
The defendant will ask the plaintiff to describe what happened on the day of the death: where the deceased was, what they were doing, who was present, and what the plaintiff knows about how the death occurred. These questions are designed to lock the plaintiff into a specific version of events before trial. If the plaintiff's testimony later differs from the interrogatory answers, the defendant can use that inconsistency to undermine the plaintiff's credibility.
The defendant may ask whether the plaintiff was present when the death occurred, or whether the plaintiff learned about it secondhand. If secondhand, the interrogatory asks who told the plaintiff and what they said. This helps the defendant identify witnesses and understand what the plaintiff actually knows versus what they heard from someone else.
Interrogatories also ask the plaintiff to identify all documents, photographs, videos, or recordings related to the death or the events leading up to it. The defendant wants to know what evidence exists and whether the plaintiff has it or knows where it is. This is a way to discover evidence before the formal document exchange happens.
Interrogatories about damages and financial loss
Because wrongful death is fundamentally about money—compensation for the loss of financial support, companionship, and other benefits the deceased would have provided—the defendant will ask detailed questions about the plaintiff's damages claim. The plaintiff must list all economic losses: lost wages the deceased would have earned, medical bills paid before death, funeral and burial costs, and any other out-of-pocket expenses.
The defendant will ask the plaintiff to provide the basis for each number claimed. If the plaintiff says the deceased would have earned $50,000 per year for 30 more years, the defendant wants to know: What was the deceased's job? What did they earn last year? What evidence supports the projection of future earnings? The plaintiff must cite specific documents—tax returns, pay stubs, employment contracts, informed reports—that back up the claim.
Interrogatories also ask about non-economic damages: the loss of companionship, guidance, comfort, and society. These are harder to quantify, and the defendant wants the plaintiff to explain in detail what specific losses the plaintiff experienced and how the plaintiff calculated a dollar amount for them. The plaintiff's answer here is often vague—"I lost my father's guidance and support"—but the defendant will push for specifics in follow-up questions or at deposition.
Interrogatories about the plaintiff's knowledge of the defendant and the cause of death
The defendant will ask what the plaintiff knows about the defendant, the defendant's actions, and how those actions caused the death. The plaintiff must describe the basis for the lawsuit: What did the defendant do or fail to do? When did the plaintiff learn about it? Who told the plaintiff? What documents support the claim?
These interrogatories are critical because they force the plaintiff to articulate the legal theory of the case. If the plaintiff cannot clearly explain why the defendant is responsible for the death, the defendant's lawyer has found a weakness to exploit. The defendant may ask: "State all facts upon which you base your claim that the defendant was negligent" or "Identify all documents that support your claim that the defendant's product was defective."
The defendant will also ask whether the plaintiff has consulted with experts—engineers, doctors, safety specialists—and if so, who they are and what those experts concluded. This allows the defendant to identify the plaintiff's informed witnesses before trial and prepare to challenge their opinions.
Interrogatories about prior claims, settlements, and insurance
The defendant may ask whether the plaintiff has filed any other lawsuits or claims related to the death, or whether the plaintiff has received any money from insurance, workers' compensation, or other sources as a result of the death. This is important because in many states, money the plaintiff receives from insurance or workers' compensation must be subtracted from the final judgment—a rule called collateral source reduction.
The defendant will also ask whether the plaintiff has discussed settlement with the defendant or the defendant's insurance company, and if so, what amounts were discussed. This can be sensitive because settlement discussions are usually confidential, but the defendant may try to use the interrogatory to learn whether the plaintiff has already signaled a willingness to settle for a lower amount than the damages claimed in the lawsuit.
How to object to an interrogatory and what happens if you don't answer
The plaintiff's lawyer does not have to answer every interrogatory exactly as written. The lawyer can object on specific grounds: the question is overly broad or vague, it seeks privileged information (like communications between the plaintiff and the lawyer), it asks for something already produced in documents, or it is unduly burdensome to answer. An objection must state the reason clearly and be signed by the lawyer.
However, objections are not a way to avoid answering. If the plaintiff objects to an interrogatory, the defendant can file a motion to compel—a request to the judge to force the plaintiff to answer. The judge will review the objection and decide whether it is valid. If the judge overrules the objection, the plaintiff must answer within a new important date, usually 14 days.
If the plaintiff fails to answer an interrogatory and does not object, or if the plaintiff's answer is incomplete or evasive, the defendant can ask the court to impose sanctions. Sanctions can include fines, attorney's fees, or in serious cases, a default judgment in favor of the defendant—meaning the defendant wins the case without trial. Courts take interrogatory responses seriously because they are part of the discovery process, which is meant to may support both sides have the information they need before trial.
Why the plaintiff's lawyer reviews and refines interrogatory answers
The plaintiff's lawyer does not straightforward hand the interrogatories to the client and ask them to write answers. The lawyer reviews each question, discusses it with the client, researches the facts and law, and then drafts an answer that is accurate, complete, and strategic. "Strategic" does not mean dishonest; it means precise and careful.
For example, if an interrogatory asks "Describe all conversations you had with the deceased about money," the plaintiff might say "We talked about money many times." But the lawyer will push for specifics: When? What was discussed? What did the deceased say about their income, debts, or plans? The more specific the answer, the stronger the foundation for the damages claim.
The lawyer also watches for traps. If an interrogatory asks "Have you ever been convicted of a crime?" and the plaintiff answers "No," but the plaintiff was actually convicted of a misdemeanor 15 years ago, the defendant will use that lie to destroy the plaintiff's credibility at trial. The lawyer makes sure the client understands that interrogatory answers are sworn statements, and lying on them is perjury.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the plaintiff refuse to answer an interrogatory?
The plaintiff can object to an interrogatory on legal grounds—if it is overly broad, seeks privileged information, or asks for something already produced. But a blanket refusal to answer will result in a motion to compel, and if the judge overrules the objection, the plaintiff must answer. Refusing without a valid objection can lead to sanctions.
What happens if the plaintiff's interrogatory answer contradicts their testimony at trial?
The defendant will use the contradiction to challenge the plaintiff's credibility. The jury will see that the plaintiff said one thing in writing under oath and another thing in person under oath, which suggests the plaintiff is not reliable. This can seriously damage the plaintiff's case.
How long does the plaintiff have to answer interrogatories?
The standard time is 30 days from the date the interrogatories are served. The plaintiff's lawyer can ask for an extension, and the defendant can agree to it. If the defendant refuses and the plaintiff cannot meet the important date, the lawyer must ask the judge for more time before the important date passes.
Can interrogatories ask about the plaintiff's medical history or mental health?
Yes, if it is relevant to the case. For example, if the plaintiff claims emotional distress from the death, the defendant can ask about the plaintiff's prior mental health treatment, therapy, or medication. The plaintiff can object if the question is overly broad or seeks privileged information, but relevance alone is not grounds to refuse.
Do interrogatory answers have to be detailed, or can they be brief?
Answers must be complete and accurate. A vague or evasive answer—one that technically responds to the question but withholds important information—can be challenged by the defendant. The plaintiff's lawyer should make sure each answer provides enough detail to support the plaintiff's claims without volunteering information the defendant did not ask for.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.