What Happens When You Lose a Wrongful Death Case
You pay your own attorney fees and court costs, and the defendant pays nothing
If a wrongful death lawsuit does not succeed — because a jury finds the defendant not liable, or because a judge dismisses the case before trial — you do not recover money for the death. You also do not recover the money you spent on the case itself. In most wrongful death cases, each side pays its own legal bills, even the side that loses. This is called the "American Rule," and it means a failed lawsuit can cost your family tens of thousands of dollars out of pocket.
The defendant does not owe you attorney fees, court filing fees, informed witness costs, or any other expense you incurred. Your attorney may have worked on a contingency basis — meaning they took a percentage of any settlement or judgment instead of an hourly fee — but if there is no recovery, there is no payment to them either. If you paid your attorney hourly, you owe that bill regardless of the outcome.
The only exception is if the court finds the defendant acted in "bad faith" — meaning they filed frivolous motions, destroyed evidence, or otherwise abused the legal process. Bad faith findings are rare and require a separate motion and hearing. Even then, the court may order the defendant to pay only some of your costs, not all.
Key Takeaways
- Under the American Rule, the losing side in a wrongful death case pays its own legal costs; the defendant does not reimburse you for attorney fees or court expenses.
- If your attorney worked on contingency, they receive no payment if the case is lost, but if you paid hourly, you still owe those bills.
- A case can be dismissed before trial if the defendant's motion succeeds, which may happen if the evidence of negligence is too weak or the defendant was not the legal cause of death.
- Appeals are possible but expensive and succeed only if the trial judge made a legal error, not because you disagree with the jury's decision.
- Some states allow wrongful death cases to proceed even if the defendant was acquitted in criminal court, because the legal standards are different.
Why a case gets dismissed or lost at trial
A wrongful death case fails for one of three reasons: the defendant was not negligent, the defendant's negligence did not cause the death, or you cannot prove either one to the required legal standard.
Negligence means the defendant owed your family member a duty of care, breached that duty, and caused injury as a result. A jury might find that a driver was not speeding, or that a doctor followed the standard of care for the patient's condition. If the defendant did not breach a duty, there is no negligence, and the case ends.
Causation is often the harder hurdle. Even if the defendant was negligent, the death must have resulted directly from that negligence. A patient might die from a pre-existing condition that a doctor's error made worse but did not cause. A fall might have happened anyway, even if a property owner failed to fix a hazard. The jury must believe the death would not have occurred "but for" the defendant's negligence. If they have reasonable doubt, they vote for the defendant.
Before trial, the defendant's attorney can file a motion to dismiss, arguing that even if all your evidence is true, it does not meet the legal standard for wrongful death. If the judge agrees, the case ends without a jury ever hearing it. This is common in cases where the link between the defendant's conduct and the death is weak or speculative.
What happens to your out-of-pocket costs
During the case, you and your attorney paid for discovery — the process of exchanging documents and taking depositions (recorded statements under oath). You may have paid for medical experts to review records, accident reconstructionists to analyze a crash, or economists to calculate lost earnings. These costs add up quickly, often reaching $5,000 to $50,000 or more in a serious case.
If you lose, those costs are gone. Your attorney cannot recover them from the defendant. If your attorney advanced these costs (paid them on your behalf), you may owe reimbursement to the firm, even though the case did not succeed. Read your retainer agreement carefully — it should spell out whether you are responsible for informed fees if the case is lost.
Court filing fees, deposition transcripts, and document production costs are also your responsibility. These are smaller amounts — usually a few hundred to a few thousand dollars — but they add up. Some attorneys absorb these costs as part of their business; others bill them back to the client.
Whether you can appeal and what it costs
An appeal is possible, but it is expensive and has a low success rate. An appeal does not mean a new trial or a second chance to present evidence. Instead, an appellate court reviews the trial record to decide whether the trial judge made a legal error — such as allowing evidence that should have been excluded, or giving the jury incorrect instructions on the law.
An appellate court will not overturn a jury verdict just because the jurors made a different judgment call than you would have. They will overturn it only if the judge's error was significant enough that it likely changed the outcome. This is a high bar.
An appeal typically costs $10,000 to $30,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the case and how many issues you appeal. Your attorney will need to write a brief explaining the legal errors, and may need to argue before a panel of judges. If you lose the appeal, you pay those costs and still recover nothing.
Some attorneys will appeal at no additional cost if they believe the trial judge made a clear error. Others will not pursue an appeal unless you pay the costs upfront. Discuss this with your attorney before the trial verdict comes in, so you understand what an appeal would cost and what the realistic chances are.
How a criminal acquittal differs from a civil loss
If the defendant was acquitted in criminal court, that does not prevent a wrongful death lawsuit. Criminal and civil cases use different standards of proof. In criminal court, the prosecution must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" — a very high bar. In civil court, you must prove your case by a "preponderance of the evidence" — meaning it is more likely than not that the defendant was negligent and caused the death.
A defendant can be acquitted in criminal court and still lose a wrongful death case, because the civil standard is lower. However, the reverse is also true: a defendant can be convicted of a crime and still win a wrongful death case if the jury finds the negligence did not cause the death, or if the defendant owed no duty of care in the civil sense.
If the defendant was acquitted criminally, your attorney may still pursue a wrongful death case, but the acquittal will be used as evidence that the defendant's conduct was not as serious as you claim. This makes the civil case harder to win, even though it is not a legal bar to proceeding.
What to consider before filing a wrongful death case
Because you pay your own costs if you lose, it is critical to have a realistic assessment of your case before you file. A reputable wrongful death attorney will tell you honestly whether the evidence supports a claim. They should explain what the defendant will argue, what weaknesses exist in your case, and what the likely range of recovery is if you win.
Ask your attorney what percentage of similar cases they have won, and what the average settlement or judgment was. Ask whether they have handled cases against the type of defendant you are suing — a hospital, a manufacturer, a government agency — because different defendants present different challenges.
Understand the statute of limitations in your state. Wrongful death cases must be filed within a set time frame, usually two to three years from the date of death, though this varies. Missing the important date means you lose the right to sue, regardless of the strength of your case.
If you cannot afford to lose the case costs, discuss a contingency arrangement with your attorney. Most wrongful death attorneys work on contingency, meaning they advance the costs and take a percentage of any recovery. If the case is lost, you owe nothing. However, some attorneys require you to pay costs upfront or to reimburse costs even if the case is lost. Get this in writing before you hire them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the defendant sue me for their attorney fees if I lose?
Not in most states, under the American Rule. However, some states allow the defendant to recover attorney fees if they believe your lawsuit was frivolous or filed in bad faith. This is rare. A few states also allow fee-shifting in certain types of cases, such as medical malpractice. Ask your attorney whether your state permits this.
What if I settle the case for less than my costs?
If you settle for $50,000 but your attorney's fees and costs total $40,000, you receive $10,000. Your attorney takes their percentage from the settlement, not from your pocket. However, if the settlement is very small, you may end up with little or nothing after costs and fees are paid. Discuss this possibility with your attorney before accepting any settlement offer.
Does losing a wrongful death case affect my credit or create debt?
If your attorney worked on contingency and the case is lost, you owe nothing and there is no debt. If you paid hourly or agreed to reimburse costs, you may owe your attorney's firm money. This is a contract debt, not a judgment against you, but it can affect your credit if you do not pay. Discuss payment plans with your attorney if you cannot pay the full amount at once.
Can I file another wrongful death lawsuit if the first one fails?
No. Once a case is decided by a jury or judge, the legal doctrine of "res judicata" prevents you from filing the same case again. You cannot sue the same defendant for the same death based on the same facts. An appeal is your only option to challenge the outcome, and it must be filed within a set time frame, usually 30 days after the verdict.
What if new evidence comes to light after I lose?
New evidence discovered after a verdict is very difficult to use. You would need to file a motion for a new trial, which requires showing that the evidence is newly discovered, was not available before trial despite reasonable diligence, and would likely change the outcome. Courts rarely grant these motions. Discuss any new evidence with your attorney when ready, as timing is critical.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.