Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How Mediation Works in a Wrongful Death Case

What happens in a wrongful death mediation

Mediation is a structured conversation between you, the defendant, and a neutral third party called a mediator. The mediator does not decide who wins or what you are owed—that is a judge or jury's job. Instead, the mediator helps both sides understand each other's position, talk about what settlement might look like, and sometimes find middle ground where both sides can agree to end the case without trial.

In a wrongful death case, mediation usually happens after the initial discovery phase (when both sides exchange documents and information) but before trial. It is voluntary—either side can refuse to mediate, though courts often encourage it. The process typically takes one day, though complex cases sometimes need more time.

Most mediations follow the same basic structure: an opening session where both sides present their view, then separate meetings where the mediator shuttles between rooms, listening to each side's concerns and exploring whether a settlement number exists that both would accept. The mediator will not tell your side what the other side said without permission, and vice versa.

Key Takeaways

  • A mediator is a neutral person who helps both sides talk and negotiate, but does not make a binding decision or force a settlement.
  • Mediation happens after discovery but before trial, usually takes one day, and is often ordered by the court or suggested by your attorney.
  • You will likely sit in a separate room from the defendant and their lawyer, with the mediator moving between you to relay offers and concerns.
  • Anything you say in mediation is confidential and cannot be used in court if the case does not settle, which protects both sides from risk.
  • Your wrongful death attorney should prepare you beforehand with a settlement range, the strengths and weaknesses of your case, and what to expect from the other side.

Who is in the room and what they do

You will be present, along with your wrongful death attorney. The defendant (or the defendant's company) will be there with their lawyer. A neutral mediator—usually a retired judge, lawyer, or someone trained in mediation—sits with both sides or moves between separate rooms depending on how the mediation is structured.

The mediator's role is to listen, ask questions, and help both sides understand what the other side values and fears. They might point out weaknesses in your case or the defendant's case, not to take sides but to help both parties think realistically about the risk of going to trial. They do not represent either side and have no stake in the outcome.

Your attorney's job is to advise you on what settlement offers make sense, explain the law and how a jury might view the evidence, and negotiate on your behalf. You should feel comfortable asking your attorney questions during breaks or in private caucus (the separate room meetings).

How the mediation process unfolds

Mediation typically begins with an opening session where both sides sit together. Your attorney will present your case: who the deceased was, how they died, what the defendant did or failed to do, and what damages you are seeking (medical bills, funeral costs, lost income, pain and suffering of family members). The defendant's attorney will present their version—why they believe the defendant is not responsible, or why the damages are lower than claimed.

After opening statements, the mediator usually separates the sides into different rooms. You and your attorney will sit in one room; the defendant and their attorney in another. The mediator will move between rooms, asking questions, listening to concerns, and eventually asking each side for a settlement number.

This back-and-forth can take hours. The mediator might say, "Your side is asking for $500,000. The other side says that is too high because of X reason. What would you say to an offer of $250,000?" Your attorney will advise you on whether to counter-offer, hold firm, or move closer to the defendant's number. The goal is to find a number both sides will accept.

If both sides agree on a settlement amount, the mediator will draft a settlement agreement—a document saying the defendant will pay you a certain sum and you will drop the lawsuit. You sign it, the defendant signs it, and the case is over. If no agreement is reached by the end of the day, mediation ends and the case moves toward trial.

What you should prepare before mediation

Your attorney should meet with you before mediation to discuss your case's strengths and weaknesses. Ask them: What is a realistic settlement range? What would a jury likely award if we go to trial? What are the risks of losing at trial? What does the other side's evidence look like? These conversations help you understand what number to hope for and what number you should accept if the defendant will not budge.

Bring documents that support your damages claim: funeral bills, medical records from the deceased's final illness or injury, pay stubs showing lost income, and any evidence of the defendant's wrongdoing. You may not need to present these in mediation itself, but having them available helps your attorney answer the mediator's questions and respond to the defendant's arguments.

Think about what settlement would feel fair to you and your family. Money cannot undo the loss, but it can cover costs and provide some security. Be honest with your attorney about your bottom line—the lowest number you would accept—so they can negotiate effectively without overstepping your wishes.

Confidentiality and what cannot be used in court

Mediation is confidential. Anything you say during mediation—offers, admissions, concerns—cannot be brought up in court if the case does not settle and goes to trial. This protection exists so both sides can speak honestly without fear that their words will be used against them later.

If you tell the mediator, "We might accept $300,000," that number cannot be introduced as evidence at trial to show you did not believe your case was worth more. If the defendant's attorney says, "Our client made a mistake," that admission cannot be used to prove liability. The confidentiality rule applies to the mediator as well—they cannot testify about what either side said.

The only exception is if both sides agree in writing that something said in mediation can be used later. This is rare and usually happens only when both sides want to enforce a settlement agreement.

What happens if mediation succeeds

If you and the defendant reach a settlement, the mediator will prepare a written agreement. This document will state the settlement amount, when the defendant will pay it, and that you are releasing the defendant from all claims related to the death. You will sign it, the defendant will sign it, and your attorney will file a notice of settlement with the court.

Once the agreement is signed, the case is closed. The defendant's insurance company (or the defendant themselves) will send the settlement payment to your attorney's trust account. Your attorney will deduct their fee (usually a percentage of the settlement, often one-third) and any costs they paid out of pocket (court fees, informed witness fees, etc.), then send you the remainder.

Settlement means no trial, no jury verdict, and no appeal. You receive the money within weeks or months rather than years. The trade-off is that you accept whatever amount you agreed to, even if a jury might have awarded more.

What happens if mediation fails

If mediation ends without a settlement, the case continues toward trial. Your attorney will file any remaining motions, prepare witnesses, and get ready to present your case to a judge or jury. The fact that mediation failed does not hurt your case—the judge and jury will not know it happened, and nothing said in mediation can be used against you.

Some cases go to mediation once, fail, and then go to trial. Others are mediated again later, sometimes after more discovery or after one side's position has shifted. If your attorney thinks a second mediation might help, they can propose it to the defendant's attorney.

Going to trial is riskier and more expensive than settling. You might win a larger award, but you might also lose and receive nothing. Your attorney should help you weigh these risks before deciding whether to push for trial or try mediation again.

Questions to ask your attorney before mediation

Before mediation, ask your attorney these questions: What is your estimate of what a jury would award? What is the defendant's strongest argument? What is our strongest argument? What settlement range do you think is realistic? If we do not settle, what happens next and how long until trial? How much will trial cost in attorney fees and informed witnesses? What are the risks of losing at trial?

Also ask: Will I need to speak during mediation, or will you do the talking? What should I avoid saying? Can I ask for a break if I become upset? These questions help you feel prepared and in control of the process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to go to mediation?

Mediation is usually voluntary, but many courts order it or strongly encourage it before trial. If the court orders mediation, you must attend or risk sanctions (penalties). If it is not ordered, your attorney might still recommend it because it often leads to settlement and saves time and money compared to trial.

What if I get emotional during mediation?

It is normal to become upset when discussing the death of a loved one. Tell your attorney you need a break, step out of the room, and take time to compose yourself. The mediator and your attorney expect emotions in wrongful death cases. You do not have to speak if you do not want to—your attorney can present your case while you listen.

Can the mediator tell the other side what I said?

Not without your permission. The mediator will ask you before sharing any statement or offer with the other side. If you say something in a private caucus and do not want it repeated, tell the mediator and they will keep it confidential.

What if we settle but the defendant does not pay?

Once you sign a settlement agreement, it is a binding contract. If the defendant does not pay, your attorney can file a motion to enforce the agreement or take other legal action to collect. This is rare because the defendant's insurance company usually handles payment, and they have a strong incentive to pay to close the case.

How long does it take to receive the settlement money?

After you sign the settlement agreement, payment usually arrives within two to six weeks. Your attorney's office will receive the funds, deduct fees and costs, and send you a check. The exact timeline depends on how quickly the defendant's insurance company processes the payment.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.