How Often Wrongful Death Cases Actually Go to Trial
Most wrongful death cases settle before trial — somewhere between 85 and 95 percent, depending on the circumstances and the parties involved
When someone files a wrongful death claim, the assumption is often that it will end in a courtroom. The reality is different. The vast majority of these cases never reach a jury. Instead, they resolve through negotiation, mediation, or structured settlement agreements between the plaintiff's attorney and the defendant's insurance company or legal team.
Why so few go to trial? Trial is expensive, time-consuming, and unpredictable for both sides. A defendant facing a wrongful death claim knows a jury might award substantial damages. A plaintiff's family knows a trial could drag on for years and might result in less money than a settlement offer on the table. Both sides have strong incentives to reach agreement before a judge or jury gets involved.
Key Takeaways
- Between 85 and 95 percent of wrongful death cases settle before trial, though the exact percentage varies based on case strength, jurisdiction, and the parties' willingness to negotiate.
- Settlement negotiations often happen months before trial would occur, sometimes within the first year after the claim is filed.
- Cases that do go to trial tend to involve disputes over liability, disagreement about damages, or a defendant's refusal to offer a reasonable settlement.
- The cost of taking a wrongful death case to trial — attorney fees, informed witnesses, court costs — can exceed $100,000, which is why many families choose settlement even if they believe they would win.
- Your attorney's experience and the strength of evidence in your specific case matter far more than national averages when predicting whether settlement or trial is likely.
Why cases settle instead of going to trial
A settlement happens when both sides agree on a dollar amount and sign a release. For the defendant, settlement stops the case when ready and limits their total exposure. For the family, settlement means money arrives within weeks or months rather than years, and there is no risk of a jury deciding the case is worth less than expected.
The financial pressure is real. Preparing a wrongful death case for trial requires informed witnesses — medical experts, accident reconstructionists, economists who calculate lost earnings and lost companionship. Each informed costs thousands of dollars. Discovery — the process of exchanging documents and taking depositions — can run $50,000 or more. Trial itself, if it lasts more than a few days, can cost an additional $50,000 to $150,000 in attorney time and court expenses.
Insurance companies know these numbers. They also know that juries in wrongful death cases can award large sums, especially when the death involved a child, a young adult with decades of earning potential ahead, or circumstances that suggest negligence or recklessness. A company facing a strong case often settles to avoid the risk of a jury verdict that exceeds their settlement offer by millions.
What makes a case more likely to go to trial
Cases that do reach trial usually involve one or more of these factors: genuine disagreement about who was at fault, a large gap between what the plaintiff's family believes the case is worth and what the defendant is willing to pay, or a defendant's insurance company that refuses to negotiate seriously.
Liability disputes are common. In a car accident wrongful death case, for example, both sides might agree the death happened but disagree about whether the defendant was actually negligent. In a medical malpractice wrongful death case, the defendant's medical experts might argue the doctor followed standard care, while the plaintiff's experts say the doctor fell below the standard. When liability is unclear, settlement becomes harder because the defendant's risk calculation changes.
Damages disputes also push cases toward trial. The family might believe the case is worth $2 million based on the deceased's age, earning potential, and the pain and suffering of surviving family members. The defendant might offer $400,000. If the gap is too wide and neither side moves significantly, trial becomes the only way to resolve the disagreement.
How long settlement negotiations typically take
Settlement discussions often begin before the case is formally filed and continue throughout the pre-trial period. In some cases, a settlement is reached within 6 to 12 months. In others, negotiations drag on for two or three years before either a settlement is reached or the case is scheduled for trial.
The timeline depends on how quickly evidence is gathered, how willing the defendant is to negotiate, and whether mediation is used. Mediation — a process where a neutral third party helps both sides talk through their positions — can accelerate settlement. Some families and defendants reach agreement in mediation within weeks. Others use mediation as a final step before trial, sometimes settling just days before the trial date.
Your attorney will advise you on whether to push for early settlement or hold out for a higher offer. That information depends on the strength of your evidence, the jurisdiction where the case would be tried, and how much time and money you are willing to spend.
What happens if your case does go to trial
If settlement negotiations fail, the case is assigned a trial date. The trial process in a wrongful death case typically involves jury selection, opening statements from both sides, presentation of evidence and witness testimony, informed testimony, closing arguments, and jury deliberation. A wrongful death trial can last anywhere from a few days to several weeks, depending on complexity.
The jury's job is to decide two things: whether the defendant was responsible for the death, and if so, how much money the family should receive. The jury does not decide whether the case "should" have gone to trial — they only decide the facts and damages based on the evidence presented.
After the jury reaches a verdict, either side can appeal if they believe the trial process had legal errors. Appeals add months or years to the case and are expensive. This is another reason settlement is often preferable: it ends the case completely, with no possibility of appeal.
How your specific circumstances affect settlement likelihood
National percentages are useful context, but your case is not a statistic. Several factors specific to your situation will influence whether settlement or trial is more likely.
The strength of liability evidence matters most. If there is clear video, witness testimony, or police reports showing the defendant was at fault, settlement becomes more likely because the defendant knows a jury will probably find them responsible. If liability is murky — the accident happened in low light, witnesses disagree, or the defendant has a plausible explanation — the defendant is more likely to take the case to trial.
The jurisdiction also matters. Some courts and juries are known to award higher damages in wrongful death cases. A defendant in a jurisdiction where juries tend to be generous will be more motivated to settle. A defendant in a jurisdiction where juries are more conservative might be willing to take the risk of trial.
Your attorney's track record and reputation in your local court system also affects settlement negotiations. Defendants and their insurers know which attorneys win at trial and which ones do not. An attorney with a strong trial record often negotiates better settlements because the other side knows the attorney will actually take the case to trial if necessary.
Questions to ask your attorney about settlement versus trial
Before your case progresses far, have a direct conversation with your attorney about the likelihood of settlement in your situation. Ask what evidence would need to be stronger to increase settlement value. Ask what the defendant would need to do or say to make trial more likely. Ask what the realistic range of settlement offers might be, and what a jury verdict might look like if the case goes to trial.
Ask your attorney to explain the costs of trial in your specific case — not just general numbers, but what your case would cost. Ask whether mediation is available and whether it might help. Ask what happens to your case if you reject a settlement offer and later lose at trial.
These conversations help you understand your own case, not just the national average. Your attorney can tell you whether your case is likely to be in the 85 to 95 percent that settle, or in the smaller group that goes to trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
If my case settles, do I have to keep it secret?
Most settlements include a confidentiality clause, which means you agree not to disclose the settlement amount or the terms. You can usually tell people you settled, but not for how much. Your attorney can negotiate the confidentiality terms before you sign — some families successfully remove or limit these clauses.
What if I turn down a settlement offer and then lose at trial?
You receive nothing. This is why settlement offers matter even if you believe your case is strong. Your attorney should help you understand the risk of rejecting an offer — what a jury might award if you lose, and how confident your attorney is in winning at trial.
Can the defendant force my case to trial?
No. Both sides must agree to settle. If you want to go to trial and the defendant wants to settle, you can refuse the settlement and proceed to trial. If the defendant refuses to settle and you want to, your attorney can push for trial, but you cannot force settlement.
How much does it cost to take a wrongful death case to trial?
Trial costs vary widely depending on case complexity, but typically range from $50,000 to $200,000 or more in attorney fees, informed witness fees, and court costs. Most wrongful death attorneys work on contingency, meaning they advance these costs and recover them from the settlement or verdict. If you lose at trial, you may owe these costs.
Does settling mean I'm giving up or admitting I was wrong?
No. Settlement is a business decision, not a judgment on the strength of your case. Many families settle strong cases because the may provide money now is worth more to them than the risk and cost of trial. Settlement is a valid choice, not a failure.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.