Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens During a Wrongful Death Deposition in a Medical Error Case

A deposition is a formal question-and-answer session where lawyers ask you under oath about the death and your losses

During a wrongful death deposition in a medical error case, you will sit in a room with a court reporter, the defendant's lawyer (usually the hospital or doctor's attorney), and your own lawyer. The defendant's lawyer will ask you questions about the person who died, the medical care they received, your relationship to them, and how their death has affected you financially and emotionally. Your answers are recorded word-for-word and can be used later in court or to settle the case. You are under oath, which means lying has legal consequences.

A deposition is not a trial. No judge is present, and you are not arguing your case—you are answering questions. The defendant's goal is to understand your claim, find weaknesses in it, and gather information to use in their defense. Your goal is to answer truthfully without volunteering extra information or damaging your case.

Depositions typically last between two and six hours, though they can run longer in complex medical cases. You will usually have a break or two. The defendant's lawyer sets the pace and decides when to stop.

Key Takeaways

  • A deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session under oath, held before trial, where the defendant's lawyer questions you about the death and your damages.
  • You must answer truthfully, but you can object to unfair questions with your lawyer's help, and you do not have to guess or speculate about medical facts.
  • Preparation with your lawyer beforehand—reviewing your story, understanding the medical timeline, and practicing difficult questions—significantly reduces mistakes and protects your case.
  • The defendant's lawyer will try to minimize the value of your claim by questioning your relationship to the deceased, the extent of your financial losses, and whether the medical error actually caused the death.
  • Your deposition testimony can be read aloud in court later, so anything you say can be used against you if your story changes or if you contradict yourself.

How the defendant's lawyer will question you

The defendant's lawyer will start with background questions: your name, address, occupation, and your relationship to the person who died. These seem straightforward, but they establish the foundation for your claim. If you were a spouse or child, your relationship is straightforward. If you were a grandparent, adult sibling, or domestic partner, the lawyer may ask detailed questions about your legal or financial dependence on the deceased—because some states limit who can recover damages in wrongful death cases.

Next, the lawyer will ask about the medical care itself. They will walk through the timeline: when the person went to the hospital or doctor's office, what symptoms they had, what tests or procedures were done, and what the medical records show. The lawyer will have those records in front of them. Do not guess or fill in gaps. If you do not remember, say so. If you are unsure whether something happened, say you are unsure. The defendant's lawyer is looking for any inconsistency between what you say and what the medical records show, because inconsistencies undermine your credibility.

The lawyer will also ask you what you understood about the medical error at the time and what you understand now. They may ask whether you discussed the error with the doctor or hospital, what was said, and whether anyone apologized or admitted fault. These questions are tricky because an apology or admission can help your case, but the lawyer will try to frame it as hearsay or misunderstanding on your part.

Questions about your financial and emotional losses

The defendant's lawyer will ask detailed questions about how the death has affected you financially. If you were dependent on the deceased for income, they will ask about your household expenses, what the person earned, and how you have managed since their death. Bring documentation: tax returns, pay stubs, bank statements, mortgage or rent payments, utility bills, and any other proof of financial dependence. The lawyer will challenge any claim you cannot back up with a number.

They will also ask about funeral and burial costs, medical bills from the person's final illness, and any estate or probate expenses. Again, have receipts and invoices ready. If you paid these costs yourself, be clear about that. If someone else paid them, say so—it affects what you can recover.

Emotional damages are harder to quantify, and the defendant's lawyer knows it. They will ask how the death has affected your daily life, your sleep, your ability to work, your relationships, and your mental health. They may ask whether you have seen a therapist or taken medication for grief or depression. They will ask how long you expect to grieve and whether you have "moved on." These questions are designed to make emotional suffering sound vague or exaggerated. Answer honestly, but do not overstate. If you say you have not slept in two years, the lawyer will challenge that as impossible. If you say you have been sad, that is too vague. Say something like, "I have had trouble concentrating at work and have missed several days because I could not get out of bed."

How to prepare with your lawyer before the deposition

Meet with your lawyer at least one week before the deposition. Bring all documents related to the death: medical records, bills, funeral invoices, pay stubs, tax returns, and any written communication with the hospital or doctor. Your lawyer will review the medical records with you and explain what went wrong in plain language. You need to understand the error well enough to describe it without reading from notes during the deposition.

Your lawyer will walk you through the timeline of events and ask you to tell the story in your own words. They will listen for gaps, inconsistencies, or places where your memory is fuzzy. If you are unsure about something, your lawyer will help you figure out whether the medical records clarify it or whether you genuinely do not remember. Do not memorize a script—that sounds rehearsed and damages your credibility. Instead, practice telling the story naturally until you are comfortable with the sequence of events and the key facts.

Your lawyer will also prepare you for hostile or tricky questions. They will ask you the hardest questions the defendant's lawyer might ask, so you are not caught off guard. They will teach you how to pause before answering, how to ask for clarification if a question is unclear, and when to say "I do not know" instead of guessing. They will also explain which questions you can object to and why—for example, questions that ask you to speculate about what a doctor was thinking, or questions that misstate the medical facts.

What you should and should not do during the deposition

Listen carefully to each question before you answer. If you do not understand the question, ask the lawyer to rephrase it. If a question has two parts and you want to answer only one, say so. Do not rush to fill silence—if the lawyer pauses, that is normal. They may be waiting for you to say more, but you are not required to volunteer information beyond what was asked.

Answer only what was asked. If the lawyer asks "Did the doctor explain the risks?" answer yes or no, then stop. Do not launch into a story about everything the doctor said unless the lawyer asks for details. Extra information gives the defendant's lawyer more ammunition.

Stay calm and respectful, even if the lawyer is aggressive or seems to be attacking you. Do not argue, do not get emotional, and do not make jokes. If you become upset, ask for a break. Your lawyer can request one. If the defendant's lawyer asks a question that your lawyer objects to, wait for your lawyer to finish the objection before you answer. Your lawyer may tell you not to answer certain questions, and you should follow that instruction.

Do not look at your lawyer for approval before answering questions. The defendant's lawyer will notice and may argue that your lawyer is coaching you. Answer the questions yourself, in your own words, based on what you actually know and remember.

Common traps and how to avoid them

The defendant's lawyer may ask you to agree with a statement that sounds reasonable but is actually misleading. For example: "The hospital provided emergency care to your spouse, correct?" You might say yes, but the lawyer is trying to establish that the hospital acted reasonably. Before you agree, make sure the statement is actually true and fair. If it is incomplete or misleading, say so: "The hospital provided emergency care, but they failed to order the correct test, which is why the diagnosis was missed."

The lawyer may also ask you to speculate about medical facts: "Do you think the doctor should have known the patient had a blood clot?" Do not guess. Say, "I am not a doctor, so I cannot say what a doctor should have known. That is a question for the medical experts." Your lawyer will have retained a medical informed to testify about the standard of care, and that informed's job is to answer those questions, not yours.

Another common trap is the "leading question" that assumes facts not in evidence. For example: "When the doctor ignored your spouse's symptoms, did that upset you?" The question assumes the doctor ignored the symptoms. If that is not accurate, do not accept the premise. Say, "The doctor did not examine my spouse thoroughly, and that is what upset me."

The lawyer may also try to minimize your relationship to the deceased or your financial dependence on them. If you were a spouse, this is usually straightforward. If you were an adult child or grandparent, be prepared to explain how you depended on the person financially or emotionally. Have documentation ready: joint bank accounts, mortgage documents, emails, or other proof of the relationship and your losses.

What happens after the deposition

The court reporter will prepare a written transcript of the deposition within a few weeks. Your lawyer will send you a copy to review. Read it carefully and mark any errors—if the court reporter misheard something or if you misspoke, you can file a correction. However, do not change your answers just because you wish you had said something different. Corrections should be limited to genuine errors in transcription.

The defendant's lawyer will use your deposition testimony to evaluate the strength of your case and to prepare for trial. If your testimony was strong and consistent, it may push the defendant toward settlement. If your testimony was weak or contradictory, the defendant may be more confident in their defense. Your lawyer will use your deposition to refine the case strategy and to prepare you for trial testimony, if the case does not settle.

The deposition transcript can be read aloud in court if the case goes to trial. If you testify at trial and your story changes from what you said at the deposition, the defendant's lawyer will confront you with the transcript. That is why consistency and honesty during the deposition matter so much.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I bring notes or documents to the deposition?

You can bring documents to refresh your memory, but the defendant's lawyer can ask to see them and may use them to challenge your testimony. Your lawyer will advise you on which documents to bring. Do not bring a script or written-out answers—that looks rehearsed and damages your credibility. Bring only materials that help you remember facts, like medical records or bills.

What if I do not remember something the lawyer asks about?

Say "I do not remember" or "I am not sure." Do not guess or make something up. If the medical records or other documents might refresh your memory, ask to see them. If you still do not remember after reviewing the documents, say so. Admitting you do not remember is better than giving wrong information that contradicts the records.

Can my lawyer object to questions during the deposition?

Yes, your lawyer can object to questions that are unfair, that ask you to speculate about medical facts, or that violate privacy rules. However, you still have to answer most questions even after an objection—the objection is noted in the transcript for the judge to consider later. Your lawyer will tell you when not to answer a question.

Will the deposition be recorded on video?

Sometimes. The court reporter always creates a written transcript. Video recording is optional and depends on what the lawyers agree to. If there is a video, it may be shown in court, so your appearance, tone, and body language matter. Dress professionally and speak clearly, as if you are already in front of a judge.

What if the defendant's lawyer asks about conversations with my lawyer?

Your conversations with your lawyer are protected by attorney-client privilege and are confidential. Your lawyer will object to these questions, and you should not answer them. The defendant's lawyer knows this but may ask anyway to see if you will slip up.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.