Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How Wrongful Death Settlements Work and What to Expect

What a wrongful death settlement actually is

A wrongful death settlement is money paid by the person or organisation responsible for someone's death, usually through their insurance company. It is not a court verdict — it is an agreement to end the case before trial. The settlement compensates the family for financial losses (lost income, medical bills, funeral costs) and for the loss itself (loss of companionship, emotional suffering). The amount varies enormously depending on the person's age, earning potential, and the strength of the case.

Settlements happen because both sides want to avoid the cost and uncertainty of trial. The defendant's insurance company pays out a lump sum or structured payments, and in return, the family agrees not to sue further. You do not have to accept a settlement — you can refuse and go to trial instead — but most wrongful death cases end this way because trials are expensive, take years, and have unpredictable outcomes.

Key Takeaways

  • A settlement is money paid to end the case before trial, usually coming from the defendant's insurance rather than their personal assets.
  • The amount depends on the deceased person's age, income, and how clearly the defendant caused the death — not on how much pain the family is in.
  • Your lawyer typically takes 25 to 40 percent of the settlement as a contingency fee, meaning they are paid only if you win money.
  • You have the right to refuse any settlement offer and take the case to trial, though this costs more time and money with no may provide of a larger award.
  • Settlement funds are usually divided among spouses, children, and parents according to state law, not according to who files the claim.

How settlement amounts are calculated

Wrongful death settlements are built on two categories: economic damages and non-economic damages. Economic damages are straightforward — they are the money the deceased would have earned over their lifetime, minus taxes and living expenses. A 35-year-old earning $60,000 a year who would have worked until 67 has a different economic value than a 72-year-old retired person. Medical bills from the final illness, funeral costs, and probate expenses are also economic damages.

Non-economic damages are harder to price because they are not a receipt. They cover the loss of companionship, guidance, and emotional support — what the family has lost by the person being gone. A child who loses a parent gets a different amount than a parent who loses an adult child, because the relationship and its duration are different. Some states cap non-economic damages (meaning there is a legal maximum), and some do not. Your lawyer will research what similar cases in your state have settled for to build a range.

The defendant's insurance company will also calculate their own number, usually lower than what your lawyer proposes. The settlement negotiation is the process of moving from those two numbers toward something both sides will accept. If the case is very strong — clear liability, serious injuries, documented losses — the insurance company's opening offer may already be substantial. If liability is disputed or the damages are hard to prove, the gap between the two numbers is wider.

The role of your lawyer in settlement talks

Most wrongful death cases are taken by lawyers on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover (usually 25 to 40 percent) and are paid nothing if you lose. This aligns their interest with yours — they want the largest settlement possible — but it also means they are making a business decision about whether your case is worth their time. A lawyer will not take a case unless they believe they can recover enough to make the work worthwhile.

Your lawyer handles all settlement negotiations with the insurance company's lawyers. You do not negotiate directly. Your lawyer will present evidence of liability, calculate damages, respond to the insurance company's counteroffers, and advise you on whether each offer is reasonable. They will also tell you honestly whether going to trial is likely to result in more money or less, based on the strength of your evidence and the judge or jury pool in your area.

Before any settlement is final, your lawyer must explain it to you in detail and get your written consent. You have the right to refuse an offer, even if your lawyer thinks it is fair. If you refuse and go to trial, you pay the lawyer's costs (informed witnesses, court filing fees, deposition transcripts) out of any award you win, and you risk losing and paying nothing.

What happens to the money after settlement

The settlement check goes to your lawyer's trust account first. Your lawyer deducts their fee (the percentage you agreed to), pays back any costs they advanced (medical records, informed reports, court fees), and pays any liens or claims against the settlement. A lien is a legal claim on the money — for example, if Medicaid paid the deceased's hospital bills, Medicaid may have a lien for that amount. Once those deductions are made, the remaining money is distributed to the beneficiaries.

Who the beneficiaries are depends on state law, not on who filed the claim or who is closest emotionally. Most states prioritise spouses and children, then parents, then siblings. If the deceased left a will, it does not control wrongful death money — state law does. If there is disagreement among family members about how to divide the settlement, the case may go back to court, which costs more money and time. This is why it is important to understand early on who legally has a claim and what each person's share might be.

Some settlements are structured rather than lump sum, meaning the money is paid over time in installments or through an annuity. This can reduce the tax burden and prevent the money from being spent quickly, but it also means the family does not have access to the full amount when ready. Structured settlements are negotiated as part of the settlement agreement.

When settlement talks stall or fail

If the insurance company's offer stays far below what your lawyer believes the case is worth, or if they refuse to negotiate seriously, your lawyer will advise you on whether to reject the offer and prepare for trial. Going to trial means months or years of waiting, depositions (recorded questioning of witnesses), discovery (exchanging evidence with the other side), and the cost of informed witnesses. It also means the outcome is uncertain — a jury might award more than the settlement offer, or they might award less, or they might find the defendant not responsible at all.

Some cases settle on the courthouse steps, literally days before trial begins, because both sides finally understand what a jury might do. Other cases go to verdict. If you win at trial, the amount is decided by a judge or jury, not negotiated. If you lose, you recover nothing and still owe your lawyer's costs.

Taxes and what you actually receive

Wrongful death settlements are generally not taxed as income — the IRS treats them as compensation for loss, not earnings. However, if the settlement includes interest or if it is structured and earns investment returns, that portion may be taxable. Your lawyer should discuss this with you and may recommend you speak with a tax professional before accepting a large settlement.

The amount you see in the settlement agreement is not the amount you take home. After your lawyer's fee, costs, and any liens are paid, the remaining sum is divided among beneficiaries. A $500,000 settlement might become $300,000 after the lawyer takes 35 percent and costs are paid, then divided among a spouse and two adult children. Understanding this math early prevents shock when the check arrives.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it usually take to reach a settlement?

Most wrongful death cases settle within one to three years, though some take longer if liability is complex or the defendant disputes responsibility. Settlement talks can begin as soon as the defendant's insurance company has enough information about the case. Your lawyer will push for settlement once they have gathered medical records, accident reports, and informed opinions.

Can I settle part of the case and go to trial for the rest?

In some cases, yes. If there are multiple defendants and you settle with one but not another, the case continues against the others. However, most settlement agreements require you to release all claims related to the death, meaning you cannot settle and then sue for something else later. Your lawyer will explain what you are giving up before you sign.

What if the defendant does not have insurance?

If the defendant has no insurance and no significant assets, there may be nothing to recover even if you win the case. Some states allow you to pursue a judgment against the defendant's future wages or assets, but this is slow and often produces little money. Your lawyer will investigate the defendant's financial situation early on to determine whether a case is worth pursuing.

Do I have to use the settlement money for anything specific?

No. Once the settlement is final and the money is distributed to you, it is yours to use as you choose. Some families use it to cover the deceased's debts or funeral costs, others to replace lost income, others to invest for the future. There is no legal requirement for how you spend it.

What if I think the settlement offer is too low?

You can refuse it. Your lawyer should explain why they think it is low and what the risks are of going to trial instead. If you and your lawyer disagree about whether an offer is fair, you have the right to hire a different lawyer for a second opinion, though this costs money and time.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.