Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When You Can Sue Your Personal Injury Lawyer for Malpractice

Yes, you can sue your personal injury lawyer, but only if they fell below the standard of care that a competent lawyer in your state would have met.

A personal injury lawyer can be sued for legal malpractice — which means they made a mistake or failed to act in a way that harmed your case. This is different from disagreeing with their strategy or being unhappy with the outcome. The law recognizes that lawyers are human and make judgment calls; you can only sue if they breached a duty they owed you and that breach cost you money.

The most common grounds for suing a personal injury lawyer are missing a important date (especially the statute of limitations), failing to file required paperwork, not investigating your claim properly, or settling your case without your permission. You can also sue if they had a conflict of interest they did not disclose, or if they abandoned your case without notice.

Before you file a lawsuit, understand that you will need to prove not just that your lawyer made a mistake, but that the mistake caused you to lose money — usually the settlement or judgment you would have won if they had done their job correctly. This is called causation, and it is the hardest part to prove.

Key Takeaways

  • You can sue your lawyer for malpractice only if they breached the duty to act competently and that breach directly cost you money.
  • Missing a statute of limitations important date, failing to file documents, or settling without your consent are the most common grounds for a lawsuit.
  • You will need an informed witness — another lawyer — to testify that your lawyer's conduct fell below the standard of care in your state.
  • Most malpractice claims against personal injury lawyers are resolved through settlement or arbitration, not trial.
  • Your state bar can investigate complaints about lawyer conduct, but a bar complaint is separate from a lawsuit and does not result in money damages.

What Counts as Legal Malpractice

Legal malpractice has three required elements. First, your lawyer owed you a duty of care — which they do the moment you hire them. Second, they breached that duty by doing something a competent lawyer would not have done, or failing to do something a competent lawyer would have done. Third, that breach caused you to lose money.

The most clear-cut cases involve missed important date. If your lawyer missed the statute of limitations — the important date to file your lawsuit — your claim dies and you have no recovery. That is malpractice. Similarly, if they failed to file a required motion, missed a court date, or did not respond to opposing counsel, and the court dismissed your case as a result, you have a strong claim.

Other common breaches include settling your case without your written consent, failing to disclose a conflict of interest (for example, representing both you and the defendant), not investigating your injuries or the defendant's assets, or giving you bad legal information that you relied on to your detriment. Failing to communicate with you about major decisions in your case can also be malpractice.

What does not count is a bad outcome when your lawyer did everything right. If your lawyer took your case to trial, presented the evidence competently, and the jury ruled against you, that is not malpractice — it is just how litigation works sometimes. Disagreeing with your lawyer's trial strategy is also not enough; you would have to show that no reasonable lawyer would have made that choice.

Proving Your Lawyer Caused You Financial Harm

Causation is where most malpractice claims fail. You must prove that if your lawyer had not made the mistake, you would have won more money. This requires you to show what your case was actually worth.

If your lawyer missed the statute of limitations and your case was dismissed, causation is straightforward — you lost the entire value of your claim. But if your lawyer made a mistake during settlement negotiations or trial, you have to prove what a jury would have awarded you if the mistake had not happened. This usually means hiring an informed — often a personal injury lawyer with experience in cases like yours — to testify about what your claim was worth.

You will also need to show the actual damages you suffered. If your lawyer settled your case for $50,000 when it was worth $200,000, your damages are $150,000. If your lawyer missed the important date and your case was dismissed, your damages are the full value of the claim you lost, minus any money you already received.

How to File a Malpractice Lawsuit Against Your Lawyer

Before you sue, you will need to hire a new lawyer — you cannot represent yourself in a malpractice case and expect to win. When you meet with a new lawyer, bring all documents related to your original case: the demand letter, settlement offers, court filings, emails with your original lawyer, and anything else that shows what happened.

Your new lawyer will likely send a demand letter to your original lawyer's malpractice insurance carrier, not to the lawyer directly. Most personal injury lawyers carry malpractice insurance, and the insurance company handles these claims. If the insurance company denies the claim or offers too little, your lawyer will file a lawsuit in civil court.

You will have a limited time to sue — your state has a statute of limitations for malpractice claims, usually between one and three years from the date you discovered (or should have discovered) the malpractice. Some states require you to file a notice of intent to sue before you file the actual lawsuit, giving the lawyer a chance to respond.

Once the lawsuit is filed, discovery begins — both sides exchange documents and take depositions. Your lawyer will need to retain an informed witness to testify that your original lawyer's conduct fell below the standard of care. The defendant's insurance company will hire their own informed to say the opposite. Most cases settle during this phase rather than going to trial.

Filing a Complaint With Your State Bar

Filing a complaint with your state bar is separate from suing your lawyer, and it serves a different purpose. The bar investigates whether your lawyer violated professional conduct rules — things like dishonesty, neglect, or failure to communicate. If the bar finds a violation, they can discipline the lawyer: reprimand, suspension, or disbarment.

A bar complaint does not result in money damages to you. It is a way to protect the public and hold lawyers accountable for ethical violations. But if you want to recover money for the harm your lawyer caused, you must sue for malpractice.

You can file a bar complaint and sue at the same time. In fact, the bar complaint can help your malpractice case — if the bar finds that your lawyer violated conduct rules, that is evidence they breached their duty to you. But do not expect the bar to resolve your case quickly; investigations can take months or years.

Defenses Your Lawyer's Insurance Company Will Raise

The insurance company will argue that your lawyer did not breach their duty, or that the breach did not cause your loss. They may claim your original case was weak and would have lost anyway, so the lawyer's mistake did not matter. They may also argue that you contributed to the problem — for example, by not providing information the lawyer needed, or by ignoring their information.

Some insurance companies will argue that you signed a fee agreement that limited the lawyer's liability, or that you agreed to arbitration instead of litigation. If your fee agreement includes an arbitration clause, your malpractice claim may have to go to arbitration rather than court.

The insurance company may also raise a comparative fault defense, arguing that you share responsibility for the loss. For example, if your lawyer missed a important date but you also failed to follow up or remind them, the insurance company might argue you were partly at fault. This can reduce the damages you recover.

What You Can Recover in a Malpractice Lawsuit

The main recovery in a malpractice case is the money you lost because of your lawyer's mistake. If your original case was worth $200,000 and your lawyer's error reduced it to $50,000, you can recover $150,000 (the difference). If your case was dismissed entirely, you can recover the full value of the claim you lost.

You can also recover the costs of your malpractice lawsuit — filing fees, informed witness fees, deposition costs, and other expenses. In some states, you can recover interest on the damages from the date you discovered the malpractice. You cannot recover punitive damages (extra money meant to punish) unless your lawyer's conduct was intentional and egregious.

You cannot recover for emotional distress or other non-economic damages in most malpractice cases. The law focuses on the financial harm — what your case was worth and what you actually received.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my lawyer while my case is still pending?

Generally no — you must wait until your original case is resolved. If you sue while the case is still active, the court will likely dismiss your malpractice claim as premature. The exception is if your lawyer abandons your case or commits fraud; in those situations, you may be able to sue when ready.

Do I have to pay my new lawyer upfront for a malpractice case?

Many lawyers will take malpractice cases on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover instead of an hourly fee. However, you will usually have to pay for informed witnesses and court costs upfront or as they are incurred. Discuss the fee arrangement before you hire your new lawyer.

What if my original lawyer is no longer in business?

You can still sue the lawyer personally, or their estate if they have died. You can also file a claim against their malpractice insurance policy, which typically remains in force for a period after the lawyer closes their practice. Your new lawyer will help you identify the correct defendant and insurance carrier.

How long does a malpractice lawsuit take?

Most malpractice cases take one to three years from filing to settlement or trial. The timeline depends on how complex your original case was, how much discovery is needed, and whether the insurance company is willing to settle. Cases that go to trial take longer than cases that settle.

Can I get my original case reopened if my lawyer committed malpractice?

In rare cases, yes — if your lawyer's malpractice resulted in a judgment against you, you may be able to file a motion to reopen the case based on ineffective information of counsel. This is difficult and requires showing that your lawyer's conduct was so bad it violated your constitutional right to counsel. Talk to your new lawyer about whether this option exists in your situation.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.