What Happens to Your Case When the Defendant Hires Their Own Legal Team
The defendant's legal team is separate from yours, and they work to minimize what you receive
When someone is sued for causing your injury, they hire their own lawyer or law firm—often called the defense counsel or defense team. This is not the same as your lawyer. The defendant's attorney represents the defendant's interests, which means they are working against you, not with you. Understanding who they are and what they do helps you know what to expect as your case moves forward.
In many cases, the defendant does not pay for their own lawyer directly. Instead, their insurance company (whether auto, homeowner's, or business liability insurance) hires and pays for the defense. This matters because it means the insurance company is also making decisions about the case—not just the defendant themselves. The defense team's job is to challenge your claim, question your injuries, and try to settle for as little money as possible.
You will encounter the defense team at several points: during discovery (when both sides exchange documents and information), at depositions (recorded question-and-answer sessions), and potentially at trial. Knowing what role they play at each stage helps you prepare and protects you from mistakes that could hurt your case.
Key Takeaways
- The defendant's lawyer works for the defendant or their insurance company, not for you, and their goal is to reduce or deny your claim.
- In most cases, insurance pays for the defense attorney, which means the insurance company has significant control over the defense strategy.
- You will interact with the defense team during discovery, depositions, and settlement negotiations, and anything you say can be used against you.
- Your own attorney should handle all communication with the defense team; you should not speak to them directly or answer their questions without your lawyer present.
- The defense team may hire their own medical experts, investigators, and other professionals to challenge your version of events and your injury claims.
Who pays for the defendant's lawyer and why it matters
In the vast majority of personal injury cases, the defendant's insurance company pays for their legal defense. This is true whether the case involves a car accident, a slip-and-fall at a business, or an injury on someone's property. The insurance policy typically includes a clause requiring the company to defend the policyholder against claims. This means the insurance company not only pays the lawyer's fees but also has a say in how the case is handled.
Because the insurance company is footing the bill, they have financial incentive to settle your case for as little as possible—or to fight it entirely if they believe they can win. The defense attorney answers to both the defendant and the insurance company, and sometimes those interests conflict. For example, the defendant might want to settle quickly, but the insurance company might push for a trial because they believe they can win and pay nothing.
In rare cases, the defendant pays for their own lawyer out of pocket. This usually happens when the defendant's insurance has denied coverage (meaning they claim the policy does not cover this type of claim) or when the defendant is self-insured. Even then, the lawyer's job is the same: to defend the defendant and minimize your recovery.
What the defense team does during discovery and depositions
Discovery is the phase where both sides exchange documents, medical records, photographs, witness statements, and other evidence. The defense team will request your medical records, employment history, social media accounts, prior injuries, and anything else they think might weaken your claim. They are looking for inconsistencies, gaps in treatment, or evidence that your injuries are not as serious as you say they are.
Your attorney will object to requests that are too broad, too invasive, or not relevant to the case. But you should expect the defense to ask for a lot, and you should expect your lawyer to advise you on what you must provide and what can be limited. Do not destroy, hide, or alter any documents or evidence—doing so can result in serious legal consequences and can destroy your case.
At your deposition, the defense attorney will ask you questions under oath. This is a recorded session, and everything you say can be used against you later. The defense is looking for statements that contradict your claim, admissions that minimize your injuries, or evidence that you are exaggerating. Your own attorney will be present and can object to certain questions, but you are the one answering. Before your deposition, your lawyer should prepare you thoroughly on what to expect and how to answer carefully and truthfully.
How the defense challenges your injury claim
The defense team will often hire their own medical experts to review your medical records and challenge your diagnosis, treatment, or prognosis. These experts may conclude that your injuries are less severe than your doctors say, that you recovered faster than you claim, or that your current symptoms are not related to the accident. This is a standard defense tactic and does not mean your claim is weak—it means the defense is doing their job.
The defense may also hire investigators to photograph the accident scene, interview witnesses, or gather evidence that contradicts your account. They might obtain surveillance video, cell phone records, or other documentation. If you made any statements to police, insurance adjusters, or others at the time of the accident, the defense will have those and will use them to challenge your current testimony if there are any differences.
The defense may also argue that you were partially at fault for the accident, that you failed to follow medical information, that you returned to normal activities too quickly (suggesting your injuries were not serious), or that your damages are overstated. Each of these is a common defense strategy, and your attorney should be prepared to counter each one with evidence and informed testimony of your own.
Settlement negotiations with the defense
Most personal injury cases settle before trial, and settlement negotiations happen between your attorney and the defense attorney. The defense will make an initial offer, usually much lower than what you are asking for. Your attorney will counter with a higher number. This back-and-forth continues until both sides reach an agreement or decide that settlement is not possible.
During negotiations, the defense will use everything they have learned in discovery to argue that your case is weak. They will point to gaps in your medical treatment, inconsistencies in your statements, or evidence that contradicts your version of events. Your attorney will counter by emphasizing the strength of your claim, the credibility of your evidence, and the risks the defense faces if the case goes to trial.
You should never negotiate directly with the defense attorney or the insurance company adjuster. Let your attorney handle all communication. Anything you say can be used against you, and you may inadvertently weaken your position by saying something that sounds like you are accepting less than you deserve or admitting fault.
What to do if the defense contacts you directly
The defense attorney or insurance company may try to contact you directly by phone, email, or in person. In most states, once you have hired an attorney, the defense is required to communicate only through your lawyer. If they contact you directly, tell them you have an attorney and give them your attorney's contact information. Do not answer their questions, do not agree to meet with them, and do not sign anything.
If the defense contacts you before you have hired an attorney, you can still refuse to speak with them. You have the right to say, "I do not want to speak with you without my attorney present." Then contact a personal injury attorney as soon as possible. Anything you say to the defense without your attorney present can be used against you in court.
Document any contact from the defense—write down the date, time, who called or emailed, and what they said. Tell your attorney when ready. This information may be relevant to your case and could affect settlement negotiations or trial strategy.
How the defense strategy affects your case timeline
The defense team's actions directly impact how long your case takes to resolve. If the defense is aggressive in discovery, requesting large amounts of documents and scheduling multiple depositions, your case will take longer. If they hire multiple experts or conduct extensive investigations, that also extends the timeline. Some defense teams use delay as a strategy, hoping that you will become frustrated and accept a lower settlement offer.
Your attorney should keep you informed about the defense's actions and explain how they affect your case. If the defense is being unreasonable—requesting documents that are not relevant, scheduling depositions at inconvenient times, or using other delay tactics—your attorney can file motions with the court to limit their requests or set reasonable important date.
Understanding that delay is sometimes a defense tactic helps you stay patient and focused on your case rather than becoming frustrated and making poor decisions under pressure. Your attorney's job is to move the case forward efficiently while protecting your interests.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the defense attorney talk to me directly, or do they have to go through my lawyer?
Once you have hired an attorney, the defense must communicate through your lawyer in most states. If they contact you directly, you can refuse to speak with them and refer them to your attorney. If you have not hired an attorney yet, you can still decline to speak with them without a lawyer present.
What happens if I say something to the defense that contradicts what I told my attorney?
The defense will use that contradiction to argue that you are not credible or that you are lying. This is why it is critical to be consistent and to let your attorney do all the talking. If you realize you made a mistake or said something inaccurate, tell your attorney when ready so they can address it before trial.
Can the defense use my social media posts against me?
Yes. The defense will often request access to your social media accounts during discovery. Posts, photos, or comments that show you doing activities you claimed you could not do, or that contradict your injury claims, can seriously damage your case. Before and during your case, be very careful about what you post online.
What if the defense's medical informed says my injuries are not real?
Your attorney will hire your own medical informed to counter that opinion. At trial, the jury will hear from both experts and decide who is more credible. This is normal in personal injury cases, and having a strong medical informed on your side is important to your case.
Does the defense have to tell me what evidence they have?
Yes, through the discovery process. Both sides must exchange relevant documents, reports, and other evidence. Your attorney will review everything the defense provides and explain what it means for your case. If the defense fails to provide evidence they are required to share, your attorney can file a motion to compel them to do so.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.