Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

When You're Sued for Personal Injury: What a Defense Solicitor Does

What a defendant's personal injury solicitor does

A defendant personal injury solicitor represents the person or business being sued for causing injury. Their job is not to prove you did nothing wrong — it is to protect your legal interests, manage the claim fairly, and keep costs down. They handle communication with the claimant's solicitor, gather evidence about what happened, advise you on settlement, and prepare a defense if the case goes to trial.

Most personal injury claims settle before trial. A defendant's solicitor negotiates that settlement, reviews medical reports, and tells you what the claim is actually worth based on similar cases. They also manage your insurance company's involvement, because in most cases your liability insurance is paying for both the solicitor and any settlement.

The work starts the moment you receive a letter of claim or a court document. Waiting or ignoring it makes everything worse — costs rise, important date are missed, and judges penalize you for not responding. A solicitor's first job is to stop the clock and tell you what you actually need to do.

Key Takeaways

  • A defendant's solicitor protects your interests from the moment you receive a claim, and ignoring the letter costs you money and legal ground.
  • Most claims settle through negotiation; your solicitor handles that conversation and advises you on what the claim is worth.
  • Your liability insurance usually pays for the solicitor and any settlement, so the cost to you may be zero if the claim is covered.
  • You need a solicitor quickly because court important date are strict and missing them can result in judgment against you without a trial.
  • A solicitor can sometimes resolve a claim before it reaches court, which saves time and money for everyone involved.

When you need a defendant's solicitor when ready

You need one as soon as you receive a formal letter of claim or court papers. The clock starts the moment that letter arrives, and the important date are real. In most cases you have 14 days to acknowledge the claim and 28 days to file a defense. Missing those dates means the claimant can ask the court for judgment against you without a trial — and the court will often grant it.

Even if you think the claim is unfair or exaggerated, do not ignore it or try to handle it alone. A solicitor's first step is to write back within the important date, which stops the claimant from taking shortcuts. They also review your insurance policy to confirm the claim is covered, because if it is not, you need to know that when ready.

If you have already received a court document (a claim form filed at court rather than a letter from a solicitor), the important date is even tighter. You typically have 14 days to respond. At that point, a solicitor is not optional — it is the difference between defending yourself and having judgment entered against you by default.

How defendant solicitors work with your insurance

Most personal injury claims are covered by liability insurance — either your home insurance, car insurance, or business insurance. Your insurer has a legal duty to defend you, which means they pay for your solicitor. This is called legal representation or legal defense under your policy.

When you receive a claim, contact your insurance company first. Tell them you have received a letter or court papers and ask them to appoint a solicitor. They will either give you a choice of solicitors or assign one from their panel. Either way, the insurer pays the bill. You do not pay the solicitor directly unless the claim falls outside your coverage.

The solicitor works for you, but they also report to the insurer because the insurer is funding the defense. This is normal and not a conflict of interest — your interests and the insurer's interests are the same: defend the claim fairly and keep costs down. If a genuine conflict arises (for example, if the insurer wants to settle and you want to fight), you can instruct your own solicitor at your own cost, but this is rare.

What happens during the defense process

Once you have a solicitor, they will ask you detailed questions about what happened. They need your account in writing, any photographs, emails, text messages, or documents related to the incident. They will also ask about any injuries you suffered, medical treatment you received, and any witnesses. This is not an interrogation — they need this information to build your defense and to understand what the other side will claim.

Your solicitor will then request the claimant's evidence: medical reports, photographs of injuries, proof of lost wages, receipts for treatment. They will review these carefully and often instruct their own medical informed to examine the claimant or review the medical evidence. This informed report is crucial because it either supports or undermines the claimant's injury claim.

Throughout this process, your solicitor and the claimant's solicitor exchange information and negotiate. Many claims settle at this stage because both sides can see what a judge would likely award. If settlement talks stall, your solicitor will prepare for trial: drafting written statements, organizing evidence, and preparing you to give evidence in court if necessary.

Settlement negotiation and what it costs

Settlement means the claimant agrees to accept a sum of money in exchange for dropping the claim. Your solicitor negotiates this amount. They will tell you what similar claims have settled for, what the claimant's injuries are worth under the law, and what the risks are if the case goes to trial. They will also factor in legal costs — the claimant's solicitor fees, informed fees, and court fees — which can be substantial.

If you settle, you usually pay the claimant's compensation, their solicitor's fees, and your own solicitor's fees. Your insurance company pays all of this from the claim budget. If you do not settle and lose at trial, you pay the same amounts plus trial costs, which are higher. This is why settlement often makes financial sense even if you believe you were not at fault.

Your solicitor cannot force you to settle — that decision is yours. But they will advise you on the realistic value of the claim and the cost of fighting it. If they tell you the claim is worth £5,000 and the claimant is asking for £4,500, refusing to settle usually costs more in the long run.

Finding and choosing a defendant solicitor

If your insurance company appoints a solicitor, you do not need to search — they handle it. But you have the right to choose your own solicitor if you prefer, though you will usually pay for it yourself unless your insurer agrees otherwise. If you do need to find one, look for a solicitor or firm with experience in personal injury defense, not just personal injury claims.

Ask about their experience with claims similar to yours. If you were in a car accident, find someone who handles motor claims. If it is a workplace injury, find someone experienced in employer's liability. Ask how they charge — most work on a fixed fee or hourly rate, and your insurer will have agreed a rate with them already.

Check that they are regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA). You can verify this on the SRA website. Ask about their response time — can they acknowledge the claim within the important date? Do they have a dedicated contact person? These practical details matter because delays cost money and missed important date cost you the case.

Red flags and what to watch for

Be cautious if a solicitor does not ask detailed questions about what happened. They need your account to build a defense, and if they skip this step, they are not doing the job properly. Similarly, if they do not explain the process or keep you informed about progress, that is a problem. You should hear from them regularly, especially as important date approach.

Watch for pressure to settle quickly without proper investigation. A good solicitor will gather evidence and get informed reports before recommending settlement. If they want to settle within days of receiving the claim, ask why. Sometimes it is the right call, but sometimes it is laziness.

If your insurer appoints a solicitor and you genuinely do not trust them, you can ask for a different one from the panel. You do not have to accept the first appointment. If no one on the panel suits you, you can instruct your own solicitor, though you will need to discuss costs with your insurer first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to use the solicitor my insurance company chooses?

No. You can request a different solicitor from your insurer's panel, or instruct your own. However, your insurer must agree to pay for it, and they usually will if you have a good reason. If you choose your own solicitor outside the panel, you may have to pay the difference in fees yourself.

What if I think the claim is completely unfair?

Tell your solicitor when ready. They will investigate thoroughly and advise you on your chances of winning. Even if you believe you are in the right, a solicitor will give you an honest assessment of what a judge would likely decide. Sometimes the law does not work the way you expect, and a solicitor's job is to tell you that plainly.

Can the claimant's solicitor contact me directly?

They can, but you should not speak to them without your solicitor present. Once you have appointed a solicitor, the claimant's solicitor should direct all communication to them. If the other side contacts you directly, tell your solicitor when ready. Do not discuss the claim or admit fault.

What happens if I cannot afford to settle and the claimant wins?

Your insurance company pays the judgment, compensation, and legal costs up to your policy limit. If the claim exceeds your limit, you may be liable for the excess. This is why it is important to review your insurance coverage early — your solicitor can help you understand what is and is not covered.

How long does a personal injury defense usually take?

Most claims settle within three to nine months. If the case goes to trial, it can take one to two years from the date of the claim. Your solicitor will give you a realistic timeline based on the complexity of the claim and the court's schedule. Straightforward claims settle faster than those involving serious injury or disputed liability.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.