Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What to Expect When You're Named as a Defendant in a Personal Injury Claim

What it means to be a defendant in a personal injury case

When someone files a personal injury claim against you, you become the defendant — the person being sued. This does not mean you are automatically liable or that you have done something wrong. It means someone believes you caused them harm and is asking a court to decide whether that is true, and if so, what you should pay them.

The claim will arrive as formal paperwork, usually from a solicitor acting for the person suing you (called the claimant). You will have a set time to respond — typically 14 days to acknowledge receipt, then 28 days to file a formal defence. Missing these important date can result in a judgment against you without your side being heard.

In Manchester, as across England, personal injury claims follow the Civil Procedure Rules. Most cases settle before trial, but you need to understand what happens at each stage and what your options are.

Key Takeaways

  • You must respond to the claim within the time limits set by the court, or a judgment can be entered against you without a hearing.
  • A solicitor who specialises in defending personal injury claims can advise whether the claim has merit and what your best response is.
  • Most cases settle through negotiation or mediation rather than going to trial, but you need legal representation to protect your position.
  • Your own insurance — whether public liability, employers' liability, or motor — may cover the cost of your defence and any settlement.
  • The claimant must prove their case on the balance of probabilities, meaning they must show it is more likely than not that you caused their injury.

How to find a solicitor who defends personal injury claims

You need a solicitor who specialises in defending claims, not one who represents claimants. This matters because the strategy, the contacts, and the way the case is handled are different. A defendant's solicitor will assess the strength of the claim against you, advise on your liability, and work to reduce any payout or defeat the claim entirely.

In Manchester, solicitors who defend personal injury claims are often part of larger firms with dedicated defence teams. You can search the Law Society website by postcode and filter for firms that list "personal injury defence" or "defendant representation" as a practice area. Some firms work exclusively for insurance companies, but many take direct instructions from individuals and small businesses.

When you contact a solicitor, tell them the date you received the claim and what the claim is about. Ask whether they have experience defending claims of that type — a solicitor experienced in workplace injury claims may not be the right fit for a motor accident defence. Most will offer an initial consultation to discuss the case and explain their fees.

What happens after you instruct a solicitor

Your solicitor will review the claim paperwork and ask you detailed questions about what happened. Be honest and thorough — they need the full picture to advise you properly, and anything you tell them is protected by legal privilege (meaning it stays confidential). They will then write a defence, which is your formal response to the court setting out why you dispute the claim or why the claimant's injuries or losses are not as serious as claimed.

Once the defence is filed, the case enters a process called disclosure, where both sides exchange documents relevant to the claim. Your solicitor will gather evidence — witness statements, photographs, CCTV footage, medical records, or anything else that supports your version of events. The claimant's solicitor will do the same.

At this stage, both solicitors usually begin negotiating. Many cases settle here because both sides can see the strength of the other's evidence. If settlement talks stall, the case may go to mediation — a structured negotiation with a neutral third party — before proceeding to trial.

Whether your insurance covers your defence

Check your insurance policy when ready. If you have public liability insurance (for a business), employers' liability insurance (if you employ staff), or motor insurance (for a driving-related claim), the policy almost certainly covers your legal defence and any damages you are ordered to pay, up to the policy limit.

Contact your insurer as soon as you receive the claim. They will either appoint a solicitor for you or allow you to instruct your own. If they appoint one, that solicitor works for you, not the insurance company, though the insurer pays the bill. If you choose your own solicitor, the insurer will usually agree to pay their fees provided the solicitor is on their approved panel.

If you do not have insurance, you will need to pay your solicitor's fees yourself. Many solicitors offer fixed fees for defending straightforward claims, or hourly rates for more complex cases. Ask about this upfront so you understand the cost.

The difference between admitting and defending the claim

You have three options when you receive a claim: admit it in full, admit it in part, or defend it entirely. Your solicitor will advise which is realistic based on the evidence.

If you admit the claim, the case moves straight to the stage where the court decides how much you must pay. You avoid the cost and time of defending, but you lose any chance of reducing the payout. Admitting part of the claim means you accept some responsibility but dispute the amount of injury or loss claimed.

If you defend the claim, you are saying either that you did not cause the injury, or that the claimant's account of what happened is wrong, or that their injuries are not as serious as they say. The claimant then has to prove their case. This takes longer and costs more, but if you win, you pay nothing.

What the trial process looks like if the case does not settle

If the case reaches trial, it will be heard in the County Court (for claims under £100,000) or the High Court (for larger claims). The trial is a formal hearing where both sides present evidence and arguments to a judge, who then decides whether you are liable and, if so, how much to pay.

You will usually attend the trial, and you may be asked to give evidence. Your solicitor will prepare you for this and will cross-examine the claimant and their witnesses. The claimant's solicitor will do the same to you. The judge then considers all the evidence and delivers a judgment.

Trials are rare in personal injury cases — most settle during the pre-trial stages because both sides can see how the judge is likely to rule. But if your case does go to trial, your solicitor will guide you through every step and represent your interests in court.

Costs and what you might have to pay

If you lose the case, you will usually have to pay not only the damages awarded but also the claimant's legal costs. This can be substantial. However, if you win, the claimant usually pays your costs. This is why settlement negotiations often focus on both liability and costs — each side weighs the risk of losing and having to pay the other side's bill.

Your solicitor's fees depend on how the case is structured. Some solicitors charge hourly rates; others offer fixed fees for particular stages. If your case is insured, the insurer pays. If not, discuss fees carefully with your solicitor before you instruct them. Some firms offer payment plans or conditional fee arrangements (where they take a percentage of any money saved if the claim is reduced or defeated).

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do the moment I receive a claim?

Do not ignore it or delay. Write down the date you received it and note the important date for your response. Contact your insurance company when ready if you have relevant cover. Then contact a solicitor who defends personal injury claims. The sooner you instruct someone, the sooner they can advise you and meet the court important date.

Can I represent myself instead of hiring a solicitor?

You can, but it is risky. Personal injury claims involve strict procedural rules, and missing a important date or filing documents incorrectly can result in judgment against you. A solicitor knows the rules, has experience with similar claims, and can negotiate on your behalf. The cost of a solicitor is usually far less than the cost of losing a case you could have defended.

What if I think the claim is completely unfair?

Your solicitor will assess the claim objectively and advise you on its strength. Even if you believe the claim is unfair, the question is whether a court would agree. Your solicitor will explain what evidence you need to prove your version of events and what the realistic outcome is. This honest assessment helps you decide whether to defend, settle, or negotiate.

How long does a personal injury case usually take?

From claim to settlement, most cases take between six months and two years, depending on complexity and whether both sides cooperate. Cases that go to trial take longer. Your solicitor can give you a more specific timeline once they have reviewed the claim and understand what is in dispute.

What if I cannot afford to pay a settlement?

This is a question for your solicitor and, if applicable, your insurer. If you are ordered to pay damages you cannot afford, you may be able to negotiate a payment plan with the claimant. Your solicitor can discuss this as part of settlement negotiations. If you have insurance, the insurer will pay up to your policy limit.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.