How to Find and Use Plaintiff Records in a Personal Injury Case
What plaintiff records are and why your lawyer needs them
Plaintiff records are documents that show what happened to the person suing — medical reports, bills, lost wages, prior injuries, and anything else that proves the harm they claim. Your lawyer uses these to build the case: to show how serious the injury is, how much it cost, and whether the defendant caused it. Without them, you have only a story. With them, you have proof.
The records come from different places depending on what happened. A car accident case needs medical records from the hospital, repair estimates for the vehicle, and pay stubs showing lost work. A slip-and-fall case needs photos of the hazard, medical records, and sometimes witness statements. A product injury case needs the product itself, medical records, and sometimes informed analysis. Your lawyer will tell you which ones matter for your case.
You usually gather these records yourself in the early stages, then your lawyer requests more from the other side through a formal process called discovery. The defendant's insurance company and their lawyers will also ask you for records — and you must provide them, even if they hurt your case.
Key Takeaways
- Plaintiff records include medical reports, bills, photos, pay stubs, and anything else proving the injury and its cost — your lawyer needs them to build the case.
- You start by gathering records yourself from hospitals, doctors, employers, and insurance companies using written requests or online patient portals.
- Your lawyer will request additional records from the defendant and other parties through discovery, a formal legal process that requires them to respond within a set time.
- The defendant's side can also request your records, and you must provide them — hiding or destroying records can result in sanctions or dismissal of your case.
- Medical records usually take two to four weeks to arrive, but older records or those from multiple providers can take longer.
Medical records: where to request them and what to expect
Start with the hospital or clinic where you were treated after the injury. Call the medical records department — not the front desk — and ask for a records request form. Most hospitals have one online. You will need to provide your name, date of birth, the date of service, and specify which records you want: the full chart, imaging (X-rays, MRI), lab results, or just the discharge summary. Some places charge a copying fee, usually a few dollars per page.
If you were treated by multiple doctors — your primary care doctor, a specialist, physical therapy — request from each one separately. Do not assume one office has records from another. Many healthcare systems are now connected through electronic health records, but many are not. Ask each provider whether they can see records from other places you were treated.
Request in writing, not by phone, so you have proof you asked. Email works if the provider accepts it; otherwise, use their form and mail or fax it. Include a important date — "I need these by [date two weeks out]" — and explain why if you can: "I am working with my lawyer on a personal injury case." Providers often move faster when they know it is legal work. Expect two to four weeks for standard records, longer if you need old records or records from multiple locations.
Once you have the records, read them carefully. Medical records contain errors — wrong dates, confused symptoms, notes from a different patient. If you spot something wrong, ask the provider to correct it in writing. Do not alter the record yourself.
Billing and wage records: what to gather and how
Medical bills show what the injury cost. Request an itemized bill from each provider — not just a summary. The itemized version breaks down what was charged for: the emergency room visit, the CT scan, the surgeon's fee, the hospital stay. Insurance companies and judges look at these to understand the full scope of treatment.
If insurance paid part of the bill, ask the provider for an explanation of benefits (EOB) from your insurance company. This shows what was billed, what insurance paid, and what you owe. Keep both the bill and the EOB together.
For lost wages, get a letter from your employer on company letterhead stating: the dates you missed work, your hourly rate or salary, and the total amount of pay you lost. If you are self-employed, gather tax returns from the year of the injury and the year before, plus bank statements showing income during the period you could not work. These are harder to prove, so keep detailed records of what you would have earned.
Gather receipts for out-of-pocket costs: over-the-counter medications, medical equipment, transportation to appointments, home care help. Keep them organized by date. Your lawyer will use these to show the full financial impact of the injury.
Photos, videos, and physical evidence
If you took photos or video of the scene, the injury, or the hazard that caused it, gather those now. Photos of a wet floor before you fell, a defective product, road conditions at the time of an accident — these are powerful evidence. If you did not take them, ask whether anyone else did: a witness, a family member, the business where it happened.
For a vehicle accident, get the police report. Call the police department's records division and request the report by the accident date and location. There is usually a small fee. The report includes the officer's observations, statements from both drivers, and sometimes photos or diagrams.
If the injury involved a product — a tool, appliance, vehicle part — keep it if possible, even if it is broken. Your lawyer may need an informed to examine it. If you cannot keep it, photograph it from multiple angles before disposal.
Preserve anything that shows the defendant's negligence: a broken handrail, a pothole, a warning label that was missing. Take photos with today's date visible if you can, or note the date you took them.
Discovery: what the other side can request from you
Once the lawsuit starts, the defendant's lawyer can request your records through discovery — a formal process where both sides exchange documents and answer questions. You will receive a document request listing what they want: all medical records, all communications about the injury, all photos, all financial records related to lost wages.
You must provide what they ask for, with limited exceptions. You cannot hide records because they hurt your case. If you do, the judge can dismiss your case or impose penalties. Your lawyer will review what you have and prepare it for delivery, usually removing personal information unrelated to the injury (like medical records about an unrelated condition).
The defendant will also send written questions called interrogatories: "Describe in detail how the injury occurred." "List all medical treatment you received." "State the total amount of wages you lost." Your lawyer will help you answer these accurately and completely. Do not exaggerate or leave things out.
You may also be deposed — questioned under oath by the defendant's lawyer, with a court reporter recording everything. Bring all your records to the deposition. Your lawyer will prepare you beforehand.
What to do if records are missing or incomplete
If a provider says they have no records, ask them to provide that in writing. Some records are legitimately lost — old files are sometimes destroyed after a certain period. If that happens, your lawyer can request that the provider testify about what they remember, or can work with an informed who can infer what treatment likely occurred based on the records you do have.
If you cannot locate a witness or a document, tell your lawyer when ready. Do not wait until trial. Your lawyer may be able to request it from the other side, or may need to adjust the case strategy. Hiding the fact that evidence is missing until the last moment damages your credibility and your case.
If the defendant's side has records you need — like security camera footage from a business, maintenance records showing a known hazard — your lawyer can request them through discovery. If they refuse or claim the records do not exist, your lawyer can file a motion to compel, asking the judge to force them to produce the records or explain why they cannot.
Organizing records for your lawyer
Once you have gathered everything, organize it chronologically by date. Create a straightforward list: date, source, and what the document is. For example: "3/15/2023 — Memorial Hospital — Emergency room discharge summary." This makes it straightforward for your lawyer to find things and to present them to the court.
Keep originals safe. Make copies for your lawyer and for your own records. If records are electronic, save them in a folder on your computer with clear file names. If they are paper, use a binder or folder with tabs for each category: medical records, bills, wage records, photos, police report.
Share everything with your lawyer as soon as you have it. Do not wait until the case is ready for trial. Your lawyer needs time to review the records, spot gaps, and request more if needed. The earlier your lawyer sees what you have, the better the case strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get records from my doctor without my lawyer's help?
Yes. You can request your own medical records directly from any provider. You have a legal right to them under HIPAA (the federal health privacy law). Call the medical records department, fill out their form, and they must provide them within 30 days. Your lawyer can also request them, which sometimes moves faster because providers know it is for a lawsuit.
What if I signed a medical release form but the provider still won't give me records?
Follow up in writing. Email or mail a second request with a copy of the signed release. If they still refuse, tell your lawyer — they can file a motion to compel or subpoena the records. Providers sometimes lose requests or delay; persistence usually works.
Do I have to give the other side my personal medical records unrelated to the injury?
Generally no. If you were treated for depression in 2015 and your injury was in 2024, the defendant cannot demand those records unless they are somehow relevant to your claim. Your lawyer will review discovery requests and object to ones that are too broad. Some requests are legitimate — if you claim the injury caused depression, they can ask for mental health records after the injury.
What happens if I cannot find a receipt for a medical bill I paid out of pocket?
Tell your lawyer. If the amount is small, it may not matter much. If it is large, your lawyer may ask the provider for a copy of the bill or ask your bank for a statement showing the payment. Credit card statements and bank transfers are proof even without a receipt. Do not make up a receipt or guess at an amount.
Can I record a conversation with the other driver or a witness about the accident?
This depends on your state's recording laws. Some states allow recording if one person in the conversation consents (you); others require all parties to consent. Ask your lawyer before recording anyone. Even if it is legal, recording can damage your credibility if it comes out in court, so your lawyer may advise against it.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.