Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

How to Appeal a Personal Injury Decision

What happens when you appeal a personal injury judgment

An appeal is a request to a higher court to review whether the lower court made a legal error in your case — not to retry the facts or ask a judge to change their mind because you disagree. The appellate court looks at the trial record, the law that was applied, and the judge's reasoning. They do not hear new evidence or new witnesses. If the appellate court finds the trial judge misapplied the law, misunderstood the evidence, or made a procedural mistake that affected the outcome, they can overturn the decision, order a new trial, or send the case back for correction.

The appeal process is expensive, slow, and has strict rules about timing and what you can argue. Most personal injury cases settle before trial, and most trial verdicts stand on appeal. You need to understand what errors the appellate court will actually review, what important date you face, and whether an appeal makes financial sense for your case.

Key Takeaways

  • You must file a notice of appeal within 30 days of the judgment in most states, or you lose the right to appeal entirely.
  • An appellate court reviews whether the trial judge made a legal error, not whether you think the verdict was unfair or the damages too low.
  • Appeals cost thousands of dollars in filing fees, transcript costs, and attorney time, and most verdicts are upheld on appeal.
  • You need a written record of what happened at trial — if the trial was not transcribed or recorded, you cannot appeal.
  • Some decisions, like dismissals before trial or rulings on motions, can be appealed when ready; others must wait until the case ends.

The 30-day important date and how to preserve your right to appeal

The clock starts the day the judge signs the judgment. In most states, you have 30 days to file a notice of appeal — a short document that tells the court and the other side you are appealing. Missing this important date means you cannot appeal, period. There is no second chance and no extension unless you can show extraordinary circumstances, which courts almost never grant.

Before the important date, you should also file a motion for a new trial or a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict (called a JNOV in some states). These motions ask the trial judge to reconsider or overturn their own decision. They rarely succeed, but filing one can extend your appeal important date by a few days in some states and preserves certain arguments for appeal. Your attorney should file these as a matter of routine if you plan to appeal.

You also need to order the trial transcript when ready. The court reporter or court clerk can tell you the cost — it is usually several hundred dollars. Without a transcript, the appellate court has no record of what was said, what evidence was shown, or what the judge ruled on. You cannot appeal without it.

What kinds of errors an appellate court will review

Appellate courts do not second-guess a jury's verdict on the facts. They will not overturn a decision just because they think the damages were too low or the jury got it wrong. They review only legal errors — mistakes about what the law is or how it was applied.

Common legal errors that can be appealed include: the judge gave the jury wrong instructions about the law; the judge excluded evidence that should have been admitted; the judge admitted evidence that should have been excluded; the judge made a mistake in calculating damages under the law; the judge dismissed the case on legal grounds before trial when the facts should have gone to a jury; or the judge made a procedural error that prevented you from presenting your case fairly.

You cannot appeal because you think the jury did not believe your witnesses, or because you think the other side's evidence was unfair, or because you wish you had presented your case differently. Those are factual judgments, and juries have the power to make them. Appellate courts will not redo that work.

The cost and timeline of an appeal

An appeal typically takes one to three years from the notice of appeal to a final decision. The process moves slowly because appellate courts handle many cases and written briefs take time to prepare and review.

Costs include the trial transcript (usually $500 to $2,000), court filing fees ($300 to $500), printing and binding of briefs ($500 to $1,500), and attorney time. A personal injury appeal usually costs $5,000 to $15,000 in total, and complex cases cost more. If you lost at trial and are appealing a judgment against you, you may also have to post a supersedeas bond — a may provide that you will pay the judgment if the appeal fails. This bond can cost thousands of dollars.

Most verdicts are upheld on appeal. Studies show that roughly 80 to 90 percent of trial judgments survive appellate review. Before you spend this money, your attorney should honestly assess whether the trial judge made a legal error that an appellate court is likely to find and reverse. If the trial was conducted fairly and the judge applied the law correctly, an appeal is unlikely to succeed.

How the appeal process works step by step

After you file the notice of appeal, you enter the briefing stage. You (the appellant) file an appellant's brief — a written argument explaining what legal error the trial judge made and why the appellate court should reverse or order a new trial. The other side files a respondent's brief answering your arguments. You may file a reply brief responding to their response. Each brief must follow strict rules about length, formatting, and how you cite the law and the trial record.

The appellate court then reviews the briefs and the trial record. In some cases, the court decides the appeal based on the written briefs alone. In others, the court schedules oral argument — a hearing where your attorney and the other side's attorney answer questions from the judges. Oral argument usually lasts 15 to 30 minutes per side.

After oral argument (or after reviewing the briefs if there is no argument), the court issues a written decision. The decision explains what the court found, what law applies, and whether the trial judge made an error. If the court reverses, it may order a new trial, send the case back to the trial court for correction, or in rare cases, enter judgment in your favor.

When you can appeal before the trial ends

Most appeals happen after a final judgment — after the trial is over and the judge has ruled on everything. But some decisions can be appealed when ready, even if the case is not finished.

If the trial judge dismisses your case before trial on legal grounds — for example, ruling that you did not file within the statute of limitations, or that the law does not allow your type of claim — you can appeal that dismissal right away. You do not have to wait for trial. The same is true if the judge grants summary judgment to the other side, meaning the judge ruled that you have no evidence of an essential fact and cannot win even if a jury believed everything you said.

Rulings during trial — like decisions to exclude evidence or give certain jury instructions — usually cannot be appealed until after the trial ends and a final judgment is entered. If you want to preserve those issues for appeal, you must object to the ruling at trial and make a clear record of your objection in the trial transcript.

Alternatives to a full appeal

A full appeal is not the only option. Some courts allow a motion for reconsideration, where you ask the trial judge to change their mind within a short time after judgment. This rarely works, but it is cheaper than an appeal and sometimes reveals an obvious mistake the judge overlooked.

You can also negotiate a settlement with the other side after judgment. Many cases that go to trial settle on appeal because both sides want to avoid the cost and delay of appellate review. If you lost at trial, the other side may offer to pay you something to avoid the risk of reversal. If you won but the other side is appealing, you may accept a payment to end the case.

In rare cases, you may be able to file a motion for a new trial based on newly discovered evidence — evidence that existed but was not available at trial through no fault of yours. This is a long shot, but it avoids a full appeal if successful.

Working with an attorney on your appeal

Appeals are technical and require knowledge of appellate procedure and law. You should have an attorney review your case before you decide to appeal. Some trial attorneys also handle appeals, but many cases benefit from an attorney who specializes in appellate work — they know the rules, the judges, and what arguments appellate courts actually listen to.

Your attorney should give you a realistic assessment of your chances. If the trial judge applied the law correctly and made no clear error, an appeal is unlikely to succeed no matter how unfair the outcome feels. If there is a genuine legal error, your attorney should explain what it is, why it matters, and what the appellate court is likely to do about it.

Ask your attorney upfront what the appeal will cost, how long it will take, and what the realistic odds of success are. Get this in writing. If your attorney cannot give you a straight answer, that is a sign to get a second opinion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I appeal if I missed the 30-day important date?

Almost never. The important date is absolute in most states. Courts will not extend it unless you can show you did not receive notice of the judgment or your attorney abandoned you without explanation. Even then, courts are reluctant to grant relief. If you missed the important date, you have lost the right to appeal.

What if I cannot afford the cost of an appeal?

If you cannot afford the transcript, filing fees, or attorney costs, you can ask the court for permission to proceed in forma pauperis — which waives or reduces some fees. You must show the court that you are genuinely unable to pay. This does not cover attorney fees, so you would still need a lawyer willing to work for free or reduced pay, which is rare in personal injury appeals.

Can I appeal a settlement agreement?

No. Once you sign a settlement agreement, you have given up your right to sue or appeal. Settlement agreements usually include a clause saying you cannot challenge the deal in court. If you were pressured into a settlement or your attorney made a serious mistake, you might have a claim against your attorney, but you cannot appeal the settlement itself.

How long does an appeal take?

Most appeals take one to three years from the notice of appeal to a final decision. Some take longer if the appellate court has a heavy caseload or if the case is complex. During this time, you are waiting for a decision and cannot move forward with anything else in the case.

What happens if I win the appeal?

If the appellate court reverses the trial judgment, it usually orders a new trial. You go back to the trial court and try the case again. In rare cases, the appellate court will enter judgment in your favor without a new trial, but this happens only when the error was so clear that a new trial would be pointless.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.