What a Personal Injury Arbitration Brief Looks Like and Why It Matters
A personal injury arbitration brief is a written argument you or your lawyer submits to an arbitrator—a private judge who will decide your case instead of a jury—laying out the facts, the law, and why you should win
Unlike a court trial, arbitration is a private process where both sides present their case to a single arbitrator (or sometimes a panel) who makes a binding decision. The arbitration brief is your chance to organize everything the arbitrator needs to rule in your favor: what happened, what injuries you suffered, what the law says about liability, and what compensation you deserve. It is typically 10 to 30 pages, submitted before a hearing or sometimes in place of one, depending on the arbitration rules you agreed to.
The brief matters because arbitrators read hundreds of pages of documents and hear hours of testimony. A well-organized brief cuts through the noise and tells a story the arbitrator can follow. A poorly written one—even if your case is strong—can bury your strongest arguments under clutter. This guide shows you what goes into a real arbitration brief, how it is structured, and what each section does.
Key Takeaways
- An arbitration brief is a formal written argument submitted to a private judge (arbitrator) before or during your case, presenting your version of the facts and the law supporting your claim.
- The brief typically includes a caption, statement of facts, legal argument, damages summary, and a prayer for relief, each serving a specific purpose in persuading the arbitrator.
- Arbitration briefs must follow the rules of the arbitration organization (such as JAMS or AAA) or the contract that sent you to arbitration, which set page limits, formatting, and important date.
- Unlike a court brief, an arbitration brief often emphasizes narrative and credibility because arbitrators are looking for a clear, believable story rather than technical legal perfection.
- If you are representing yourself, your brief should be plain and direct; if you have a lawyer, they typically draft and file it, but you should understand what it says about your case.
The Caption and Heading Section
The brief opens with a caption—a formal header that identifies the case, the parties, and the arbitration forum. This looks like a court caption but names the arbitrator or arbitration organization instead of a judge. For example: "In Arbitration Before [Arbitrator Name], JAMS" or "AAA Case No. [number]." Below that comes the title of the brief itself, such as "Claimant's Opening Brief" or "Respondent's Reply Brief."
The caption serves a practical purpose: it tells the arbitrator and the other side which case this brief belongs to and whose side you are on. It also establishes the formal tone. Even though arbitration is less formal than court, the brief still follows legal conventions because it is a legal document that may be referenced later if either side challenges the arbitrator's decision.
Statement of Facts and Background
This section tells what happened, in chronological order, from your perspective. It includes the date and location of the incident, who was involved, what the defendant did (or failed to do), and how you were injured. A personal injury brief might read: "On March 15, 2023, Claimant was a customer at Defendant's grocery store. Defendant's employee had left a wet floor without posting a warning sign. Claimant slipped on the wet floor and fell, fracturing her left wrist."
The facts section is not neutral—it is written to support your case. You choose which details to emphasize and how to frame them. You do not lie, but you present the facts in the light most favorable to you. You cite to evidence: "As shown in Exhibit A (the store's own incident report), the employee acknowledged the spill occurred at 2:00 p.m. and was not marked until 3:30 p.m." This grounds your narrative in documents and makes it harder for the arbitrator to dismiss.
A good facts section reads like a story. It answers: What was the defendant supposed to do? What did they actually do? What went wrong? What happened to you as a result? The arbitrator should finish this section understanding your version of events and why the defendant bears responsibility.
Legal Argument and Liability Section
Here you explain the law that applies to your case and why the facts you just described prove the defendant broke it. In a slip-and-fall case, you might argue negligence: the defendant owed you a duty of care, breached that duty by failing to warn of the hazard, and that breach caused your injury and damages.
This section cites statutes, case law, and the arbitration agreement itself. You explain what the law requires, then show how the defendant's conduct fell short. For example: "Under [State] law, a property owner must maintain premises in a reasonably safe condition and warn invitees of known hazards. The defendant knew or should have known of the spill for 90 minutes before posting a sign. This delay breached the duty of care." You then cite a case where a court found similar conduct negligent, showing the arbitrator that your legal theory is established law, not a stretch.
The legal argument is where your lawyer's informed shows most. If you are representing yourself, this section is harder to write well, but it is not impossible. You can research your state's law on your specific injury type (slip-and-fall, car accident, medical malpractice, etc.), find a few key cases, and explain how they explore to your facts. Many state bar associations publish plain-language guides to common legal standards.
Damages and Compensation Section
This section lists what you are asking for and why. It breaks damages into categories: medical expenses (past and future), lost wages, pain and suffering, and any other losses you claim. You provide numbers and evidence for each.
For medical expenses, you attach bills and receipts. For lost wages, you attach pay stubs and a letter from your employer confirming the time you missed. For pain and suffering—the hardest to quantify—you describe your injuries, recovery, and ongoing limitations. "Claimant underwent surgery on April 2, 2023, and was unable to work for eight weeks. She continues to experience pain and limited range of motion in her wrist, affecting her ability to perform her job as a graphic designer."
Arbitrators expect this section to be specific and supported by documents. Vague claims ("I suffered a lot") carry little weight. Detailed claims backed by evidence ("Medical records show three physical therapy sessions per week for 12 weeks, totaling $4,800 in co-pays") are persuasive. You are not asking for sympathy; you are asking the arbitrator to compensate you for real, documented losses.
Exhibits and Supporting Documents
The brief references exhibits—documents that prove your points. These are attached at the end and labeled Exhibit A, Exhibit B, and so on. Common exhibits in a personal injury brief include medical records, photographs of the injury or the scene, receipts and invoices, pay stubs, the defendant's own documents (like an incident report or email), and informed reports if you have them.
Each exhibit is cited in the brief by number and date. "As shown in Exhibit C (medical report dated April 5, 2023)..." This forces you to organize your evidence and makes it straightforward for the arbitrator to find what you are talking about. If an exhibit is long (like a 50-page medical file), you can highlight the relevant pages or include a summary page first.
The exhibits are often more persuasive than the brief itself. A photograph of a hazard, a medical report from a doctor, or an email from the defendant admitting fault speaks louder than your words. Spend time gathering and organizing exhibits before you write the brief.
Prayer for Relief and Conclusion
The brief ends with a formal request for what you want the arbitrator to do. This is called the "prayer for relief." It might read: "Claimant respectfully requests that the arbitrator find Defendant liable for negligence and award Claimant $85,000 in damages, consisting of $12,000 in medical expenses, $18,000 in lost wages, $50,000 for pain and suffering, and $5,000 in costs, plus pre-award and post-award interest as permitted by law."
This section is short and direct. It tells the arbitrator exactly what you want and in what amounts. It also leaves room for the arbitrator to award less if they find your damages claim too high—you are not asking for a yes-or-no decision, but for a specific remedy. Some briefs also include a brief conclusion restating the strongest points: "For the reasons above, Defendant's negligence caused Claimant's injury, and Claimant is may have access to to full compensation for her losses."
Formatting, Length, and Arbitration Rules
Arbitration briefs must follow the rules of the arbitration organization or the contract that sent you to arbitration. The American Arbitration Association (AAA) and JAMS (Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services) both publish rules that specify page limits (often 20 to 30 pages), font size (usually 12-point), margins, and important date dates. Some arbitration agreements allow longer briefs; others impose strict limits.
Check your arbitration agreement or the arbitrator's case management order for the specific rules. Missing a important date or exceeding a page limit can result in the arbitrator refusing to consider your brief, so these rules matter. If you need more space, you can request an extension in writing before the important date, explaining why. Some arbitrators grant extensions; others do not.
The brief should be formatted like a legal document: numbered paragraphs, clear headings, single or double spacing (check the rules), and a table of contents if it is longer than 15 pages. The tone is formal but not flowery. You are writing to persuade a professional decision-maker, not a jury, so avoid emotional language and stick to facts and law.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to write a brief if I am going to arbitration?
It depends on the arbitration rules and the arbitrator's case management order. Some arbitrations require written briefs; others allow the parties to present their case only at a hearing. Check your arbitration agreement and any orders from the arbitrator. Even if a brief is not required, submitting one is usually a good idea because it gives the arbitrator a written record of your arguments and evidence.
What if the other side's brief makes false claims about what happened?
You address this in your reply brief, which you submit after the other side files their opening brief. Your reply brief points out the inaccuracies, cites to evidence that contradicts their version, and explains why your version is more credible. You do not need to respond to every claim they make—focus on the ones that matter to liability or damages.
Can I represent myself and write my own arbitration brief?
Yes, but it is difficult. Arbitration briefs require knowledge of the law, evidence rules, and persuasive writing. If you are representing yourself, consider consulting a lawyer for a few hours to review your brief before you file it. Many lawyers offer limited-scope representation for this purpose and charge by the hour rather than taking the whole case. The cost is usually worth it to avoid mistakes that could cost you thousands in damages.
How long does it take to write an arbitration brief?
If you have a lawyer, they typically spend 10 to 20 hours drafting and revising, depending on the complexity of the case. If you are representing yourself, expect to spend 20 to 40 hours researching the law, organizing your evidence, and writing. Start early so you do not rush and miss the important date.
What happens after I submit my brief?
The other side has a set time (usually 14 to 21 days) to file their reply brief responding to your arguments. You may then have a chance to file a short surreply. After all briefs are filed, the arbitrator may schedule a hearing where both sides present oral arguments, or they may decide the case based on the briefs alone. The arbitrator will then issue a written decision explaining their ruling.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.