Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What a Personal Injury Defendant's Lawyer Does and Why You Need One

A defendant's lawyer protects you when someone sues you for causing their injury

When you're sued for personal injury—whether from a car crash, a slip on your property, or an accident at work—a defendant's lawyer represents your interests, not the injured person's. Their job is to defend you in court, negotiate with the other side's lawyers, and work toward the best outcome for you. That outcome might be winning the case, reducing what you owe, or reaching a settlement that costs less than going to trial.

You may think you don't need a lawyer if you have insurance. Your insurance company will assign a lawyer to defend you—but that lawyer works for the insurance company first, not for you. If your interests and the insurance company's interests ever conflict, you may want your own separate lawyer to protect yourself.

Key Takeaways

  • A defendant's lawyer defends you against a personal injury claim and works to reduce or eliminate what you owe.
  • Your insurance company's lawyer represents the insurance company's interests, which may not always match yours.
  • The defendant's lawyer handles discovery, depositions, settlement talks, and trial if the case goes that far.
  • You should hire your own lawyer if the claim exceeds your insurance limits, if you disagree with your insurer's strategy, or if the other side is asking for punitive damages.

What the defendant's lawyer actually does

Once you're sued, the defendant's lawyer takes over the legal work. They file responses to the lawsuit, gather evidence that supports your side of what happened, and respond to the other side's requests for documents and information—a process called discovery. They also prepare for and attend depositions, where the other side's lawyer questions you and witnesses under oath.

If the case doesn't settle, your lawyer prepares for trial: organizing evidence, preparing you to testify, and building arguments to present to a judge or jury. Throughout, they communicate with the other side's lawyer about whether a settlement is possible and at what amount.

The goal is not always to win outright. Many personal injury cases settle before trial because both sides want to avoid the cost and uncertainty of a jury decision. Your lawyer negotiates on your behalf to reach a settlement that protects you.

When you need your own lawyer separate from your insurance company's

Your insurance policy has a limit—the maximum amount the company will pay for a claim. If the injured person is suing for more than that limit, you face personal liability for anything above it. In that situation, your interests and your insurance company's interests diverge. The insurance company's lawyer may be willing to settle at your policy limit to close the case, but you want to fight harder to avoid paying out of pocket. You need your own lawyer to protect that personal exposure.

You should also hire your own lawyer if you disagree with your insurance company's strategy or if you believe the company is not defending you adequately. Some insurers settle cases quickly to save money, even when the claim is weak. If you think that's happening, your own lawyer can push back.

Finally, if the other side is asking for punitive damages—money meant to punish you rather than just compensate the injured person—your insurance may not cover those damages. Punitive damages are rare in personal injury cases but serious when they appear. Your own lawyer can focus on defending against them while the insurance company's lawyer focuses on the main claim.

How much a defendant's lawyer costs

If your insurance company is defending you, you pay nothing out of pocket—the insurance company pays the lawyer's fees. This is part of what your insurance premium covers.

If you hire your own lawyer separate from the insurance company's, costs vary widely. Some defendant's lawyers work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of any money you save (for example, if they negotiate the settlement down from $100,000 to $60,000, they might take 25% of that $40,000 savings). Others charge hourly rates, which can range from $150 to $400 per hour depending on the lawyer's experience and your location. A few charge a flat fee for specific tasks.

Before hiring, ask the lawyer how they charge and get a written agreement that spells out the fee structure. If you're paying hourly, ask for an estimate of total hours the case might take.

Finding and choosing a defendant's lawyer

Start by telling your insurance company that you want to hire your own lawyer. They should provide you with a list of approved defense counsel, or you can find a lawyer through your state bar association's referral service or through personal recommendations.

When you interview lawyers, ask about their experience defending cases like yours. A lawyer who has handled dozens of slip-and-fall cases will know the common defenses and what juries in your area typically award. Ask how they would approach your case and what they think the realistic outcomes are. Be wary of any lawyer who promises a specific result—no honest lawyer can may provide you'll win.

Make sure the lawyer is licensed in your state and has no disciplinary history. You can check this through your state bar association's website.

What happens if you lose or settle

If you lose at trial, the court orders you to pay the injured person a specific amount of money—called a judgment. Your insurance company pays up to your policy limit. Anything above that, you owe personally. Your lawyer can appeal the judgment if there were legal errors at trial, though appeals are expensive and uncertain.

If you settle, you and the injured person agree on an amount, and the case ends. Your insurance company typically pays the settlement amount (up to your policy limit), and the injured person signs a release promising not to sue you again over that injury. Settlements are final—you can't appeal or change your mind later.

In either case, the lawsuit ends and the injured person cannot pursue you further for that injury.

Questions to ask your lawyer early on

Before you hire a defendant's lawyer, or early in your work with one, ask these questions to understand what you're facing:

  • What is your experience with cases like mine, and what outcomes have you seen?
  • What do you think the injured person's strongest argument is, and how would you counter it?
  • What is your estimate of what this case might cost to defend, and how long might it take?
  • If we go to trial, what do you think a jury in this county would award for an injury like this?
  • Do you recommend we try to settle, and if so, at what range?

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to talk to the other side's lawyer?

No. Once you have a lawyer, all communication with the other side goes through your lawyer. If the other side's lawyer contacts you directly, tell them you have representation and refer them to your lawyer. Do not discuss the case with them or with anyone else except your own lawyer.

What if I can't afford a lawyer?

If your insurance company is defending you, you don't pay anything. If you need your own separate lawyer and cannot afford hourly rates, ask about contingency arrangements or whether the lawyer offers payment plans. Some lawyers will work on contingency if the case involves a significant amount of money.

Can my lawyer make me settle if I don't want to?

No. Your lawyer advises you, but you make the final decision about whether to settle or go to trial. If you and your lawyer strongly disagree on strategy, you can hire a different lawyer, though this may cost you time and money.

What if the injured person's lawyer keeps asking for documents I don't want to give?

Your lawyer reviews all document requests and can object to ones that are unreasonable or protected by attorney-client privilege. Your lawyer will tell you which documents you must provide and which you can withhold. Ignoring a valid request can result in court sanctions against you.

Will this case go to trial?

Most personal injury cases settle before trial—roughly 90 to 95 percent. Your lawyer will tell you early on whether your case looks like a settlement candidate or a trial case based on the strength of the evidence and the injured person's damages. Either way, your lawyer should prepare as if trial is coming.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.