Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Interrogatories Are and How to Answer Them in a New Jersey Personal Injury Case

Interrogatories are written questions the other side sends you before trial, and you must answer them under oath

Interrogatories are formal written questions that the defendant (or plaintiff, if you are the defendant) sends you as part of discovery—the phase where both sides exchange information before trial. In New Jersey personal injury cases, interrogatories are one of the most common discovery tools. You receive them, you answer them in writing, you sign them under oath, and you send them back within a set important date. The other side uses your answers to understand your case, find weaknesses, and prepare for trial or settlement talks.

If you are the plaintiff (the person suing), the defendant's lawyer will send you interrogatories asking about your injuries, your medical treatment, your lost income, how the accident happened, and what you are claiming in damages. You cannot ignore them or give vague answers. Failing to respond or lying under oath can result in sanctions—penalties imposed by the court—or even dismissal of your case.

Key Takeaways

  • Interrogatories are written questions you must answer in writing and sign under oath, usually within 35 days in New Jersey.
  • The defendant typically asks about your injuries, medical records, lost wages, and the circumstances of the accident.
  • Answers must be truthful and complete; vague or evasive responses can trigger court sanctions or hurt your credibility at trial.
  • You should work with your personal injury attorney to draft answers that are accurate but do not volunteer information beyond what is asked.
  • If you cannot answer a question, you must object in writing and explain why, rather than straightforward refusing to respond.

What the defendant typically asks in personal injury interrogatories

Interrogatories in a personal injury case follow predictable patterns. The defendant's lawyer wants to lock down your version of events and test whether your story is consistent. Common questions include: How did the accident occur? What were you doing when ready before the accident? Did you see the defendant or their vehicle before impact? What injuries did you suffer? What medical providers have you seen? What treatment have you received? How much time did you miss from work? What wages did you lose? Are you claiming any other damages?

The defendant also asks questions designed to find contradictions or weaknesses. For example: Have you posted anything on social media about your injuries? Have you engaged in any activities that contradict your claimed limitations? Have you received any settlement offers? Have you discussed your case with anyone other than your attorney? These questions are not meant to be friendly—they are meant to gather ammunition for trial or to pressure you into a lower settlement.

In New Jersey, interrogatories are limited to 30 questions unless the parties agree otherwise or the court permits more. This limit encourages the defendant to ask the most important questions, but it also means the questions tend to be broad and require detailed answers.

The timeline and format for responding in New Jersey

When you receive interrogatories, you have 35 days to respond under New Jersey's civil procedure rules. This important date can be extended if both sides agree in writing, or if the court grants an extension. Do not assume you have more time—mark the important date on your calendar when ready and give your attorney notice well before the due date.

Your answers must be typed, numbered to match the interrogatory numbers, and signed by you under oath. Each answer should be preceded by the full text of the question. At the end, you sign a certification stating that your answers are true and complete to the best of your knowledge. Your attorney typically prepares the answers, but you are the one swearing to their truth, so you must review them carefully and make sure they are accurate.

If you cannot answer a question because you do not know the answer or because the information is not in your possession, you must say so. If you object to a question—for example, because it asks for information protected by attorney-client privilege—you must state your objection in writing and explain the legal reason. straightforward refusing to answer without an objection can result in the court ordering you to answer or imposing sanctions.

How to work with your attorney on interrogatory answers

Your personal injury attorney should handle the drafting of interrogatory responses, but this is a collaborative process. Your lawyer will ask you detailed questions about your injuries, your medical history, your work, and the accident itself. Be thorough and honest in these conversations. Do not try to make your case sound better than it is—exaggeration or inconsistency will be caught and used against you.

A good attorney will draft answers that are truthful and complete but do not volunteer extra information. For example, if asked "What injuries did you suffer?" you should list the injuries you actually sustained, but you do not need to speculate about future injuries or add commentary. If asked "Have you missed work?" you should state the dates and amount, but you do not need to explain your employer's policies unless asked.

Review your attorney's draft carefully before signing. If an answer is inaccurate or incomplete, tell your attorney before the response is filed. Once you sign and submit interrogatory answers, they become part of the court record and can be used against you at trial if you contradict them. Changing your story later is far more damaging than getting it right the first time.

Common mistakes to avoid when answering interrogatories

The most common mistake is being evasive or incomplete. If you answer "I was injured" without specifying what injuries, the defendant will follow up with a more detailed question, and you will have wasted time. Answer fully the first time. Another mistake is contradicting yourself—if you tell your doctor you can walk a mile but tell the defendant you cannot walk more than a block, that contradiction will be highlighted at trial and will damage your credibility.

Do not lie or exaggerate. If you were not wearing a seatbelt, say so. If you were partially at fault, your attorney will address that in your defense, but lying about it will destroy your case. Do not answer questions you do not understand—ask your attorney to clarify. Do not assume you know what a question is asking if the wording is unclear; ask for clarification in writing before responding.

Another mistake is missing the important date. If you do not respond by the due date, the defendant can file a motion to compel, asking the court to force you to answer. If you still do not respond, the court can impose sanctions, dismiss your case, or enter a default judgment against you. There is no excuse that will save you if you straightforward ignore interrogatories.

What happens after you submit your answers

Once you submit your interrogatory answers, the defendant's attorney will review them and may follow up with additional discovery requests. They may ask for documents (requests for production), ask you to sit for a deposition (an in-person or video interview under oath), or send more interrogatories if they need clarification. Your answers to interrogatories will inform all of these next steps.

Your answers may also be used in settlement negotiations. If your answers show that your case is strong—clear liability, serious injuries, significant damages—the defendant may be more willing to settle. If your answers reveal weaknesses or inconsistencies, the defendant will use that to push for a lower settlement or to prepare a stronger defense for trial.

At trial, if you testify, the defendant's attorney can use your interrogatory answers to cross-examine you. If you said something different in your answers than you say on the stand, the attorney will confront you with the written answer and ask you to explain the contradiction. This is why accuracy and consistency are critical.

When to object to an interrogatory

You do not have to answer every interrogatory. New Jersey law allows you to object to questions that are overly broad, unduly burdensome, seek privileged information, or ask for things that are not relevant to the case. Common objections include: the question is vague or ambiguous; the question seeks information protected by attorney-client privilege or the work-product doctrine; the question is not relevant to the claims or defenses in the case; the question is overly broad or burdensome; or the question seeks information that is equally available to the other side.

If you object, you must state the objection clearly and explain the legal basis for it. You cannot straightforward refuse to answer without an objection. In some cases, you can object to part of a question and answer the rest. For example, if a question asks "Have you discussed your injuries with anyone, and if so, what did you tell them?" you might object to the second part (what you told them) if it involves conversations with your attorney, but answer the first part (yes, I discussed my injuries with my doctor).

Work with your attorney to decide which objections are appropriate. Objecting to too many questions can frustrate the court and make you look like you are hiding something. Objecting to too few can result in you having to answer questions that are not really relevant to your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I refuse to answer an interrogatory if I think it is unfair?

No. You must either answer the question truthfully or file a written objection explaining the legal reason you cannot answer. straightforward refusing to respond can result in the court ordering you to answer and imposing sanctions against you or your attorney. If you believe a question is unfair, your attorney can object on legal grounds, but you cannot just ignore it.

What if I do not remember the answer to a question?

Say so. You can answer "I do not recall" or "I do not have information regarding this matter." You are not required to guess or speculate. However, if the information is something you should reasonably know—like the date of your surgery or the name of your employer—saying you do not remember may hurt your credibility.

Can I talk to the defendant or their attorney before answering interrogatories?

No. You should not communicate directly with the other side about your case. All communication should go through your attorney. If the defendant's attorney contacts you directly, tell them to speak to your lawyer and do not answer any questions.

What if I realize my interrogatory answers were wrong after I submit them?

Tell your attorney when ready. You can file a supplemental response correcting the error, but the longer you wait, the worse it looks. If you discover the error during your deposition or at trial, you can explain it then, but it will damage your credibility. This is why reviewing your answers carefully before signing is so important.

Do interrogatory answers have to be notarized?

No. In New Jersey, you sign a certification under oath, but you do not need to have it notarized. Your attorney will include the certification language at the end of the responses, and you sign it. The certification is sufficient to make your answers sworn testimony.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.