What Happens When You Give a Deposition in a Personal Injury Case
A deposition is a recorded question-and-answer session where you testify under oath before trial
A deposition is a formal meeting where the other side's lawyer asks you questions about your injury, your medical treatment, your lost wages, and how the accident happened. You sit in a room with a court reporter who records everything you say. You swear or affirm to tell the truth, just as you would in court. The other side uses your deposition to understand your case, lock down your story before trial, and look for weaknesses in what you claim.
Your own lawyer will be present. The other side's lawyer will ask the questions. You are not in front of a judge or jury yet—this is a private discovery process, meaning both sides are gathering facts before the case goes to trial. What you say in a deposition can be used against you later if your trial testimony differs, or it can be read aloud in court if you cannot attend trial.
Depositions happen in most personal injury cases that do not settle early. They typically occur four to eight weeks before trial, though timing varies by court and how busy the lawyers are. You will receive a written notice telling you the date, time, and location at least two weeks in advance.
Key Takeaways
- A deposition is a sworn question-and-answer session with the other side's lawyer, recorded by a court reporter, and held before trial.
- Your lawyer attends and can object to unfair questions, but you must answer most questions truthfully and directly.
- Preparing with your lawyer beforehand—reviewing medical records, your accident account, and how to handle hostile questioning—reduces mistakes and strengthens your case.
- Answers given in a deposition become part of the court record and can be used to contradict you at trial or read to a jury if you cannot testify in person.
- The other side uses depositions to test your credibility, find inconsistencies, and pressure you into settling before trial.
Why the other side takes your deposition
The other side's lawyer has three main goals. First, they want to hear your version of events in detail and under oath, so they can compare it to what witnesses say and what physical evidence shows. If your story changes later, they can use the deposition to prove you are unreliable. Second, they want to assess how you will perform in front of a jury—whether you come across as honest and sympathetic, or evasive and exaggerated. Third, they want to find weaknesses: gaps in your memory, contradictions between what you claim and what medical records show, or admissions that help their case.
A deposition also serves a settlement purpose. If you perform poorly—if you seem confused, angry, or dishonest—the other side may believe they can win at trial and will offer less money to settle. If you perform well, they may decide a jury will side with you and offer more.
What to expect during the deposition
You will arrive at the lawyer's office or a neutral meeting space at the scheduled time. The court reporter will swear you in. The other side's lawyer will then ask questions, starting with background (your name, address, employment) and moving to the accident, your injuries, your medical treatment, and your damages (lost wages, pain, medical bills). Your lawyer sits nearby and can object if a question is improper, but objections do not stop you from answering—they just create a record that the question was asked unfairly.
The other side's lawyer may ask the same question multiple ways to see if your answer changes. They may ask about things that seem unrelated to your injury, to establish your credibility or find contradictions. They may ask you to describe pain or emotional harm in detail, which can feel invasive. The deposition usually lasts two to four hours, though complex cases can run longer. You are may have access to to breaks.
Everything is recorded by the court reporter, who produces a written transcript. Both lawyers receive a copy. If you later testify at trial and your trial testimony differs from what you said in the deposition, the other side will use the deposition transcript to show the inconsistency.
How to prepare with your lawyer
Meet with your lawyer at least one week before the deposition. Bring all documents related to your case: medical records, bills, pay stubs showing lost wages, photographs of your injuries or the accident scene, text messages or emails about the accident, and any written statements you gave to insurance companies. Review these documents with your lawyer so you are not surprised by questions about them.
Walk through your account of the accident step by step. Your lawyer will ask you the same questions the other side's lawyer likely will, so you can practice answering clearly and concisely. Discuss areas where your memory is fuzzy—do not guess or fill in details you are unsure of. It is better to say "I do not remember" than to guess and be contradicted later.
Ask your lawyer about the other side's theory of the case. What are they claiming happened? What do they say you did wrong or failed to do? Understanding their position helps you anticipate hostile questions. Your lawyer should also explain what topics are off-limits (attorney-client privilege, settlement discussions) and when you can refuse to answer.
Rules for answering questions
Answer only the question asked. Do not volunteer extra information or explain your answer unless the lawyer asks you to. If the other side's lawyer asks "Were you speeding?" and you were not, say "No"—do not add "I was going the speed limit and was being very careful." The extra words give the other side more material to work with.
If you do not understand a question, say so. Ask the lawyer to rephrase it. Do not guess at what they mean. If you do not remember something, say "I do not recall" or "I do not remember." Do not say "I think" or "I believe" unless you actually have some memory of the event. If a question calls for a yes-or-no answer but the truth is more complicated, you can ask permission to explain, but keep the explanation brief.
Never lie or guess. A lie under oath is perjury, a crime that can result in criminal charges. If you guess and are later contradicted by medical records or other evidence, you lose credibility with a jury. Pause before answering if you need time to think. It is not a race.
What happens if you do poorly or the other side is aggressive
If you lose your temper, cry, or appear evasive, the other side will use that performance to argue you are not credible or that your injuries are not as serious as you claim. Your lawyer can object to aggressive or harassing questions, and can ask for a break if you need one. If the other side's lawyer is truly abusive—asking questions designed to humiliate rather than gather facts—your lawyer can end the deposition and file a motion with the court to limit the other side's conduct.
If you make a mistake or say something you regret, tell your lawyer when ready after the deposition. Your lawyer can sometimes file a correction with the court, or can prepare you to address the mistake at trial. Do not try to hide it or hope the other side did not notice—they will notice, and hiding it makes things worse.
A poor deposition does not end your case. It may weaken your negotiating position and make settlement harder, but it does not prevent you from going to trial. Your lawyer can work with you to explain any inconsistencies or poor performance when you testify at trial.
How deposition testimony is used later
If your case settles before trial, the deposition transcript becomes part of the settlement file but is usually not public. If your case goes to trial, the other side can use your deposition testimony in several ways. If you testify at trial and your testimony differs from your deposition, the other side will read the deposition transcript aloud to the jury to show you changed your story. If you cannot attend trial (illness, death, or other reason), the other side can ask the court to allow them to read your deposition testimony to the jury instead of having you testify in person.
Your own lawyer can also use your deposition testimony at trial—for example, to refresh your memory if you forget something, or to support a point you made consistently in both the deposition and at trial.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I bring documents or notes to the deposition?
You can bring documents that relate to your case—medical records, bills, photos—and review them during the deposition if a question asks about them. You should not bring a written script or detailed notes to read from, as that can make you appear unprepared or dishonest. Discuss with your lawyer beforehand what documents to bring.
What if I do not know the answer to a question?
Say "I do not know" or "I do not recall." Do not guess, make up an answer, or say "I think" unless you actually have some memory. The other side will often ask follow-up questions to test whether you really do not remember or are avoiding the question, so be consistent.
Can my lawyer tell me what to say?
Your lawyer can prepare you by explaining what to expect and how to answer clearly, but cannot tell you what facts to state or coach you to lie. Your testimony must be truthful. Your lawyer can object to improper questions during the deposition, but cannot prevent you from answering most questions.
What if the other side's lawyer is rude or asks inappropriate questions?
Your lawyer can object and ask for a break. If the behavior is truly abusive, your lawyer can end the deposition and file a motion with the court. You do not have to tolerate harassment, but staying calm and professional is usually the best strategy—juries notice if you lose your temper, and it can hurt your case.
Will my deposition be public?
Depositions are not automatically public. They are part of the discovery process, which is usually confidential. If your case goes to trial, parts of your deposition may be read in open court, which is public. If your case settles, the deposition typically remains private unless the settlement agreement says otherwise.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.