What Happens After a Personal Injury Verdict
What a personal injury verdict actually is
A verdict is a decision by a jury (or sometimes a judge, if there is no jury) about who caused the injury and how much money the injured person should receive. It is the formal end of a trial. The verdict answers two separate questions: liability (did the defendant cause the harm?) and damages (how much is that harm worth in dollars?).
A verdict is not the same as a settlement. A settlement is an agreement both sides reach before trial. A verdict is what happens when the case goes to trial and a jury or judge decides. Once a verdict is entered, the case moves into a different phase — collecting the money, handling appeals, and dealing with liens or other claims against the award.
Key Takeaways
- A verdict is a jury or judge's decision on liability and the dollar amount owed, but it does not automatically put money in your account.
- The defendant has the right to appeal a verdict, which can delay payment by months or years and may result in a new trial or reduced award.
- Medical providers, insurers, and government programs may have legal claims against your award to recover costs they paid on your behalf.
- Collection can be straightforward if the defendant has insurance or assets, but difficult or impossible if they do not.
- A personal injury attorney typically takes a percentage of the final award (usually 25 to 40 percent) and handles collection and lien negotiations.
The difference between a verdict and actually receiving money
Winning a verdict does not mean the money arrives. The court has issued a judgment — a legal order saying the defendant owes you a specific amount — but the defendant must then pay it. If the defendant has liability insurance, the insurance company usually pays up to the policy limit. If they do not have insurance or the judgment exceeds the policy, collection becomes much harder.
The defendant can also post a bond and appeal the verdict, which freezes collection while the appeal is pending. Appeals can take one to three years or longer. During that time, you do not receive the money, and the defendant may argue the verdict was wrong, the damages were too high, or the trial had legal errors that require a new trial.
Even after an appeal is decided, if the defendant has no insurance and no significant assets, the judgment may be uncollectible. You would hold a legal judgment, but collecting it could require wage garnishment, bank levies, or other enforcement steps that are slow and may yield little.
Appeals and what they mean for your award
Either side can appeal a verdict. The defendant appeals far more often than plaintiffs do. An appeal does not retry the case or let a jury hear new evidence. Instead, an appellate court reviews whether the trial judge made legal errors that affected the outcome. Common grounds include improper jury instructions, admission of evidence that should have been excluded, or a verdict that no reasonable jury could reach based on the evidence presented.
If an appeal is filed, the judgment is not automatically stayed (paused), but the defendant can request a stay pending appeal. If granted, you do not receive payment while the appeal is pending. The appellate process typically takes 12 to 36 months. The appellate court may affirm the verdict (uphold it), reverse it (overturn it), or remand it (send it back for a new trial on some issues).
A reversal or remand can mean starting over, negotiating a settlement, or facing a second trial. This is why many defendants appeal verdicts in their favor as well — to reduce the award or eliminate it entirely. Your attorney should explain the strength of the defendant's appeal and whether settlement negotiations might be worth considering while the appeal is pending.
Liens, subrogation, and claims against your award
When you receive a personal injury award, other parties may have legal claims against it. A lien is a legal hold placed on your money by someone who paid medical bills or other costs on your behalf. Common lienholders include health insurance companies, Medicaid, Medicare, and hospital systems. They are may have access to to recover what they paid from your award before you keep the remainder.
Subrogation is similar but applies to your health insurance or auto insurance. If your health insurance paid your medical bills, they may have a subrogation right to recover that amount from your personal injury award. The same applies if your auto insurance paid for repairs or medical payments coverage.
Your attorney should identify all potential liens and negotiate reductions where possible. Medicare and Medicaid liens are often negotiable, and hospitals may settle for less than the full amount owed. If liens are not handled before you receive the award, you could end up owing money to multiple parties and receiving less than expected. This is one reason why having an attorney handle the post-verdict process is important — they know how to identify liens, negotiate them down, and may support you understand what you will actually receive after all claims are paid.
How much of the verdict you actually keep
If you hired a personal injury attorney on a contingency fee basis (meaning they only get paid if you win), they typically receive 25 to 40 percent of the final award. The exact percentage depends on the fee agreement you signed and whether the case settled before trial or went to verdict. Cases that go to trial often have higher percentages because they require more work and carry more risk for the attorney.
In addition to the attorney's fee, you will pay court costs, informed witness fees, medical record retrieval, and other expenses. These are usually deducted from the award as well. Some attorneys advance these costs and deduct them from the final award; others require you to pay them upfront. Your fee agreement should specify how costs are handled.
After the attorney's fee and costs are deducted, liens are paid, and any taxes owed are handled, the remainder goes to you. On a $100,000 verdict with a 33 percent attorney fee, $15,000 in costs, and $20,000 in liens, you would receive approximately $45,000. Understanding this math before trial helps you set realistic expectations about what the award will actually mean for your finances.
Collection when the defendant has no insurance
If the defendant has no liability insurance and no significant assets, a verdict can be nearly worthless. You hold a judgment, but collecting it requires enforcement steps that are slow, expensive, and often unsuccessful. Common collection methods include wage garnishment (taking a portion of the defendant's paycheck), bank levies (seizing money from their bank account), and property liens (placing a claim on real estate they own).
Wage garnishment typically yields 10 to 25 percent of disposable income, depending on state law, and only works if the defendant is employed. If they are self-employed, unemployed, or move frequently, garnishment is ineffective. Bank levies work only if you know which bank they use and they have money in the account at the time of the levy. Property liens are useful only if the defendant owns real estate, and even then, you may have to wait years for them to sell the property before you collect.
Before trial, your attorney should investigate the defendant's insurance and assets. If they have neither, the case may not be worth pursuing, or you may need to discuss a realistic settlement that accounts for collection risk. After a verdict, if collection appears difficult, your attorney can refer you to a judgment collection specialist, but there is no may provide they will recover anything.
When to settle instead of going to verdict
Many cases settle before or during trial, even after a verdict seems likely. Settlement offers may come from the defendant's insurance company or the defendant themselves. The advantage of settlement is certainty — you know exactly what you will receive and when. The disadvantage is that you receive less than you might win at trial.
After a verdict is entered, settlement becomes more complicated. If the defendant appeals, they may offer to settle the appeal for a reduced amount rather than risk the appellate court affirming the full verdict. These post-verdict settlements can be attractive if the appeal is weak or if you want to avoid years of waiting. Your attorney should explain the likelihood of the appeal succeeding and whether a settlement offer is reasonable given that likelihood.
The decision to accept a post-verdict settlement depends on your financial situation, the strength of the appeal, and how much certainty matters to you. If you need the money now and the appeal is risky, a settlement may make sense. If you can wait and the appeal is weak, holding out for the full verdict may be better.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to receive money after a verdict?
If there is no appeal and the defendant has insurance, payment typically arrives within 30 to 90 days. If the defendant appeals, payment is delayed until the appeal is resolved, which can take one to three years or longer. If collection is difficult, payment may take months or years of enforcement steps.
Can the defendant appeal a verdict in their favor?
Yes. Either side can appeal. A defendant who wins at trial can appeal if they believe the verdict should have been in their favor or if they want to reduce the damages awarded. An appeal does not retry the case; it reviews whether legal errors occurred during trial.
What happens if I cannot collect the judgment?
You hold a valid judgment, but if the defendant has no income or assets, collection may be impossible. Wage garnishment, bank levies, and property liens are available tools, but they work only if the defendant has money or property to seize. Some judgments remain uncollected indefinitely.
Do I have to pay taxes on a personal injury verdict?
Personal injury awards for physical injury or sickness are generally not taxable under federal law. However, awards for lost wages, punitive damages, or emotional distress may be taxable. Consult a tax professional about your specific verdict to understand any tax obligations.
What if the defendant files bankruptcy after a verdict?
Personal injury judgments can be affected by bankruptcy. Some debts are discharged (eliminated) in bankruptcy, but personal injury claims have different treatment depending on the type of bankruptcy and the nature of the injury. Your attorney should advise you on how bankruptcy affects your judgment and what steps to take.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.