What Happens During Jury Selection in a Personal Injury Case
Jury selection in a personal injury case is called voir dire, a process where lawyers for both sides question potential jurors to find out whether they can be fair to their client.
The judge, the plaintiff's lawyer, and the defendant's lawyer all participate. Each side gets to remove a certain number of jurors without giving a reason (called peremptory challenges) and can remove unlimited jurors for cause — meaning the juror has admitted bias or a conflict that makes them unable to be impartial. The goal is to seat 12 jurors (or 6 in some cases) who will listen to the evidence without prejudging the outcome.
Voir dire happens before the trial itself begins. It can take anywhere from a few hours to several days depending on the complexity of the case and how many potential jurors are in the pool. Understanding what happens during this phase helps you know what to expect if your case goes to trial, and it gives you a sense of how your lawyer is preparing your case for a jury.
Key Takeaways
- Voir dire is the formal questioning of potential jurors to determine whether they can be fair and impartial in your case.
- Both the plaintiff's lawyer and the defendant's lawyer ask questions and can remove jurors they believe cannot be fair.
- Lawyers use peremptory challenges to remove jurors without stating a reason, though they cannot remove jurors based solely on race, gender, or other protected characteristics.
- The judge oversees the process and can remove jurors for cause if they admit bias, have a conflict of interest, or cannot follow the law.
- Your lawyer's strategy during voir dire focuses on finding jurors who are open to hearing your side of the story and understanding the type of damages you are seeking.
How the Jury Pool Is Selected and Summoned
Before voir dire begins, the court draws potential jurors from a list of registered voters, driver's license holders, or both, depending on your state. These people receive a summons in the mail telling them to appear on a specific date. Some ignore it; others request to be excused for hardship. The court staff screens out people with legitimate reasons not to serve — severe illness, caregiving responsibilities, or financial hardship that would cause real suffering.
The remaining pool, called the venire, shows up on the day of trial. This is typically 20 to 100 people, depending on the case size and court. They fill out a written questionnaire asking about their background, work, prior jury service, and sometimes specific questions about the case topic — for example, whether they have personal experience with the type of injury at issue, or whether they have strong feelings about personal injury lawsuits in general.
Your lawyer and the defendant's lawyer receive copies of these questionnaires before voir dire begins. This gives them a head start in identifying jurors who might favor one side or the other based on what they have already disclosed.
What Lawyers Ask During Voir Dire
The plaintiff's lawyer (your lawyer) typically goes first and asks questions designed to find jurors who can understand your perspective and are willing to award damages if the evidence supports it. Questions might include: Have you or a family member been injured in a similar way? Do you have any bias against people who bring personal injury lawsuits? Would you have difficulty awarding money for pain and suffering, or do you believe only medical bills should be covered?
The defendant's lawyer asks different questions, looking for jurors who are skeptical of injury claims, who believe people often exaggerate their injuries, or who have a general distrust of lawsuits. They might ask: Do you think most personal injury claims are frivolous? Would you need very strong evidence to believe someone's injury is as serious as they claim? Do you know anyone who has been sued, and did that affect your view of defendants?
The judge also asks questions, usually about jurors' ability to follow the law, whether they can set aside personal feelings, and whether they have any hardship that would prevent them from serving for the length of the trial. Judges tend to ask more neutral, procedural questions rather than case-specific ones, though this varies by judge and jurisdiction.
Peremptory Challenges and Removal for Cause
After questioning, each side can remove jurors in two ways. A challenge for cause means the lawyer argues to the judge that a juror cannot be fair — for example, the juror admitted they already believe the plaintiff is lying, or they are related to the defendant, or they work for the defendant's insurance company. The judge decides whether the reason is valid. There is no limit to how many jurors can be removed for cause.
A peremptory challenge lets each side remove a juror without explaining why, up to a set number — typically three to five per side in a standard personal injury case, though this varies by state and court. The catch: a lawyer cannot use peremptory challenges to remove jurors based on race, gender, national origin, or other protected characteristics. If the other side objects and argues that a pattern of removals looks discriminatory, the judge can require the lawyer to explain their reason, and if the explanation seems pretextual, the judge can overrule the challenge.
Your lawyer's strategy during this phase is to remove jurors who seem hostile to injury claims or who have admitted bias, while keeping jurors who seem open-minded and sympathetic to your situation. The defendant's lawyer does the opposite.
How Juror Bias and Conflicts Are Identified
Bias can be obvious or subtle. Obvious bias includes a juror saying they think all personal injury lawsuits are scams, or that they have a financial interest in the defendant winning. Subtle bias might be a juror who had a bad experience with a similar injury and recovered quickly, leading them to doubt that yours is as serious, or a juror who works in insurance and may unconsciously favor the defendant's interests.
Conflicts of interest include any relationship to the parties, lawyers, or judge; employment by the defendant or their insurance company; or a financial stake in the outcome. A juror might also have a conflict if they are friends with someone who was injured in a similar way and received a large settlement, which could bias them in either direction.
Your lawyer listens carefully during voir dire for hints of these biases and conflicts. Sometimes a juror will volunteer the information; sometimes your lawyer has to ask follow-up questions to draw it out. The goal is to identify problems before the juror is seated, because once they are sworn in, removing them becomes much harder.
What Happens After Jury Selection Is Complete
Once both sides have used their challenges and the judge has removed jurors for cause, the remaining jurors are sworn in. They take an oath to listen to the evidence fairly, follow the judge's instructions on the law, and base their verdict only on what they hear in court. At this point, jury selection is over and the trial begins with opening statements.
Your lawyer's work during voir dire does not end when the jury is seated, though. The jurors' answers during questioning give your lawyer insight into how they think and what arguments might resonate with them. This information shapes how your lawyer presents evidence, which witnesses to call, and how to frame your damages claim during trial.
If the case does not settle before trial, you will likely be present during jury selection. You may be asked to sit at the counsel table so jurors can see you, and your lawyer might ask your opinion on certain jurors, though the lawyer makes the final decisions on challenges.
Differences in Voir Dire Across States and Courts
Voir dire procedures vary significantly. Some judges conduct most of the questioning themselves and give lawyers limited time to ask follow-up questions. Others let lawyers do most of the questioning with minimal judge involvement. Some courts use written questionnaires extensively; others rely mainly on oral questioning in the courtroom.
The number of peremptory challenges also differs. A few states allow more challenges in personal injury cases than in criminal cases; others use the same number across all civil cases. Some jurisdictions have moved toward limiting peremptory challenges or eliminating them entirely, though this is still uncommon.
Your lawyer will know the specific rules for your court and will explain them to you before trial. If you are unsure about how jury selection will work in your case, ask your lawyer to walk you through the process and explain what to expect.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be removed from the jury if I know the plaintiff or defendant?
Yes. If you have a personal or professional relationship with either party, you should disclose it during voir dire. The judge will likely remove you for cause because you cannot be impartial. Even a casual acquaintance can be grounds for removal if it creates a reasonable question about fairness.
What if a juror lies during voir dire and gets seated anyway?
If a juror's dishonesty is discovered after the verdict, it may be grounds for a new trial, but this is difficult to prove and rarely succeeds. This is why lawyers ask detailed questions and sometimes hire jury consultants to help spot inconsistencies or evasiveness during questioning.
Can my lawyer ask jurors about their income or financial situation?
Yes, if it is relevant to the case. For example, in a case involving a large damage award, a lawyer might ask whether a juror's financial situation could make them uncomfortable awarding that amount of money. However, the judge can limit questions that seem designed to discriminate or that are overly invasive.
How long does jury selection usually take?
In a straightforward personal injury case, voir dire might take half a day to a full day. In complex cases or cases with significant media attention, it can take several days. Your lawyer can give you a better estimate based on the specifics of your case and your court's typical pace.
Will I have to testify during jury selection?
No. Jury selection is for questioning potential jurors, not parties or witnesses. You will sit at the counsel table and may be introduced to the jury, but you will not answer questions under oath until the trial itself begins, if you testify at all.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.