How UIM Arbitration Works When Your Insurer Won't Pay What You're Owed
What UIM arbitration is and why you might need it
UIM arbitration is a process where you and your own insurance company ask a neutral third party to decide how much your underinsured motorist coverage should pay you. It happens when the at-fault driver's insurance won't cover your full damages — either because their policy limit is too low or because liability is disputed — and you and your insurer disagree on what your own UIM policy owes.
In Queens, this matters because many drivers carry minimum liability limits ($25,000 per person in New York), which often falls short when injuries are serious. If you've been hit by someone underinsured and your own policy includes UIM coverage, arbitration is the formal way to resolve the gap between what you're owed and what the other driver's insurance will pay.
You don't go to court for UIM arbitration. Instead, you and your insurer each present your case to an arbitrator — usually a retired judge or experienced attorney — who decides the amount. This process is faster and less formal than litigation, but it still requires clear documentation of your damages.
Key Takeaways
- UIM arbitration happens between you and your own insurance company when the at-fault driver's coverage is insufficient and you disagree on what you're owed.
- You must exhaust the at-fault driver's policy limits first; arbitration only covers the gap between those limits and your actual damages.
- Either party can demand arbitration in writing, and New York law requires insurers to respond within a set timeframe.
- An arbitrator (not a judge or jury) hears both sides and issues a binding decision on the UIM amount owed.
- Having medical records, repair estimates, lost wage documentation, and a clear damages calculation strengthens your position before arbitration begins.
When you can demand UIM arbitration in Queens
You can demand arbitration once you've settled or received a judgment against the at-fault driver's insurance for their policy limit. New York law does not allow you to pursue your own UIM coverage until the other driver's coverage is exhausted. This is called the exhaustion requirement.
The process typically looks like this: the at-fault driver's insurer pays you their policy limit (say, $25,000), you sign a release for that amount, and then you can turn to your own UIM coverage for the remainder. If you and your insurer disagree on how much more you're may have access to to, either side can demand arbitration by sending a written notice.
In Queens, the demand must be in writing and must include a statement that you and your insurer cannot agree on the UIM amount. Your insurer then has a set period to respond. If they refuse arbitration without good cause, a court can order them to proceed.
How the arbitration process actually works
Once arbitration is demanded, you and your insurer each select an arbitrator, or you agree on a single arbitrator. The arbitrator sets a hearing date — usually within 60 to 90 days, though this varies. You'll exchange documents beforehand: medical records, bills, wage loss statements, repair estimates, and your calculation of total damages.
At the hearing, you present your case first, usually with your attorney. You explain your injuries, show medical evidence, present bills and lost wages, and explain why your damages exceed the at-fault driver's policy limit. Your insurer then presents their case, often arguing that your damages are lower or that some expenses are not covered under the policy.
The arbitrator listens to both sides, reviews the documents, and then issues a written decision. This decision is binding — meaning both you and your insurer must accept it. You cannot appeal an arbitration decision to a court unless there is fraud or the arbitrator acted outside their authority, which is rare.
What damages can be included in UIM arbitration
UIM arbitration covers the same categories of damages as a personal injury claim: medical expenses (past and future), lost wages, pain and suffering, and permanent injury or disfigurement. However, your insurer will only pay the difference between what the at-fault driver's insurance already paid and your total documented damages.
For example, if the at-fault driver's policy paid $25,000 and your total damages are $60,000, the arbitrator can award up to $35,000 from your UIM coverage (assuming your policy limit allows it). If your policy limit is only $50,000 total, the maximum you can recover is $50,000 combined from both sources.
Medical bills must be documented with invoices or statements. Lost wages require pay stubs and a letter from your employer confirming the time you missed. Pain and suffering is harder to quantify, but the arbitrator considers the severity of injury, length of recovery, and impact on daily life. Future medical costs require a medical opinion about ongoing treatment needs.
How to prepare your case before arbitration
Start by gathering everything: all medical records from every provider who treated you, all bills and invoices, pay stubs showing lost income, repair estimates or invoices for vehicle damage, photographs of injuries and vehicle damage, and any documentation of how the injury affected your life (missed events, inability to work, ongoing limitations).
Create a clear damages summary that lists each category and the amount. Medical expenses go first, then lost wages, then other out-of-pocket costs. For pain and suffering, research similar cases in Queens to understand what arbitrators typically award for injuries like yours. Your attorney can help with this comparison.
Write a narrative explaining the accident, your injuries, and your recovery. Be honest about what you can and cannot do now. If you've fully recovered, say so. If you have permanent limitations, describe them. Arbitrators respond to clear, factual presentations more than emotional appeals.
What happens if you and your insurer still disagree after arbitration
Once the arbitrator issues a decision, it is final. You cannot ask for a new hearing or appeal to a higher authority unless you can prove the arbitrator was corrupt, biased, or made a decision that is completely irrational. Courts rarely overturn arbitration decisions on these grounds.
If your insurer refuses to pay the arbitration award, you can file a lawsuit to enforce it. This is usually quick because the arbitrator has already decided the amount; the court straightforward orders payment. Your attorney can also seek interest and attorney fees if your policy allows it.
If the arbitration award is lower than you expected, you cannot appeal it. This is the trade-off of arbitration: it is faster and less formal than court, but the decision is final. This is why preparation and presentation matter — you get one chance to make your case.
When to hire an attorney for UIM arbitration in Queens
You can represent yourself in UIM arbitration, but most people do not. An attorney knows how arbitrators in Queens typically value different types of injuries, what documentation carries the most weight, and how to present your case persuasively. They also handle the procedural requirements — the written demand, the exchange of documents, and the hearing itself.
An attorney can also negotiate with your insurer before arbitration. Sometimes, seeing that you are prepared and serious about the process prompts the insurer to offer a settlement that avoids the hearing altogether. If settlement is not possible, your attorney presents the case at arbitration.
Many personal injury attorneys in Queens work on contingency for UIM arbitration, meaning they take a percentage of what you recover rather than charging an hourly fee. This aligns their incentive with yours: they only make money if you win. Ask about this arrangement when you first speak with an attorney.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I go to court instead of arbitration for UIM?
In New York, you can demand a trial instead of arbitration if your insurer refuses to settle, but arbitration is faster and less expensive. Most UIM disputes are resolved through arbitration because both sides prefer to avoid the cost and delay of court. If arbitration does not work, you can then pursue litigation.
What if the at-fault driver's insurance is still fighting liability?
You cannot use UIM arbitration until the at-fault driver's liability is resolved. If liability is disputed, you may need to settle that claim first, go to trial, or reach a judgment. Only after that is settled can you move to UIM arbitration for the gap between what they paid and your full damages.
Does my UIM policy limit have to be higher than the at-fault driver's limit?
No. You can have UIM coverage equal to or lower than the at-fault driver's limit. If your UIM limit is lower, that becomes your maximum recovery. For example, if the at-fault driver's limit is $25,000 and your UIM limit is $15,000, you can recover a maximum of $40,000 total.
How long does UIM arbitration usually take in Queens?
From the written demand to the arbitrator's decision typically takes three to six months, depending on how quickly both sides exchange documents and how busy the arbitrator is. This is much faster than a court trial, which can take one to two years or longer.
What if I disagree with the arbitrator's decision?
Arbitration decisions are final and binding. You cannot appeal based on disagreement with the amount. You can only challenge the decision if you can prove fraud, corruption, or that the arbitrator acted completely outside their authority — a very high bar that rarely succeeds.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.