What Happens When You Lose a Personal Injury Lawsuit
You Pay Your Own Legal Costs and the Other Side's Costs May Be Your Responsibility
If you lose a personal injury lawsuit, you are responsible for paying your own attorney's fees unless you had a contingency fee agreement — a contract where your lawyer only gets paid if you win. If you did have a contingency agreement, you owe your attorney nothing. If you paid hourly or had a flat fee, you owe that bill regardless of the outcome.
The other side — usually the defendant or their insurance company — may ask the court to order you to pay their legal costs. This is called a judgment for costs, and it is separate from the damages they might have won. Costs typically include court filing fees, service of process fees, and informed witness fees, though the exact list varies by state and by what the judge allows.
You will not automatically owe the defendant's attorney fees just because you lost. Most states follow the "American Rule," which means each side pays its own lawyer unless a statute or contract says otherwise. However, some states allow attorney fees as costs in specific situations — for example, if the judge finds your case was frivolous or brought in bad faith.
Key Takeaways
- If you had a contingency fee agreement with your lawyer, you owe them nothing when you lose; if you paid hourly or a flat fee, you still owe that bill.
- The defendant can ask the court to order you to pay their court costs (filing fees, informed witnesses, service fees), though attorney fees are usually not included unless state law or your contract says otherwise.
- A judgment for costs becomes a debt you must pay, and the defendant can pursue collection if you do not pay voluntarily.
- Some states allow sanctions or attorney fees against a plaintiff whose case was frivolous, but this is not automatic and requires the judge to make a specific finding.
- If you cannot pay a judgment, you may be able to request a payment plan or ask the court to reduce the amount, depending on your state and financial situation.
How Court Costs Are Calculated and Ordered
When you lose, the defendant's attorney will usually file a motion for costs or include a costs request in their post-trial paperwork. They list every expense they incurred that the court rules are recoverable — court filing fees, fees paid to serve you with the lawsuit, deposition transcripts, informed witness fees, and sometimes travel costs to attend trial.
The judge reviews the list and decides which costs are reasonable and directly tied to the case. A judge will not award costs that seem excessive or unrelated to defending against your claim. For example, if the defendant hired three informed witnesses but only two testified, the judge might disallow the third one's fee.
Once the judge approves the costs, they enter a judgment for costs — a court order saying you owe a specific dollar amount. This judgment is enforceable like any other debt. The defendant can use it to garnish your wages, place a lien on your property, or pursue other collection methods allowed in your state.
The Difference Between Costs and Attorney Fees
Costs are the expenses the court system charges or the defendant paid to third parties — the clerk's office, process servers, court reporters, and informed witnesses. Attorney fees are what you pay your own lawyer or what the defendant paid theirs for their time and work on the case.
In most states, you will not owe the defendant's attorney fees just because you lost. The defendant has to show that a specific law or contract allows it. For example, some loan agreements or business contracts include a clause saying the losing party pays the winner's attorney fees. Some statutes — particularly in consumer protection or civil rights cases — allow attorney fees to the prevailing party.
If the judge finds your case was frivolous, malicious, or brought solely to harass the defendant, they may order you to pay the defendant's attorney fees as a sanction. This is rare and requires the judge to make a deliberate finding that your case had no legal or factual basis and was brought in bad faith.
What Happens to Your Own Legal Bill
If you hired an attorney on a contingency fee basis, you owe nothing. Your lawyer took the risk that you might lose and agreed to work for free if that happened. This is the most common arrangement in personal injury cases because most people cannot afford to pay a lawyer upfront.
If you paid your attorney hourly or with a flat fee, you still owe that bill. The fact that you lost does not erase your debt to your own lawyer. If you have not paid in full, your attorney may send you a final bill, place the debt with a collection agency, or sue you for the unpaid balance.
Some attorneys will negotiate a reduced final bill if the case did not go as planned, but they are not required to. If you cannot pay, ask your attorney whether they will accept a payment plan. Many will work with clients on this rather than pursue collection.
Judgments and Collection After You Lose
A judgment for costs is a court order that creates a legal debt. The defendant can use it when ready to try to collect. The most common collection methods are wage garnishment (the defendant asks the court to order your employer to send part of your paycheck to them) and property liens (the defendant records a claim against your house or other assets).
In some states, the defendant can also pursue a debtor's examination, where they ask the court to order you to appear and answer questions about your income, assets, and bank accounts. This helps them figure out where to collect from.
If you cannot pay the judgment, you have limited options. You can ask the court for a stay of execution, which pauses collection temporarily while you arrange payment. You can request a payment plan. In rare cases, if you are judgment-proof — meaning you have no income or assets the court can reach — the judgment sits unpaid, but it remains on your record and can be renewed in many states.
When You Might Owe More Than Costs
In most personal injury cases, the only money you owe after losing is your own attorney fees (if you did not have a contingency agreement) and the defendant's court costs. However, some situations expose you to larger liability.
If the defendant counterclaimed against you — meaning they sued you back for something — and they won their counterclaim, you owe damages on that claim. For example, if you sued for a car accident injury and the defendant counterclaimed that you damaged their vehicle, you could owe repair costs if the judge found you at fault.
If your state allows sanctions for frivolous lawsuits, the judge can order you to pay the defendant's attorney fees and additional penalties. This requires a specific finding that your case had no reasonable basis in law or fact and was brought to harass or delay.
Options If You Cannot Pay the Judgment
If the court enters a judgment for costs and you cannot pay it, contact the defendant's attorney or the court clerk to discuss your situation. Some courts allow you to file a motion to reduce or waive costs based on financial hardship, though success depends on your state and the judge.
You can request a payment plan. Many defendants will accept monthly payments rather than pursue expensive collection. Put any agreement in writing so both sides know the terms.
If you believe the costs awarded were unreasonable or the judge made an error, you may be able to file a motion to reconsider or appeal the costs portion of the judgment. This is a separate issue from appealing the underlying loss. Consult with an attorney about whether this makes sense in your case.
In some states, certain assets are protected from judgment collection — for example, your primary residence up to a certain amount, your car up to a certain value, and retirement accounts. The defendant cannot touch these even if they have a judgment. The specifics vary widely by state.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to pay my lawyer if I lose on a contingency fee?
No. A contingency fee agreement means your lawyer only gets paid if you win. If you lose, you owe them nothing. If you paid hourly or a flat fee, you still owe that bill regardless of the outcome.
Can the defendant make me pay their lawyer's fees?
Not automatically. Most states do not allow attorney fees to the winner unless a law or contract specifically says so. The defendant can recover court costs (filing fees, informed witnesses, service fees), but attorney fees are different. If your case was frivolous or brought in bad faith, the judge may order you to pay their fees as a sanction, but this is rare.
What if I cannot pay the judgment for costs?
Contact the defendant's attorney to discuss a payment plan. You can also ask the court for a stay of execution to pause collection temporarily, or file a motion for hardship relief if your state allows it. Some assets like your primary home and retirement accounts may be protected from collection depending on your state.
Can the defendant garnish my wages for court costs?
Yes. Once the judge enters a judgment for costs, the defendant can ask the court to order your employer to send part of your paycheck to them. The amount varies by state and your income level. Your employer is required to comply with the garnishment order.
What is the difference between costs and attorney fees?
Costs are expenses paid to third parties — court filing fees, process servers, informed witnesses, and court reporters. Attorney fees are what lawyers charge for their time. You usually owe the defendant's costs but not their attorney fees, unless a law or contract says otherwise.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.