Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What a Shoulder Injury Settlement Looks Like Without Surgery

Shoulder injuries settle differently depending on whether you need an operation

A shoulder injury that heals without surgery typically settles for less than one requiring an operation, but the actual amount depends on what happened to you, how long recovery takes, and what you can no longer do. Insurance companies and courts look at your medical records, your lost wages, your out-of-pocket costs, and the gap between your life before and after the injury. There is no formula that works the same way for everyone.

If you did not have surgery, the insurer will want to see that you completed physical therapy, followed your doctor's restrictions, and reached a point where your shoulder either recovered or stopped improving. They will also look at whether you returned to work, whether you can do the same job you did before, and whether you have ongoing pain or weakness that affects your daily life. The settlement reflects all of that, not just the injury itself.

Key Takeaways

  • Non-surgical shoulder settlements depend on your actual recovery, lost income, medical costs, and whether you can return to your previous work or activities.
  • Insurance companies will request your complete medical records, physical therapy notes, imaging reports, and any wage loss documentation before making an offer.
  • The longer your recovery takes and the more permanent your limitations, the higher the settlement tends to be, even without surgery.
  • You should document everything: every therapy visit, every day you missed work, every activity you cannot do now that you could before the injury.
  • Many non-surgical shoulder cases settle within 6 to 18 months, though this varies based on how quickly you recover and whether the other party disputes liability.

What insurance companies look for in non-surgical shoulder cases

The insurer will ask for your medical records from the first emergency room visit or urgent care appointment through your last physical therapy session. They want to see the imaging—X-rays, MRI, ultrasound—that shows what was actually damaged. They want the doctor's notes describing your pain level, your range of motion, and what you were told you could and could not do. If you saw multiple doctors, they will want records from all of them.

They will also look at your physical therapy records in detail. How many sessions did you attend? Did you go consistently, or did you miss appointments? Did your therapist note improvement over time, or did you plateau? Did you follow the home exercise program, or did the notes say you were not compliant? Insurance adjusters use this to decide whether your injury was as serious as you claim and whether you did what you were supposed to do to recover.

If you returned to work, they will want to know when, whether it was full duty or restricted duty, and whether you had to take time off after that. If you did not return to work, they will want medical documentation explaining why. They will also look for any gaps in treatment—long stretches where you did not see a doctor or therapist—because they interpret those as signs that you were getting better or that the injury was not as disabling as claimed.

How lost wages and out-of-pocket costs affect your settlement

If you missed work while recovering, you can include those lost wages in your settlement. You will need pay stubs or a letter from your employer showing how much you earned before the injury and how much you lost. If you were paid hourly, the calculation is straightforward: hours missed times your hourly rate. If you were salaried, your employer can confirm the salary you lost during the time you could not work.

Out-of-pocket costs include what you paid for medical care that insurance did not cover—copays, deductibles, physical therapy sessions your plan did not fully cover, imaging that required out-of-network providers, or medications. Keep receipts and statements. You can also include mileage to and from medical appointments if you tracked it, though some insurers will only reimburse a portion of this.

If you paid for treatment that was not medically necessary but helped you recover—such as massage therapy, acupuncture, or a personal trainer to help you regain strength—the insurer may or may not include it, depending on your state and whether a doctor recommended it. Document everything anyway. The stronger your records, the easier it is to justify what you spent.

The difference between full recovery and permanent limitations

If your shoulder recovered completely and you returned to all your previous activities with no pain or weakness, your settlement will be lower than if you have ongoing problems. The insurer will look at your final medical records and your doctor's assessment: did they say you reached maximum medical improvement with a full recovery, or did they note residual symptoms?

Permanent limitations are worth more. If your doctor says you cannot lift more than 10 pounds, cannot reach overhead, cannot throw, or cannot do repetitive arm motions, that affects your ability to work and your quality of life. If your job requires heavy lifting or overhead work and you can no longer do it, that is a significant loss. If you had to change jobs or take a lower-paying position because of the injury, that loss of earning capacity is part of your settlement.

Pain that does not go away also increases settlement value. If you have chronic shoulder pain that flares up with certain activities, that is documented in your medical records and affects what you can do. The longer you have had the pain and the more it limits you, the more it is worth in a settlement.

When the other party disputes what happened

If the other party admits fault—they caused the accident, they were clearly negligent, there are witnesses—your settlement is usually faster and higher. If they dispute liability, meaning they argue that the accident was not their fault or that you were partly responsible, your case will take longer and the settlement may be lower.

In some states, you can recover even if you were partly at fault, but the amount is reduced by your percentage of responsibility. For example, if you were found 20 percent at fault and your case is worth $50,000, you would receive $40,000. In other states, if you are found more than 50 percent at fault, you cannot recover anything. Your state's rules matter here, and an attorney in your area can tell you how they explore to your situation.

If liability is disputed, the insurer will investigate more thoroughly. They may hire their own medical informed to review your records and argue that your injury was not as serious as you claim, or that you recovered faster than your medical records suggest. This is why documentation is critical: your own medical records and your own doctor's assessment carry more weight than the insurer's hired informed.

Timeline for settling a non-surgical shoulder case

Most non-surgical shoulder injuries settle between 6 and 18 months after the injury, though this varies widely. The timeline depends on how long you take to recover, whether you reach a point where your condition is unlikely to improve further, and how quickly the insurance company processes your claim.

You cannot settle until you have finished or nearly finished treatment, because the insurer needs to know what your permanent condition is. If you settle too early and then need more treatment, you may not be able to reopen the case. Your doctor will tell you when you have reached maximum medical improvement—the point where further treatment is unlikely to produce significant change. That is usually when settlement discussions begin.

If you hire an attorney, they will handle the settlement negotiation. If you are handling it yourself, you will send the insurer a demand letter that includes your medical records, your wage loss documentation, your out-of-pocket costs, and a dollar amount you are asking for. The insurer will make a counteroffer, and you will negotiate from there. This back-and-forth can take weeks or months.

What you should document right now

Start keeping a record of everything related to your injury. Write down the date of every doctor visit, physical therapy session, and any other medical appointment. Note what the doctor or therapist said about your progress, your pain level, and your restrictions. Take photos of any visible swelling or bruising early on.

Keep all receipts and statements for medical care, medications, and travel to appointments. If you missed work, get a written statement from your employer confirming the dates and the amount of pay you lost. If you had to reduce your hours or take a lower-paying job because of the injury, document that too.

Write down the activities you cannot do now that you could before the injury. Can you not lift your child? Cannot throw a ball? Cannot do your job? Cannot sleep on that side? These details matter when the insurer is deciding what your injury is worth. The more specific you are, the stronger your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my settlement cover future medical care if my shoulder gets worse?

Usually not. Once you settle, you give up the right to sue for that injury again. If your shoulder worsens years later, you generally cannot go back to the insurer for more money. This is why it is important not to settle until you know your permanent condition. Some settlements include a structured payment that continues over time, but this is rare and requires negotiation.

How much less is a non-surgical settlement compared to surgery?

There is no set percentage. A non-surgical case might settle for $10,000 to $100,000 or more, depending on your lost wages, medical costs, and permanent limitations. A surgical case might be worth significantly more, but only if the surgery was necessary and you have ongoing problems. The injury itself matters more than whether you had surgery.

Can I settle if I am still in physical therapy?

You can, but most insurers will not make a serious offer until you are close to finishing. If you settle while still in active treatment, you risk settling for too little if you need more therapy later. Talk to your doctor about when you might reach maximum medical improvement before you start settlement negotiations.

What if I cannot afford to wait for a settlement?

Some attorneys will advance you money against your future settlement, though this comes with fees and interest. You can also ask the insurer for an interim payment while your case is being evaluated, though they are not required to offer one. If you are in financial hardship, an attorney can discuss your options.

Does my settlement have to go through court?

No. Most settlements are negotiated between you and the insurer and finalized with a written agreement. You only go to court if you cannot reach an agreement and decide to file a lawsuit. Settlement is usually faster and more certain than going to trial.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.